| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Blue Panther | El Satanico* | Acapulco, Mexico | 12/18/91 |
| 2. | El Dandy | Negro Casas** | Mexico City, Mexico | 7/3/92 |
| 3. | Bestia Salvaje | El Dandy | Mexico City, Mexico | 9/4/92 |
| 4. | El Dandy | Bestia Salvaje | Naucalpan, Mexico | 12/16/92 |
| 5. | Emilio Charles Jr. | El Dandy | Acapulco, Mexico | 5/12/93 |
| 6. | El Dandy | Emilio Charles Jr. | Mexico City, Mexico | 10/5/93 |
| 7. | Javier Llanes | El Dandy | Mexico City, Mexico | 2/22/94 |
| 8. | Apolo Dantes | Javier Llanes | Mexico City, Mexico | 9/11/94 |
| 9. | El Satanico | Apolo Dantes | Guadalajara, Mexico | 11/27/94 |
| 10. | Ringo Mendoza | El Satanico | Mexico City, Mexico | 3/7/99 |
| 11. | Emilio Charles Jr. | Ringo Mendoza | Mexico City, Mexico | 3/18/01 |
| 12. | Negro Casas | Emilio Charles Jr. | Puebla, Mexico | 4/26/04 |
| 13. | Averno | Negro Casas | Mexico City, Mexico | 9/17/06 |
| 14. | El Hijo del Phantasma | Averno | Mexico City, Mexico | 7/21/09 |
| 15. | Negro Casas | El Hijo del Phantasma | Mexico City, Mexico | 2/14/10 |
| 16. | Jushin Liger | Negro Casas | Fukuoka, Japan | 5/3/10 |
| 17. | Dragon Rojo Jr. | Jushin Liger | Mexico City, Mexico | 11/18/11 |
| 18. | Angel de Oro | Dragon Rojo Jr. | Mexico City, Mexico | 3/25/17 |
| 19. | El Cuatrero | Angel de Oro | Tokyo, Japan | 1/19/18 |
*This was the finals of a tournament to crown the first champion.
**The title was vacated when Panther jumped to AAA. This was the finals of a tournament to crown a new champion.