| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Wifebeater | Nick Mondo* | Dover, DE | 8/28/02 |
| 2. | Nate Hatred | Nick Mondo and John Zandig** | Philadelphia, PA | 1/18/03 |
| 3. | Nick Gage | Nate Hatred and The Messiah*** | Philadelphia, PA | 6/14/03 |
| 4. | Nate Hatred | Nick Gage | Philadelphia, PA | 8/9/03 |
*This was the finals of the Tournament of Death to crown the first champion.
**The title was vacated when Wifebeater retired. This was a three-way match to determine the new champion.
***This was a three-way match.