| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | The Sensational One | N/A*(1) | Mantua, NJ | 2/19/99 |
| 2. | Quicksilver | The Sensational One | Mantua, NJ | 2/19/99 |
| 3. | The Sensational One | Quicksilver | Mantua, NJ | 3/27/99 |
| 4. | Justice Pain | The Sensational One | Mantua, NJ | 4/3/99 |
| 5. | Ric Blade | Justice Pain | Mantua, NJ | 7/19/99 |
| 6. | Justice Pain | Ric Blade | Sewell, NJ | 4/8/00 |
| 7. | Trent Acid | Justice Pain | Paulsboro, NJ | 6/9/00 |
| 8. | Winger | Trent Acid | Tokyo, Japan | 7/1/00 |
| 9. | Men's Teioh | Winger | Tokyo, Japan | 9/15/00 |
| 10. | Jun Kasai | Men's Teioh | Sapporo, Japan | 5/4/01 |
| 11. | Trent Acid | Jun Kasai | Yokohama, Japan | 8/19/01 |
| 12. | Ruckus | Trent Acid and Winger*(2) | Yokohama, Japan | 12/2/01 |
| 13. | Trent Acid | Ruckus | Philadelphia, PA | 12/15/01 |
| 14. | Ruckus | Trent Acid | Philadelphia, PA | 1/18/03 |
| 15. | Sonjay Dutt | Ruckus | Philadelphia, PA | 12/13/03 |
| 16. | Alex Shelley | Sonjay Dutt | Philadelphia, PA | 1/8/05 |
| 17. | Mike Quackenbush | Alex Shelley | Philadelphia, PA | 2/5/05 |
| 18. | Sabian | Mike Quackenbush | Philadelphia, PA | 4/2/05 |
| 19. | Mike Quackenbush | Sabian | Philadelphia, PA | 6/11/05 |
| 20. | Derek Frazier | Mike Quackenbush | Philadelphia, PA | 9/10/05 |
| 21. | Niles Young | Derek Frazier, Cheech, Cloudy, Sabian and The Heretic*(3) | Philadelphia, PA | 3/11/06 |
| 22. | Sexxxy Eddy | Niles Young | Philadelphia, PA | 7/8/06 |
| 23. | Sonjay Dutt | Sexxxy Eddy | Philadelphia, PA | 9/9/06 |
| 24. | Jigsaw | Sonjay Dutt | Philadelpia, PA | 9/9/06 |
| 25. | Scotty Vortekz | Jigsaw | Philadelphia, PA | 4/7/07 |
| 26. | Danny Havoc | Scotty Vortekz, DieHard, Joker and Drake Younger*(4) | Philadelphia, PA | 9/8/07 |
| 27. | Sabian | Danny Havoc | Philadelphia, PA | 10/13/07 |
| 28. | Chuck Taylor | Sabian | Philadelphia, PA | 5/10/08 |
| 29. | Ryan McBride | Pinkie Sanchez, Carter Gray, Egotistico Fantastico and Dan Paysan*(5) | Philadelphia, PA | 12/13/08 |
| 30. | Egotistico Fantastico | Ryan McBride | Philadelphia, PA | 5/9/09 |
| 31. | Drew Blood | Egotistico Fantastico | Philadelpia, PA | 9/12/09 |
| 32. | Greg Excellent | Drew Blood | Philadelphia, PA | 12/12/09 |
| 33. | Sabian | Greg Excellent | Philadelphia, PA | 2/13/10 |
| 34. | Adam Cole | Sabian | Philadelphia, PA | 5/8/10 |
| 35. | Sami Callihan | Adam Cole | Philadelphia, PA | 11/12/11 |
| 36. | Drake Younger | Sami Callihan | Bloomington, IN | 5/5/12 |
| 37. | Sami Callihan | Drake Younger | Voorhees Township, NJ | 7/14/12 |
| 38. | AR Fox | Sami Callihan | Voorhees Township, NJ | 7/14/12 |
| 39. | Alexander James | N/A*(6) | Voorhees, NJ | 8/23/14 |
| 40. | Greg Excellent | Alexander James | Voorhees, NJ | 3/14/15 |
*(1)The Sensational One was recognized as the first champion.
*(2)Due to a double pinfall, the title was vacated. This was a three way match to determine a new champion.
*(3)This was a Six Man Ladder Match.
*(4)This was a Five Man Ladder Match.
*(5)Taylor was stripped of the title for unknown reasons. This was a TLC Match to determine a new champion.
*(6)The title was unified with the CZW Wired Television Title on September 8, 2012 when Fox defeated Television Champion Dave Crist in a Ladder Match. Two years later, the belt was brought back and awarded to James.