| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | JC Bailey | Necro Butcher* | Philadelphia, PA | 2/5/05 |
| 2. | Zandig | JC Bailey | Unknown Location | 7/05 |
| 3. | Necro Butcher | Zandig** | New Castle, DE | 7/30/05 |
| 4. | JC Bailey | Necro Butcher | Philadelphia, PA | 8/13/05 |
| 5. | Nick Gage | Necro Butcher and JC Bailey*** | Philadelphia, PA | 1/14/06 |
| 6. | Drake Younger | Nick Gage | Middletown, DE | 10/15/06 |
| 7. | Brain Damage | Philadelphia, PA | 5/12/07 | |
| 8. | Brain Damage | Scotty Vortekz, Danny Havoc and JC Bailey**** | Smyma, DE | 9/15/07 |
| 9. | Drake Younger | Brain Damage | Philadelphia, PA | 2/9/08 |
| 10. | Danny Havoc | Drake Younger | Philadelphia, PA | 10/11/08 |
| 11. | Sami Callihan | Danny Havoc | Townsend, DE | 10/25/09 |
| 12. | Thumbtack Jack | Sami Callihan | Townsend, DE | 10/25/99 |
| 13. | Adam Polak | Thumbtack Jack | Oberhausen, Germany | 1/17/10 |
| 14. | Nick Gage | Adam Polak | Oberhausen, Germany | 11/7/10 |
| 15. | Yuko Miyamoto | Nick Gage | Philadelphia, PA | 12/11/10 |
| 16. | Jun Kasai | Yuko Miyamoto | Tokyo, Japan | 3/22/11 |
| 17. | Danny Havoc | Jun Kasai | Philadelphia, PA | 4/9/11 |
| 18. | Masada*(5) | Danny Havoc | Philadelphia, PA | 6/9/11 |
*(1)This was a match to determine the first champion.
*(2)Zandig gave the title to Necro after Necro beat him in the Tournament of Death.
*(3)This was a Three-Way Match.
*(4)The title was vacated due to a double pinfall in a match between Damage and Younger. This was a Four Corners Elimination Match to determine a new champion.
*(5)Masada went on to win the World Title in a Unification Match, and the UU Title was merged into the World Title.
*(5)