| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Tyler Veritas | Adam Cole* | Philadelphia, PA | 12/12/09 |
| 2. | Drew Gulak | Tyler Veritas | Philadelphia, PA | 4/10/10 |
| 3. | AR Fox | Drew Gulak | Philadelphia, PA | 6/13/10 |
| 4. | Jake Crist | AR Fox | Philadelphia, PA | 7/9/11 |
| 5. | Dave Crist | Jake Crist | Voorhees, NJ | 4/14/12 |
| 6. | AR Fox | Dave Crist | Voorhees, NJ | 9/8/12 |
| 7. | Alex Colon | AR Fox | Voorhees, NJ | 9/14/13 |
| 8. | Devon Moore | Alex Colon | Voorhees, NJ | 1/11/14 |
| 9. | Shane Strickland | Devon Moore | Voorhees, NJ | 3/8/14 |
| 10. | Joe Gacy | Shane Strickland | Blackwood, NJ | 7/30/14 |
| 11. | Shane Strickland | Joe Gacy | Blackwood, NJ | 8/13/14 |
| 12. | Joe Gacy | Shane Strickland | Voorhees, NJ | 12/13/14 |
| 13. | Frankie Pickard | Joe Gacy | Blackwood, NJ | 7/1/15 |
| 14. | Joe Gacy | Frankie Pickard | Blackwood, NJ | 7/8/15 |
| 15. | Tim Donst | Joe Gacy | Philadelphia, PA | 7/11/15 |
| 16. | Joey Janela | Tim Donst | Voorhees, NJ | 10/10/15 |
| 17. | Lio Rush | Joey Janela | Voorhees, NJ | 12/12/15 |
| 18. | Joey Janela | Lio Rush | Voorhees, NJ | 2/13/16 |
| 19. | Lio Rush | Joey Janela | Voorhees, NJ | 3/26/16 |
| 20. | Joey Janela | Lio Rush | Voorhees, NJ | 9/10/16 |
| 21. | YUMA | Joey Janela | Port Huemene, CA | 3/26/17 |
| 22. | Maxwell Jacob Friedman | YUMA | Voorhees, NJ | 5/13/17 |
| 23. | Zachary Wentz | Alex Reynolds, John Silver and Wheeler Yuta** | Voorhees, NJ | 5/12/18 |
| 24. | Ace Austin | Zachary Wentz and Alex Colon*** | Dayton, OH | 9/7/18 |
| 25. | Blackwater | Ace Austin, Jordan Oliver and KC Navarro**** | Voorhees, NJ | 9/8/18 |
| 26. | Jordan Oliver | Blackwater | Voorhees, NJ | 10/13/18 |
*This was a match to determine the first champion.
**This was a Four-Way Match.
***This was a Three-Way Match.
****This was a Four-Way Match.