| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | AR Fox | Sami Callihan* | Secaucus, NJ | 4/5/13 |
| 2. | Chris Hero | AR Fox | Brooklyn, NY | 2/23/14 |
| 3. | Drew Galloway | Chris Hero | Ybor City, FL | 8/7/14 |
| 4. | Timothy Thatcher | Drew Galloway | Tampa, FL | 7/10/15 |
| 5. | Zack Sabre Jr. | Timothy Thatcher | Queens, NY | 2/25/17 |
| 6. | Matt Riddle | Zack Sabre Jr. | Kenner, LA | 4/5/18 |
| 7. | Shane Strickland | Matt Riddle | Philadelphia, PA | 8/4/18 |
| 8. | Fabian Aichner | Shane Strickland | Ybor City, FL | 10/28/18 |
| 9. | Austin Theory | Fabian Aichner | Queens, NY | 12/15/18 |
*This was the finals of a tournament to crown the first champion.
Title Defenses:
1. AR Fox
---pinned Nick Jackson, EVOLVE 20: 5/30/13
---pinned Lince Dorado, EVOLVE 22: 6/2/13
---pinned Anthony Nese, EVOLVE 23: 9/21/13
---pinned Davey Richards, EVOLVE 25: 1/10/14
2. Chris Hero
---pinned Trent?, EVOLVE 28: 4/3/14
---beat Tony Nese and AR Fox in a 20 Minute Sprint, 2014 - A Wrestling Odyssey: 4/4/14
3. Drew Galloway
---pinned Tony Nese, EVOLVE 32: 8/9/14
---pinned Rich Swann, EVOLVE 34: 9/13/14
---pinned Ricochet, EVOLVE 37: 1/10/15
---pinned PJ Black, EVOLVE 39: 3/26/15
4. Timothy Thatcher
---no contest against Matt Riddle, EVOLVE 58: 4/1/16
---pinned Sami Callihan, WWN Mercury Rising: 4/2/16
---beat Matt Riddle in a No Holds Barred Match, EVOLVE 66: 8/19/16
---pinned Drew Gulak, EVOLVE 67: 8/20/16