| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Harry Smith | won battle royale* | Tampa, FL | 6/26/07 |
| 2. | Afa Jr. | Harry Smith | New Port Richey, FL | 10/16/07 |
| 3. | TJ Wilson | Afa Jr. | New Port Richey, FL | 12/1/07 |
| 4. | Ted DiBiase Jr. | TJ Wilson | New Port Richey, FL | 12/18/07 |
| 5. | Heath Miller | N/A** | New Port Richey, FL | 1/19/08 |
| 6. | Jake Hager | Heath Miller | New Port Richey, FL | 3/22/08 |
*A battle royale was held to determine the first champion.
**Miller was awarded the title when DiBiase could not defend it due to injury.