| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Eddie Colon & Eric Perez (The Puerto Rican Nightmares) | Heath Miller & Steve Lewington* | Port Richey, FL | 2/23/08 |
| 2. | Brad Allen & Nic Nemeth | The Puerto Rican Nightmares | Port Richey, FL | 3/23/08 |
| 3. | The Puerto Rican Nightmares | Brad Allen & Nic Nemeth | Port Richey, FL | 4/15/08 |
| 4. | Drew McIntyre & Stu Sanders (The Empire) | The Puerto Rican Nightmares | Port Richey, FL | 5/6/08 |
| 5. | Gabe Tuft & Joe Hennig | The Empire | Port Richey, FL | 7/12/08 |
| 6. | The Empire | Gabe Tuft & Joe Hennig | Port Richey, FL | 7/15/08 |
| 7. | The Puerto Rican Nightmares | The Empire | Tampa, FL | 7/17/08 |
| 8. | Gavin Spears & Nic Nemeth | The Puerto Rican Nightmares and Scotty Goldman & Kafu*(2) | New Port Richey, FL | 8/16/08 |
| 9. | Heath Miller & Joe Hennig | Gavin Spears & Nic Nemeth | Tampa, FL | 9/11/08 |
| 10. | DH Smith & TJ Wilson (The New Hart Foundation) | Heath Miller & Joe Hennig | Tampa, FL | 10/30/08 |
| 11. | Johnny Curtis & Tyler Reks | The New Hart Foundation | Tampa, FL | 12/11/08 |
| 12. | Caylen Croft & Trent Baretta (The Dude Busters) | Johnny Curtis & Tyler Reks | Tampa, FL | 4/30/09 |
| 13. | Justin Angel & Kris Logan | The Dude Busters | Tampa, FL | 7/23/09 |
| 14. | Bo & Duke Rotundo | Justin Angel & Kris Logan | Tampa, FL | 7/23/09 |
| 15. | Curt Hawkins & Caylen Croft (The Dude Busters) | Bo & Duke Rotundo | Tampa, FL | 11/19/09 |
| 16. | Joe Hennig & Brett DiBiase (The Fortunate Sons) | The Dude Busters | Tampa, FL | 1/14/10 |
| 17. | Jimmy & Jey Uso | The Fortunate Sons | Crystal River, FL | 3/13/10 |
| 18. | Epico & Hunico (Los Aviadores) | Jimmy & Jey Uso | Tampa, FL | 6/3/10 |
| 19. | Michael McGillicutty & Kaval | Los Aviadores | Tampa, FL | 7/15/10 |
| 20. | Los Aviadores | Michael McGillicutty & Kaval | Sebring, FL | 7/16/10 |
| 21. | Derrick Bateman & Johnny Curtis | Los Aviadores and Brodus Clay & Donny Marlow*(3) | Tampa, FL | 8/12/10 |
| 22. | Wes Brisco & Xavier Woods | Derrick Bateman & Johnny Curtis | Tampa, FL | 11/4/10 |
| 23. | Damien Sandow & Titus O'Neil | Xavier Woods & Mason Ryan*(4) | Plant City, FL | 12/3/10 |
| 24. | Richie Steamboat & Seth Rollins | Damien Sandow & Titus O'Neil | Miami, FL | 3/25/11 |
| 25. | Calvin Raines & Big E. Langston | Richie Steamboat & Seth Rollins | Tampa, FL | 5/12/11 |
| 26. | CJ Parker & Donnie Marlow | Calvin Raines & Big E. Langston | Tampa, FL | 7/21/11 |
| 27. | Brad Maddox & Briley Pierce | CJ Parker & Donnie Marlow | Tampa, FL | 11/3/11 |
| 28. | Bo Rotundo & Husky Harris | Brad Maddox & Eli Cottonwood*(5) | Tampa, FL | 2/2/12 |
| 29. | Corey Graves & Jake Carter | Bo Rotundo & Husky Harris | Tampa, FL | 3/15/12 |
| 30. | Mike Dalton & Leakee | Corey Graves & Jake Carter | Palatka, FL | 6/15/12 |
| 31. | CJ Parker & Jason Jordan | Mike Dalton & Leakee | Punta Gorda, FL | 7/13/12 |
| 32. | Rick Victor & Brad Maddox | CJ Parker & Jason Jordan | Melbourne, FL | 7/28/12 |
*This was the finals of a tournament to crown the first champions.
*(2)This was a Three-Way Match.
*(3)This was a Three-Way Match.
*(4)Brisco was sidelined with an injury and the titles were vacated. This match determined the new champions.
*(5)The titles were vacated after Pierce was injured. This match determined the new champions.