| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Jake Hager | Ted DiBiase Jr.* | Tampa, FL | 2/15/08 |
| 2. | Sheamus O'Shaunessy | Jake Hager | Tampa, FL | 9/18/08 |
| 3. | Eric Escobar | Sheamus O'Shaunessy | Tampa, FL | 12/11/08 |
| 4. | Joe Hennig | Eric Escobar | Tampa, FL | 2/26/09 |
| 5. | Drew McIntyre | Eric Escobar*(2) | Tampa, FL | 3/19/09 |
| 6. | Tyler Reks | Drew McIntyre | Tampa, FL | 6/11/09 |
| 7. | Heath Miller | Tyler Reks | Tampa, FL | 8/13/09 |
| 8. | Justin Angel | Heath Miller | Tampa, FL | 9/24/09 |
| 9. | Alex Riley | Justin Angel and Wade Barrett*(3) | Tampa, FL | 3/18/10 |
| 10. | Mason Ryan | Alex Riley and Johnny Curtis*(4) | Tampa, FL | 7/22/10 |
| 11. | Bo Rotundo | Mason Ryan | Tampa, FL | 2/3/11 |
| 12. | Lucky Cannon | Bo Rotundo | Tampa, FL | 2/3/11 |
| 13. | Bo Rotundo | Lucky Cannon | Tampa, FL | 5/19/11 |
| 14. | Leo Kruger | Dean Ambrose, Husky Harris and Damien Sandow*(5) | Tampa, FL | 9/1/11 |
| 15. | Mike Dalton | Leo Kruger | Tampa, FL | 2/2/12 |
| 16. | Leo Kruger | Mike Dalton | Tampa, FL | 2/23/12 |
| 17. | Seth Rollins | Leo Kruger | Tampa, FL | 2/23/12 |
| 18. | Rick Victor | Seth Rollins | Crystal River, FL | 6/16/12 |
| 19. | Bo Rotundo | Rick Victor | Crystal River, FL | 6/16/12 |
| 20. | Rick Victor | Bo Rotundo | Punta Gorda, FL | 7/13/12 |
| 21. | Richie Steamboat | Rick Victor | St. Augustine, FL | 7/20/12 |
*These were the last two men in a battle royale to determine the first champion.
*(2)Hennig was stripped of the title due to injury. This match determined the new champion.
*(3)This was a Three-Way Match.
*(4)This was a Three-Way Match.
*(5)Rotundo was stripped of the title due to injury. This was a Fatal Four Way Match to determine a new champion.