| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Jimmy Rave & Eddie Vegas (DP Associates) | Roderick Strong & Jerelle Clark and CM Punk & Don Juan* | Brandon, FL | 4/22/05 |
| 2. | Spanky & Sal Rinauro | DP Associates | Bushnell, FL | 8/6/05 |
| 3. | Fabulous Phil & Superstar Sean (The Heartbreak Express) | Spanky & Sal Rinauro | Arcadia, FL | 9/2/05 |
| 4. | Sean Murphy & Joey Machete (Black Market) | The Heartbreak Express | Crystal River, FL | 5/27/06 |
| 5. | The Heartbreak Express | Black Market** | Crystal River, FL | 9/9/06 |
| 6. | Jay & Mark Briscoe | The Heartbreak Express | Bushnell, FL | 10/14/06 |
| 7. | Kenny King & Jason Blade (The YRR) | Jay & Mark Briscoe | Crystal River, FL | 11/9/07 |
| 8. | Roderick Strong & Erick Stevens | The YRR | Crystal River, FL | 12/20/08 |
| 9. | Christopher Gray & Tommy Taylor (The British Lions) | Roderick Strong & Erick Stevens | Crystal River, FL | 10/3/09 |
| 10. | Jon Davis & Kory Chavis (The Dark City Fight Club) | The British Lions | Crystal River, FL | 7/31/10 |
| 11. | Caleb Konley & Scott Reed (The Scene) | The Dark City Fight Club | Brooksville, FL | 10/28/11 |
| 12. | Eddie Rios & Jay Cruz (Dos Ben Dejos) | The Scene | Ybor City, FL | 2/1/13 |
| 13. | Harlem & Lance Bravado | Dos Ben Dejos and Sugar Dunkerton & Aaron Epic (The KOA)*** | Ybor City, FL | 7/5/13 |
| 14. | Rich Swann & Roderick Strong | Harlem & Lance Bravado | Ybor City, FL | 12/6/13 |
| 15. | David Starr & JT Dunn (Juicy Product) | Rich Swann & Roderick Strong | Ybor City, FL | 5/2/14 |
| 16. | Eddie Graves & Teddy Stigma (Savages) | Juicy Product, Dos Ben Dejos and Evan Gelistico & Pierre Abernathy (The Submission Squad)**** | Winter Park, FL | 1/10/15 |
| 17. | Devin & Mason Cutter (The Hooligans) | Savages | Ybor City, FL | 8/7/15 |
| 18. | Odinson & Parrow (The End) | The Hooligans | Ybor City, FL | 2/2/18 |
| 19. | Chance Auren & Omar Amir (The Precipice) | The End | Ybor City, FL | 3/3/19 |
*This was a tournament final to crown the first tag champs.
**This was a mixed six-person tag also involving Lacey and Allison Danger.
***This was a Three Way Match.
****This was a Four Corners Match.
Title Defenses:
1. DP Associates
---pinned Roderick Strong & Jerelle Clark, Payback: 6/25/05
2. Sal Rinauro & Spanky
---pinned Jimmy Rave & Jay Lethal, Big Year One Bash - Night 1: 9/2/05
3. The Heartbreak Express
---pinned Evan Starsmore & Jaison Moore, Big Year One Bash - Night 2: 9/3/05
---pinned Dunn & Marcos, X Factor: 10/7/05
---lost to Colt Cabana & Sal Rinauro by DQ, Fallout: 10/8/05
---pinned Sal Rinauro & Davey Andrews, Strength in Numbers: 11/11/05
---pinned Adam Pearce & Azrieal, Florida Rumble 2005: 12/9/05
---beat Colt Cabana & Sal Rinauro in a No DQ Match, New Year's Classic 2006: 1/6/06
---lost to Chasyn Rance & Seth Delay by DQ, Orlando Onslaught: 1/20/06
---pinned Chasyn Rance & Seth Delay: 2/16/06
---pinned Jerelle Clark & Jay Fury: 3/3/06
---lost to Scott Commodity & Preston James by DQ: 3/11/06
---pinned Chasyn Rance & Seth Delay: 3/18/06
---lost to Sean Murphy & Joey Machete by DQ: 4/15/06
4. Black Market
---beat Sean & Phil Davis by DQ, Chasing the Dragon: 6/9/06
---beat Sean & Phil Davis in an Anything Goes Match, Heatstroke - Night 1: 7/7/06
---beat Sean & Phil Davis in a Double Chain Match, Heatstroke - Night 2: 7/8/06
---pinned Colt Cabana & Sal Rinauro, Second Year Spectacular - Night 1: 9/8/06
5. The Heartbreak Express
---N/A
6. The Briscoes
---beat Sean Murphy & Joey Machete and Sean & Phil Davis in a Three Way Elimination Match, All or Nothing: 11/10/06
---no contest against Necro Butcher & Mad Man Pondo in an Anything Goes Match, In Full Force: 2/3/07
---beat Necro Butcher & Mad Man Pondo in a Bar Room Brawl, International Impact - Phase 2: 4/21/07
---pinned Tyler Black & Marek Brave, Melbourne Meltdown: 5/26/07
---pinned Jake & Dave Crist, Heatstroke '07 - Night 1: 8/17/07
---pinned Tyler Black & Trik Davis, Heatstroke '07 - Night 2: 8/18/07
7. The YRR
---pinned Robert Anthony & Shawn Osborne, Redefined: 2/16/08
---pinned Jay & Mark Briscoe, Dangerous Intentions: 4/26/08
---pinned Jimmy Jacobs & Tyler Black, In Full Force: 5/30/08
---beat Jimmy Jacobs & Tyler Black in a Two out of Three Falls Match, Hot Summer Nights: 7/19/08
---pinned Jay & Mark Briscoe, Fallout: 10/11/08
8. Roderick Strong & Erick Stevens
---pinned Sal Rinauro & Chasyn Rance: 3/28/09
---pinned Tommy Taylor & Chris Gray, Unfinished Business: 5/2/09
---submitted Tommy Taylor & Chris Gray, Heatstroke: 8/1/09
9. The British Lions
---pinned Nooie Lee & Jerrelle Clark, Southern Stampede: 4/17/10
---beat Jon Davis & Kory Chavis and Jake & Dave Crist in a Triple Threat Match: 6/26/10
10. The Dark City Fight Club
---N/A
11. The Scene
---N/A
12. Dos Ben Dejos
---pinned Caleb Konley & Scott Reed, Establish Dominance: 3/15/13
---pinned Sugar Dunkerton & Aaron Epic, Ascension: 4/26/13
13. The Bravado Brothers
---pinned Eddie Rios & Jay Cruz, Dangerous Intentions: 10/11/13
---lost to Eddie Rios & Jay Cruz by DQ, With Malice: 10/12/13
14. Rich Swann & Roderick Strong
---pinned Caleb Konley & Andrew Everett, Violence is the Answer: 12/7/13
15. Juicy Product
---beat Gran Akuma & Tim Donst, John Skyler & Trevor Lee and Jason Cade & Aaron Solow in a Four Way Elimination Match, Accelerate: 5/3/14
---pinned Eddie Graves & Teddy Stigma, Heatstroke: 8/9/14
---pinned Eddie Rios & Jay Cruz, EVOLVE 33: 8/10/14
16. Savages