| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Homicide | CM Punk* | Tampa, FL | 9/25/04 |
| 2. | Bryan Danielson | Homicide and Roderick Strong*(2) | Philadelphia, PA | 1/14/06 |
| 3. | Roderick Strong | Bryan Danielson | Inverness, FL | 11/10/06 |
| 4. | Erick Stevens | Roderick Strong | New York, NY | 12/30/07 |
| 5. | Roderick Strong | Erick Stevens | Crystal River, FL | 2/16/08 |
| 6. | Erick Stevens | Roderick Strong | Crystal River, FL | 7/19/08 |
| 7. | Go Shiozaki | Erick Stevens | Crystal River, FL | 8/23/08 |
| 8. | Tyler Black | Go Shiozaki | Crystal River, FL | 12/20/08 |
| 9. | Davey Richards | N/A*(3) | Crystal River, FL | 5/2/09 |
| 10. | Masaaki Mochizuki | Davey Richards | Sapporo, Japan | 12/6/09 |
| 11. | Davey Richards | Masaaki Mochizuki | Chicago, IL | 1/23/10 |
| 12. | Jon Moxley | Roderick Strong*(4) | Crystal River, FL | 4/17/10 |
| 13. | Jon Davis | AR Fox*(5) | Ybor City, FL | 2/1/13 |
| 14. | Trent Baretta | Jon Davis | Ybor City, FL | 8/9/13 |
| 15. | Rich Swann | Trent Baretta | Emeishan City, China | 11/14/14 |
| 16. | Roderick Strong | Trent Baretta*(6) | Tampa, FL | 2/20/15 |
| 17. | Rich Swann | Roderick Strong | Orlando, FL | 4/18/15 |
| 18. | Caleb Konley | Rich Swann | Tampa, FL | 7/3/15 |
| 19. | Fred Yehi | Caleb Konley | Orlando, FL | 5/27/16 |
| 20. | Austin Theory | Fred Yehi | Melrose, MA | 12/10/17 |
| 21. | Anthony Henry | Austin Theory | Ybor City, FL | 9/30/18 |
*This was the final of a tournament to crown the first FIP Champion.
*(2)This was a Three Way Dance.
*(3)Richards was awarded the belt by forfeit when Black couldn't make his title defense.
*(4)Richards was stripped of the belt when he left the promotion. Moxley won a 12-Man Southern Stampede Rumble Match to become the new champion.
*(5)The title was vacated when the promotion became inactive. On the return show, this match determined a new champion.
*(6)Swann was unable to defend the title due to an injury. This was a No DQ Match to determine the new champion.
Title Defenses
1. Homicide
---pinned BJ Whitmer, Fallout - Part 1: 11/12/04
---beat CM Punk in a Falls Count Anywhere Match, Fallout - Night 2: 11/13/04
---submitted Spanky, Florida Rumble 2004: 12/17/04
---pinned James Gibson, New Year's Classic 2005: 1/7/05
---pinned Rocky Romero, Dangerous Intentions: 2/12/05
---pinned Antonio Banks, ROH Do or Die IV: 2/19/05
---beat CM Punk in an Anything Goes Match, Violence is the Answer: 4/23/05
---pinned Colt Cabana, In Full Force: 5/27/05
---pinned Azrieal, Unstoppable: 5/28/05
---submitted Steve Madison, Heatstroke - Night 1: 8/5/05
---pinned Tony Mamaluke, Heatstroke - Night 2: 8/6/05
---pinned Nigel McGuinness, Big Year One Bash - Night 1: 9/2/05
---pinned Jimmy Rave, Big Year One Bash - Night 2: 9/3/05
---no contest against Austin Aries, X Factor: 10/7/05
---pinned Rainman, Fallout: 10/8/05
---pinned Jimmy Rave, Florida Rumble 2005: 12/9/05
2. Bryan Danielson
---pinned Matt Sydal: 2/17/06
---pinned Roderick Strong: 3/17/06
---pinned Tony Mamaluke: 3/18/06
---pinned Jay Fury: 4/8/06
---pinned Jay Lethal: 5/27/06
---pinned Sal Rinauro, Chasing the Dragon: 6/9/06
---pinned Colt Cabana, Heatstroke - Night 1: 7/7/06
---pinned Davey Richards, Southern Justice: 10/14/06
3. Roderick Strong
---submitted Steve Madison, Cage of Pain: 12/15/06
---pinned Hallowicked, Florida Rumble 2006: 12/16/06
---beat Davey Richards by CO, ROH International Challenge: 12/22/06
---pinned Brent Albright, Unfinished Business: 1/13/07
---beat Davey Richards in an I Quit Match, Dangerous Intentions: 2/2/07
---beat Davey Richards in a Two out of Three Falls Match, In Full Force: 2/3/07
---beat Delirious by CO, ROH Fifth Year Festival - Philly: 2/17/07
---pinned Pac, ROH Fifth Year Festival - Liverpool: 3/3/07
---beat Austin Aries by ref stoppage, ROH Supercard of Honor II: 3/31/07
---pinned Yamato, International Impact - Phase 1: 4/20/07
---pinned Sal Rinauro, International Impact - Phase 2: 4/21/07
---beat Christopher Daniels by CO, ROH The Battle of St. Paul: 4/27/07
---pinned Kenny King, Southern Stampede: 4/29/07
---beat Necro Butcher in a No Holds Barred Match, Stronger Than Ever: 5/25/07
---pinned Jimmy Rave, Melbourne Meltdown: 5/26/07
---pinned Aaron Eagle, PCW Uncut Shock Treatment: 6/1/07
---beat Jimmy Rave in an Anything Goes Match, Hot Summer Nights - Night 1: 6/29/07
---pinned Eddie Kingston, Hot Summer Nights - Night 2: 6/30/07
---beat the Masked Fipper #16, the Masked Sparkler and Chasyn Rance, SHIMMER Volume 14 - SPARKLE Pre-show: 7/1/07
---beat Austin Aries, Gran Akuma and Jimmy Rave in a Four Way Fray, ROH Race to the Top Tournament - Night 1: 7/27/07
---pinned Tyler Black, Heatstroke '07 - Night 1: 8/17/07
---pinned Delirious, Heatstroke '07 - Night 2: 8/18/07
---pinned Larry Sweeney, Cage of Pain II: 9/29/07
---pinned Claudio Castagnoli, ROH Chaos at the Cow Palace: 10/21/07
---beat Claudio Castagnoli in a Two out of Three Falls Match, Unstoppable: 11/9/07
---beat Erick Stevens and Ray Beez in a Three Way Match, PWR Reload: 11/16/07
4. Erick Stevens
---pinned Austin Aries, ROH Proving Ground: 1/11/08
---pinned Bryan Danielson, ROH Transform: 1/12/08
---pinned Ray Beez, PWR Uncontrollable: 1/19/08
---beat Davey Richards and Austin Aries in a Three Way Match, ROH Breakout: 1/25/08
5. Roderick Strong
---beat Erick Stevens and Necro Butcher in a Three Way Match, ROH Sixth Anniversary Show: 2/23/08
---beat Austin Aries by CO, Unfinished Business: 3/22/08
---beat Erick Stevens in a Last Man Standing Match, Dangerous Intentions: 4/26/08
---beat Go Shiozaki and Erick Stevens in a Three Way Match, ROH A New Level: 5/10/08
---beat Austin Aries and Jerry Lynn in a Three Way Dance, In Full Force: 5/30/08
---beat Erick Stevens in a Fight Without Honor, ROH Respect is Earned II: 6/7/08
6. Erick Stevens
---beat Claudio Castagnoli by DQ, ROH Age of Insanity: 8/15/08
---pinned Chris Hero, ROH Night of the Butcher II: 8/16/08
7. Go Shiozaki
---pinned Kevin Steen, ROH Glory By Honor VII: 9/20/08
---pinned Roderick Strong, Fallout: 10/11/08
---pinned Austin Aries, ROH Return of the 187: 10/24/08
---no contest against Necro Butcher, ROH Ring of Homicide 2: 10/25/08
---lost by DQ to Erick Stevens and Roderick Strong in a Three Way Match, Melbourne Meltdown II: 12/19/08
8. Tyler Black
---pinned Delirious, Eddie Graham Memorial Battle of the Belts: 2/8/09
9. Davey Richards
---pinned Kenny King, Unfinished Business: 5/2/09
---pinned Brad Attitude, Hot Summer Nights: 6/6/09
---pinned Kenny King, Heatstroke: 8/1/09
---beat Kenny King in a Steel Cage Match, Fallout: 10/3/09
10. Masaaki Mochizuki
---N/A
11. Davey Richards
---N/A
12. Jon Moxley
---pinned Bruce Santee, Cage of Pain III: 7/31/10
13. Jon Davis
---pinned Samuray Del Sol, Establish Dominance: 3/15/13
---pinned Homicide, Ascension: 4/26/13
---lost to Trent Baretta by DQ, Declaration of Independence: 7/5/13
14. Trent Baretta
---pinned Rich Swann, Dangerous Intentions: 10/11/13
---pinned Lince Dorado, In Full Force: 12/6/13
---pinned Tony Nese, EVOLVE 25: 1/10/14
---pinned Lince Dorado, 2014 - A Wrestling Odyssey: 4/4/14
---pinned Trevor Lee, Establish Dominance: 5/2/14
---beat Roderick Strong by DQ, Accelerate: 5/3/14
15. Rich Swann
---beat Roderick Strong by DQ, Everything Burns: 1/10/15
16. Roderick Strong
---N/A
17. Rich Swann
---N/A
18. Caleb Konley
---beat Maxwell Chicago, Gary Jay and Jason Cade in a Four Way Match, WWN Mercury Rising: 4/2/16