| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Taz | N/A* | Queens, NY | 5/14/98 |
| 2. | Sabu | Taz | Philadelphia, PA | 12/19/98 |
| 3. | Taz** | Sabu | Asbury Park, NJ | 3/21/99 |
| 4. | Brian Cage | N/A*** | Jacksonville, FL | 7/2/20 |
| 5. | Ricky Starks | Brian Cage | Cedar Park, TX | 7/14/21 |
| 6. | Hook | Ricky Starks | Worcester, MA | 7/27/22 |
| 7. | Jack Perry | Hook | Boston, MA | 7/19/23 |
| 8. | Hook | Jack Perry | London, England | 8/27/23 |
| 9. | Chris Jericho | Hook | St. Louis, MO | 4/21/24 |
*Taz introduced his own title in ECW as a result of the injured World Champion Shane Douglas supposedly ducking his challenge.
**This was a Unification Match with the ECW World Title. The FTW Championship was subsequently deactivated.
***Over twenty years later in AEW, Taz reintroduced the FTW Championship as the centerpiece of his Team Taz stable, which he managed. He named Cage as his champion.