| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Mosh & Thrasher (The Headbangers) | Bobo Brazil Jr. & Andy Chase*(1) | Fort Wright, KY | 1/5/96 |
| 2. | The Bounty Hunter & Brian Taylor | Bobo Brazil Jr. & Andy Chase*(2) | Harveysburg, OH | 8/22/97 |
| 3. | Chip Fairway & Cody Hawk | The Bounty Hunter & Brian Taylor | Lima, OH | 9/23/98 |
| 4. | Brian Taylor & Sean Casey | Chip Fairway & Cody Hawk | Hamilton, OH | 1/23/99 |
| 5. | Chip Fairway & Cody Hawk | Brian Taylor & Sean Casey | Hamilton, OH | 2/27/99 |
| 6. | Alexis Machine & Brian Fury | Chip Fairway & Cody Hawk | Blanchester, OH | 8/25/99 |
| 7. | Anthony McMurphy & Cody Hawk | Alexis Machine, Suicido & GQ Masters III*(3) | Hamilton, OH | 2/19/00 |
| 8. | Bobby Casanova & Brian Fury | Anthony McMurphy & Cody Hawk | Hamilton, OH | 6/17/00 |
| 9. | Chet & Dean Jablonski | Bobby Casanova & Brian Fury and Anthony McMurphy & Cody Hawk*(4) | Blanchester, OH | 10/7/00 |
| 10. | Anthony McMurphy & Cody Hawk | Chet & Dean Jablonski | Rising Sun, IN | 1/26/01 |
| 11. | Chet & Dean Jablonski | Anthony McMurphy & Cody Hawk | Rising Sun, IN | 3/16/01 |
| 12. | Nigel McGuinness & AAA | Chet & Dean Jablonski | Cincinnati, OH | 7/10/01 |
| 13. | Chet & Dean Jablonski | Nigel McGuinness & AAA | Cincinnati, OH | 8/7/01 |
| 14. | Shannon Moore & Evan Karagias (3 Count) | Chet & Dean Jablonski | Batavia, OH | 10/13/01 |
| 15. | Kimo & Ekmo (The Island Boyz) | 3 Count | Dayton, OH | 11/14/01 |
| 16. | Steve Bradley & Val Venis | The Island Boyz | Batavia, OH | 12/8/01 |
| 17. | Lance Cade & Mike Sanders | Steve Bradley & Val Venis | Dayton, OH | 2/13/02 |
| 18. | Lance Cade & Steve Bradley | N/A*(4) | Cincinnati, OH | 2/20/02 |
| 19. | Hugh Morrus & Raven | Lance Cade & Steve Bradley | Cincinnati, OH | 3/12/02 |
| 20. | Lance Cade & Steve Bradley | Hugh Morrus & Raven | Dayton, OH | 3/15/02 |
| 21. | Cody Hawk & Ice Cream Man | Lance Cade & Steve Bradley | Batavia, OH | 4/10/02 |
| 22. | Nigel McGuinness & HTB | Cody Hawk & Ice Cream Man | Cincinnati, OH | 7/23/02 |
| 23. | Brother Clay & Matt Dillinger (Southern Breeze) | N/A*(5) | N/A | N/A |
| 24. | Matt Stryker & Rory Fox | Cody Hawk & Race Steele*(6) | Batavia, OH | 12/7/02 |
| 25. | Chet Jablonski & Cody Hawk | Matt Stryker & Rory Fox | Cincinnati, OH | 3/25/03 |
| 26. | D'lo Brown & Matt Stryker | Chet Jablonski & Cody Hawk | Dayton, OH | 5/23/03 |
| 27. | Chet Jablonski & Cody Hawk | D'lo Brown & Matt Stryker | Cincinnati, OH | 5/26/03 |
| 28. | TJ Dalton & JT Stahr | Chet Jablonski & Cody Hawk | Columbus, OH | 7/26/03 |
| 29. | Chet Jablonski & Cody Hawk | TJ Dalton & JT Stahr | ? | ? |
| 30. | Johnny & Jason Riggs | won tournament*(7) | Wilmington, OH | 11/26/03 |
| 31. | TJ Dalton & JT Stahr | Johnny & Jason Riggs | Cincinnati, OH | 12/16/03 |
| 32. | Crazy J & Lotus (Irish Airborne) | TJ Dalton & JT Stahr | Cincinnati, OH | 2/6/04 |
| 33. | TJ Dalton & JT Stahr | Irish Airborne | Cincinnati, OH | 2/10/04 |
| 34. | Matt Stryker & Cody Hawk | TJ Dalton & JT Stahr | Cincinnati, OH | 4/2/04 |
| 35. | Benjamin Kimera & Shawn Osborne | Matt Stryker & Cody Hawk (Black Militia) | Cincinnati, OH | 6/15/04 |
| 36. | Irish Airborne | Black Militia | Cincinnati, OH | 8/17/04 |
| 37. | Quinten Lee & Ala Hussein (Foreign Intelligence) | Irish Airborne | Cincinnati, OH | 10/5/04 |
| 38. | Matt Stryker & Cody Hawk | Foreign Intelligence | Cincinnati, OH | 10/26/04 |
| 39. | Tack & Mike Desire | won tournament*(8) | Cincinnati, OH | 12/17/04 |
| 40. | Jimmy Turner & Jon Moxley (Necessary Roughness) | Tack & Mike Desire | Cincinnati, OH | 3/11/05 |
| 41. | Foreign Intelligence | Necessary Roughness | Cincinnati, OH | 5/13/05 |
| 42. | Jon Moxley & Ric Byrne (Heartland Foundation) | Foreign Intelligence | Cincinnati, OH | 8/19/05 |
| 43. | Foreign Intelligence | N/A*(9) | Cincinnati, OH | 8/19/05 |
| 44. | Matt Stryker & Tack | Foreign Intelligence | Cincinnati, OH | 10/25/05 |
| 45. | Brian Jennings & Benjamin Kimera | Matt Stryker & Tack | Cincinnati, OH | 12/13/05 |
| 46. | Foreign Intelligence | Brian Jennings & Benjamin Kimera | Cincinnati, OH | 2/21/06 |
| 47. | Aaron Williams & Alan Wasylychyn (The Mavericks) | Foreign Intelligence | Cincinnati, OH | 7/11/06 |
| 48. | Foreign Intelligence | The Mavericks | Cincinnati, OH | 9/06 |
| 49. | Irish Airborne | Foreign Intelligence*(10) | Cincinnati, OH | 10/20/06 |
| 50. | Tack & Tarek the Legend | Irish Airborne | Cincinnati, OH | 3/10/07 |
| 51. | Jon Moxley & Cody Hawk | Tack & Tarek the Legend | Cincinnati, OH | 6/12/07 |
| 52. | Andre Heart & Richard Phillips (The GP Code) | Jon Moxley & Cody Hawk | Cincinnati, OH | 6/16/07 |
| 53. | JT Stahr & The Madness | Richard Phillips & Dave Crist*(11) | Middletown, OH | 9/24/08 |
| 54. | Richard Phillips & Benjamin Kimera | JT Stahr & The Madness | Middletown, OH | 11/19/08 |
| 55. | JT Stahr & The Madness & V-Rad (The Entourage)*(11) | Richard Phillips & Benjamin Kimera | Middletown, OH | 11/22/08 |
| 56. | The GP Code & Benjamin Kimera | The Entourage | Middletown, OH | 12/19/08 |
| 57. | Donovan Cain & Jason Lyte (The Hybrids) | Benjamin Kimera & Andre Heart | Middletown, OH | 2/11/09 |
| 58. | The GP Code | The Hybrids | Peoria, IL | 4/11/09 |
| 59. | The Hybrids | Benjamin Kimera & Andre Heart and Dave Crist & Dustin Rayz*(12) | Norwood, OH | 4/18/09 |
| 60. | Joseph Schwartz & Sean Tylerstein (The Kosher Klub) | The Hybrids | Norwood, OH | 9/26/09 |
| 61. | Richard Phillips & Jon Moxley (Royal Violence) | The Kosher Klub | Middletown, OH | 10/14/09 |
| 62. | Irish Airborne | Royal Violence | Middletown, OH | 12/2/09 |
| 63. | Royal Violence | Irish Airborne | Norwood, OH | 12/19/09 |
| 64. | Irish Airborne | Royal Violence | Middletown, OH | 1/13/10 |
| 65. | Lord Matthew Taylor & Sir Chadwick Cruise (The Noble Bloods) | Irish Airborne | Middletown, OH | 2/24/10 |
| 66. | Loto & Loco (The Flying Mendoza Brothers) | The Noble Bloods | Norwood, OH | 5/29/10 |
| 67. | The Noble Bloods | Irish Airborne, The Hybrids and Jeremy Madrox & Kaden Assad (The Heat Seekers)*(13) | Norwood, OH | 8/20/10 |
| 68. | The Heatseekers | The Noble Bloods and The Hybrids*(14) | Norwood, OH | 12/18/10 |
| 69. | Doug Charlez & Aaron Extreme (DNA) | The Heatseekers*(15) | Hamilton, OH | 7/16/11 |
| 70. | The Heatseekers | N/A*(16) | Norwood, OH | 8/27/11 |
| 71. | The Noble Bloods | The Heatseekers | Norwood, OH | 10/29/11 |
| 72. | Jeff Mayhem & Troy Marcum (The American Wrestling Warriors) | The Noble Bloods, The Heatseekers and DNA*(17) | Hamilton, OH | 12/17/11 |
| 73. | DNA | The American Wrestling Warriors | Hamilton, OH | 2/7/12 |
| 74. | The American Wrestling Warriors | DNA | Hamilton, OH | 2/25/12 |
| 75. | Jon Murray & Clark Konnor (The Heavyweight Heroes) | The American Wrestling Warriors | Hamilton, OH | 4/3/12 |
| 76. | Jesse Emerson & Chris Hall | The Heavyweight Heroes | Hamilton, OH | 4/24/12 |
*This was the finals of a tournament to crown the first HWA Tag Team Champions.
*(2)The titles were vacated, and this was the tournament final to crown new champions.
*(3)This was a Three Way Match.
*(4)This was a Three Way Match.
*(5)The titles were vacated, and a singles match took place between Cade and Sanders, with the winner picking their new championship partner.
*(6)Southern Breeze was stripped of the titles and this was the tournament final to crown new champions.
*(7)Titles were vacated when Hawk was injured and Jablonski left the promotion. This was a tournament final to crown new champions.
*(8)Hawk and Stryker were stripped of the titles and this was the tournament final to crown new champions.
*(9)The Foundation was stripped of the titles and awarded to Foreign Intelligence.
*(10)This was part of a Gauntlet Match.
*(11)This was a handicap match. The three men continued on to defend the titles between them.
*(12)This was a Three Way Dance.
*(13)The title was held up and put up for grabs in a Four Way Match.
*(14)This was a Three Way Match.
*(15)This was the final match in a Gauntlet Match.
*(16)Due to a neck injury to Aaron Extreme, DNA was unable to make their scheduled defense, and the belts were awarded to the Heatseekers by forfeit.
*(17)This was a Four Way Elimination Match.
Title Defenses:
52. The GP Code
---beat Jason Lyte & Donovan Cain in a Lumberjack Match, A Fight at the Opera: 9/10/08
53. The Entourage
---beat Benjamin & Jason Kimera by DQ, A Fight at the Opera: 10/1/08
---lost to Jake & Dave Crist by DQ, Halloween Haunt: 10/29/08
54. Richard Phillips & Benjamin Kimera
---N/A
55. The Entourage
---lost to Benjamin Kimera & Richard Phillips, A Fight at the Opera: 12/3/08
56. The GP Code & Benjamin Kimera
---pinned JT Stahr & Chris Hall & V-Rad, A Fight at the Opera: 1/7/09
57. The Hybrids
---beat Benjamin Kimera & Andre Heart and Kid & Sid Fabulous in a Three Way Dance, A Fight at the Opera: 2/25/09
58. The GP Code
---N/A
59. The Hybrids
---pinned Dave Crist & Jesse Emerson, A Fight at the Opera: 4/29/09
---pinned Brian Beech & Ron Mathis, May Day: 5/23/09
---pinned Dave Crist & Aaron Williams, Domination: 5/30/09
---beat Ron Mathis & Brian Beech in a 2 out of 3 Falls Match, Uprising: 6/26/09
---beat Jesse Emerson & V-Rad and Brian Beech & Ron Mathis in a Three Way Elimination Match, A Fight at the Opera: 7/22/09
---pinned Chad Cruise & Matt Taylor, Road to Destiny: 8/22/09
---DCO against Ron Mathis & Brian Beech, A Fight at the Opera: 9/9/09
60. The Kosher Klub
---N/A
61. Royal Violence
---lost to Jake & Dave Crist by DQ, A Fight at the Opera: 11/11/09
62. Irish Airborne
---N/A
63. Royal Violence
---N/A
64. Irish Airborne
---beat Louis Lyndon & Flip Kendrick, Donovan Cain & Jason Lyte and Drake Younger & Scotty Vortekz in a TLC Match, All or Nothing: 1/29/10
65. The Noble Bloods
---pinned Jake & Dave Crist, A Fight at the Opera: 3/17/10
---pinned Donovan Cain & Jason Lyte, Hysteria: 3/27/10
---lost to Loto & Loco Mendoza by CO, Cyberclash 5.0: 4/24/10
66. The Flying Mendoza Brothers
---pinned Lord Matthew Taylor & Sir Chadwick Cruise, A Fight at the Opera: 6/16/10
---pinned Lord Matthew Taylor & Sir Chadwick Cruise, A Fight at the Opera: 6/30/10
67. The Noble Bloods
---pinned Sid & Kid Fabulous, A Fight at the Opera: 9/8/10
68. The Heatseekers
---beat Lord Matthew Taylor in a Handicap Match, Hysteria: 3/19/11
---pinned Jake & Dave Crist, Cyberclash 6.0: 4/30/11
---no contest against Doug Charlez & Aaron Extreme, May Day: 5/28/11
69. DNA
---pinned Jon Murray & Clark Konnor, Adrenaline: 7/19/11
70. The Heatseekers
---pinned Jon Murray & Clark Konnor, Road to Destiny: 8/27/11
71. The Noble Bloods
---N/A
72. The American Wrestling Warriors
---pinned Jon Murray & Clark Konnor, Adrenaline: 1/3/12
---pinned Jeremy Madrox & Kaden Assad, Kick Off: 1/7/12
73. DNA
---N/A
74. The American Wrestling Warriors
---N/A
75. The Heavyweight Heroes