| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | D'lo Brown | Bobby Blaze*(1) | Fort Wright, KY | 1/5/96 |
| 2. | Bobby Blaze | D'lo Brown | Ashland, KY | 3/9/96 |
| 3. | D'lo Brown | Bobby Blaze | Lima, OH | 3/16/96 |
| 4. | Race Steele | Chip Fairway*(2) | Cincinnati, OH | 5/25/00 |
| 5. | Chad Collyer | Race Steele | Rising Sun, IN | 1/26/01 |
| 6. | Shark Boy | Matt Stryker and Dean Jablonski*(3) | Cincinnati, OH | 2/27/01 |
| 7. | Race Steele | Shark Boy | Rising Sun, IN | 3/16/01 |
| 8. | Cody Hawk | Race Steele | Cincinnati, OH | 7/7/01 |
| 9. | Race Steele | Cody Hawk | Batavia, OH | 8/4/01 |
| 10. | Nick Dinsmore | Race Steele | Cincinnati, OH | 8/9/01 |
| 11. | Race Steele | Nick Dinsmore | Dayton, OH | 8/18/01 |
| 12. | EZ Money | D'lo Brown*(4) | Dayton, OH | 11/14/01 |
| 13. | Charlie Haas | EZ Money | Dayton, OH | 1/9/02 |
| 14. | EZ Money | N/A*(5) | Dayton, OH | 1/29/02 |
| 15. | Rico Constantino | EZ Money | Dayton, OH | 3/15/02 |
| 16. | Stevie Richards | Rico Constantino | Jeffersonville, IN | 3/17/02 |
| 17. | Race Steele | Stevie Richards | Cincinnati, OH | 3/20/02 |
| 18. | Johnny the Bull | Race Steele | Dayton, OH | 5/8/02 |
| 19. | Lance Cade | Johnny the Bull | Jeffersonville, IN | 5/19/02 |
| 20. | Johnny the Bull | Lance Cade | Batavia, OH | 7/20/02 |
| 21. | Lance Cade | Johnny the Bull | Batavia, OH | 7/20/02 |
| 22. | Cody Hawk | Lance Cade | Jeffersonville, IN | 7/21/02 |
| 23. | Matt Stryker | Cody Hawk | Cincinnati, OH | 9/17/02 |
| 24. | Chet Jablonski | Matt Stryker | Batavia, OH | 11/9/02 |
| 25. | Matt Stryker | Chet Jablonski | Batavia, OH | 1/3/03 |
| 26. | Cody Hawk | Matt Stryker | Wilmington, OH | 3/24/03 |
| 27. | Matt Stryker | Cody Hawk | Wilmington, OH | 3/29/03 |
| 28. | Ala Hussein | Matt Stryker | Cincinnati, OH | 4/15/03 |
| 29. | Chad Collyer | Ala Hussein | Aurora, IN | 5/2/03 |
| 30. | Nigel McGuinness | Chad Collyer | Batavia, OH | 9/6/03 |
| 31. | Hoss | Nigel McGuinness | Batavia, OH | 1/3/04 |
| 32. | Nigel McGuinness | Hoss | Cincinnati, OH | 1/6/04 |
| 33. | El Temor | Nigel McGuinness | Cincinnati, OH | 3/17/04 |
| 34. | Rory Fox | El Temor | Cincinnati, OH | 3/30/04 |
| 35. | Shawn Osborne | Rory Fox | Dayton, OH | 3/25/05 |
| 36. | Matt Stryker | Shawn Osborne | Cincinnati, OH | 6/17/05 |
| 37. | Cody Hawk | Matt Stryker | Cincinnati, OH | 9/23/05 |
| 38. | Pepper Parks | Jon Moxley*(6) | Cincinnati, OH | 1/3/06 |
| 39. | Jon Moxley | Pepper Parks | Cincinnati, OH | 5/9/06 |
| 40. | Chad Collyer | Jon Moxley | Cincinnati, OH | 9/12/06 |
| 41. | Pepper Parks | Chad Collyer | Cincinnati, OH | 11/7/06 |
| 42. | Jon Moxley | Matt Stryker, JT Stahr and Brian Jennings*(7) | Dayton, OH | 12/30/06 |
| 43. | Brian Jennings | Jon Moxley | Cincinnati, OH | 1/2/07 |
| 44. | BJ Whitmer | Brian Jennings | Dayton, OH | 1/18/08 |
| 45. | Jake Crist | Jon Moxley*(8) | Cincinnati, OH | 7/11/08 |
| 46. | King Vu | Jake Crist | Norwood, OH | 8/22/09 |
| 47. | Aaron Williams | King Vu | Norwood, OH | 12/19/09 |
| 48. | Jon Moxley | Aaron Williams | Middletown, OH | 1/6/10 |
| 49. | Gerome Phillips | Jon Moxley | Middletown, OH | 7/14/10 |
| 50. | BJ Whitmer | Gerome Phillips | Norwood, OH | 3/19/11 |
| 51. | Jesse Emerson | BJ Whitmer | Norwood, OH | 8/28/11 |
| 52. | Jake Crist | Jesse Emerson | Hamilton, OH | 12/17/11 |
| 53. | Ron Mathis | Jake Crist | Hamilton, OH | 10/19/12 |
| 54. | Chance Prophet | Ron Mathis | Hamilton, OH | 7/27/13 |
*This was the tournament final to crown the first HWA Champion.
*(2)The title went inactive and would remain that way for four years. This was the tournament final to crown the new champion.
*(3)Collyer was stripped of the title and this was the three way final of a tournament to crown a new champion.
*(4)The title was held up on September 30, and this was the tournament final to crown a new champion.
*(5)Haas was stripped of the title and it was awarded to Money.
*(6)Hawk was stripped of the title in November. This was the tournament final to crown the new champion.
*(7)Parks vacated the title, and this was a Four Way to determine the new champion.
*(8)Whitmer was stripped of the title and this match determined the new champion.
Title Defenses:
43. Brian Jennings
---beat Ben Kimera and Jon Moxley in a Three Way Match, Aftermath: 4/15/07
---pinned Dick Rick, Reborn: 11/9/07
44. BJ Whitmer
---pinned Nigel McGuinness, Cyberclash 3.0: 4/25/08
45.Jake Crist
---beat JT Stahr and Vincent Nothing, Road to Destiny: 8/30/08
---pinned JT Stahr, A Fight at the Opera: 9/10/08
---pinned Sami Callihan, A Fight at the Opera: 9/24/08
---pinned Richard Phillips, A Fight at the Opera: 10/15/08
---pinned Dick Rick, A Fight at the Opera: 11/12/08
---beat Jon Moxley in a Steel Cage Match, World War 3: 12/19/08
---pinned Metal Master, A Fight at the Opera: 1/7/09
---no contest against JT Stahr, A Fight at the Opera: 2/11/09
---time limit draw against JT Stahr, A Fight at the Opera: 3/04/09
---DCO against JT Stahr in a 2 out of 3 Falls Match, A Fight at the Opera: 3/20/09
---pinned JT Stahr, Cyberclash 4.0: 4/18/09
---pinned Jesse Emerson, A Fight at the Opera: 5/13/09
---pinned Dean Jablonski, Domination: 5/30/09
---pinned Andre Heart, Uprising: 6/26/09
---pinned Richard Phillips, Trouble in Paradise: 7/18/09
---pinned Ala Hussein, A Fight at the Opera: 7/29/09
46. Richard Phillips
---lost to Dave Crist by DQ, A Fight at the Opera: 9/9/09
---beat Dave Crist via ref stoppage, Pick Your Poison: 9/26/09
---pinned Jake Crist, Fear For All: 10/31/09
47. Aaron Williams
---N/A
48. Jon Moxley
---pinned Richard Phillips, All or Nothing: 1/29/10
---pinned Dustin Rayz, A Fight at the Opera: 3/31/10
---submitted Richard Phillips, Championship Wednesday: 2/24/10
---pinned Scotty Vortekz, A Fight at the Opera: 3/10/10
---pinned Dustin Rayz, A Fight at the Opera: 3/31/10
---pinned Chris Hall, Cyberclash 5.0: 4/24/10
---pinned Jesse Emerson, May Day: 5/29/10
---pinned Richard Phillips, A Fight at the Opera: 6/23/10
49. Gerome Phillips
---pinned Dave Crist, A Fight at the Opera: 8/4/10
---pinned Drake Younger, Road to Destiny: 8/20/10
---pinned Jon Murray, A Fight at the Opera: 9/8/10
---pinned Shank Barzini, World War III: 12/18/10
50. BJ Whitmer
---no contest against Gerome Phillips, Deadline: 4/15/11
---beat Jesse Emerson and Gerome Phillips in a Three Way Match, Cyberclash 6.0: 4/30/11
---pinned Jake Crist, Aftermath: 5/6/11
---beat Gerome Phillips, Jesse Emerson and Jake Crist in a Four Corners Match, Collision Course: 6/3/11
---pinned Sami Callihan, Heatwave: 7/16/11
51. Jesse Emerson
---pinned Chris Hall, Pick Your Poison: 9/24/11
---lost to BJ Whitmer by DQ, Out For Justice: 10/15/11
---pinned Chris Hall, Havoc: 10/29/11
---lost to Dave Crist by DQ, Adrenaline: 11/1/11
---beat Chris Hall in a Lumberjack Match, Adrenaline: 11/8/11
52. Jake Crist
---pinned Juice Jennings, Kick Off: 1/7/12
---pinned Ron Mathis, Cold War: 2/25/12
---pinned Chris Hall, Adrenaline: 3/13/12
---pinned Samuray Del Sol, Eggs, Kegs & Breakin' Legs: 3/17/12
53. Ron Mathis
---N/A
54. Chance Prophet