| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Fenix | Aero Star, Bengala, Big Ryck, Jack Evans, King Cuerno and Sexy Star* | Boyle Heights, CA | 4/19/15 |
| 2. | King Cuerno | Fenix | Boyle Heights, CA | 11/14/15 |
| 3. | Fenix | King Cuerno | Boyle Heights, CA | 11/21/15 |
| 4. | Chavo Guerrero Jr. | Aero Star, El Siniestro de la Muerte, Joey Ryan, Sexy Star, Texano and The Mack*(2) | Boyle Heights, CA | 1/10/16 |
| 5. | Cage | Chavo Guerrero Jr. | Boyle Heights, CA | 1/16/16 |
| 6. | Sexy Star | Daga, El Siniestro de la Muerte, Killshot, Mariposa, Marty Martinez and Nightclaw*(3) | Boyle Heights, CA | 1/31/16 |
| 7. | Johnny Mundo | Sexy Star | Boyle Heights, CA | 3/19/16 |
| 8. | Pentagon Dark | Son of Havoc*(4) | Boyle Heights, CA | 6/25/16 |
| 9. | Dragon Azteca Jr. | Dezmond X and King Cuerno*(5) | Los Angeles, CA | 3/1/18 |
| 10. | Marty Martinez | Dragon Azteca Jr. | Los Angeles, CA | 3/10/18 |
| 11. | Jake Strong | King Cuerno, Big Bad Steve, Aero Star, Hernandez, PJ Black and Dante Fox*(6) | Los Angeles, CA | 3/18/18 |
*This was an eight-way match to crown the first champion.
*(2)This was a The title was vacated when Fenix cashed in the belt for a shot at the Lucha Underground Title. This was a seven-way match to determine the new champion.
*(3)This was a The title was vacated when Cage cashed in the belt for a shot at the Lucha Underground Title. This was a seven-way match to determine the new champion.
*(4)This was a The title was vacated when Mundo cashed in the belt for a shot at the Lucha Underground Title. This was a Ladder Match to determine the new champion.
*(5)This was a The title was vacated when Pentagon cashed in the belt for a shot at the Lucha Underground Title. This was a three-way match to determine the new champion.
*(6)This was a The title was vacated when Martinez cashed in the belt for a shot at the Lucha Underground Title. This was a seven-way match to determine the new champion.