| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Yaqui Joe* | ?? | ?? | 1933 |
| 2. | Octavio Gaona | Black Guzman*(2) | Mexico City, Mexico | 2/6/37 |
| 3. | Firpo Segura | Octavio Gaona | Mexico City, Mexico | 9/2/38 |
| 4. | Octavio Gaona*(3) | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| 5. | Tarzan Lopez | Octavio Gaona | Mexico City, Mexico | 2/9/39 |
| 6. | Black Guzman | Tarzan Lopez | Mexico City, Mexico | 5/12/41 |
| 7. | Murcielago Velazquez | Octavio Gaona*(4) | Mexico City, Mexico | 5/24/42 |
| 8. | El Santo | Murcielago Velazquez | ?? | 3/19/43 |
| 9. | Bobby Bonales | El Santo | ?? | 6/1/43 |
| 10. | Tarzan Lopez | Bobby Bonales | ?? | 1943 |
| 11. | Bobby Bonales | Tarzan Lopez | ?? | 1/1/44 |
| 12. | Gory Guerrero | Bobby Bonales | Mexico City, Mexico | 9/25/45 |
| 13. | El Santo | Tuffy Truesdale*(5) | ?? | 5/31/46 |
| 14. | El Gladiator | El Santo | ?? | ?? |
| 15. | El Santo | El Gladiator | Mexico City, Mexico | 5/31/56 |
| 16. | Karloff Lagarde | El Santo | ?? | 3/24/61 |
| 17. | El Santo | Karloff Lagarde | ?? | 6/28/63 |
| 18. | Rene Guajardo | El Santo | ?? | 6/22/67 |
| 19. | Alberto Munoz | Rene Guajardo | ?? | 3/9/68 |
| 20. | Rene Guajardo | Alberto Munoz | ?? | 11/20/69 |
| 21. | Humberto Garza | Rene Guajardo | Monterrey, Mexico | 5/13/70 |
| 22. | Ciclon Veloz Jr. | Humberto Garza | Monterrey, Mexico | 4/6/71 |
| 23. | Adorable Rubi | Ciclon Veloz Jr. | Mexico City, Mexico | 12/14/73 |
| 24. | Anibal | Adorable Rubi | Mexico City, Mexico | 6/28/74 |
| 25. | Ringo Mendoza | Anibal | Mexico City, Mexico | 11/29/74 |
| 26. | Perro Aguayo | Ringo Mendoza | Mexico City, Mexico | 2/28/77 |
| 27. | Jose Luis Mendieta | ??*(6) | Mexico City, Mexico | 4/14/77 |
| 28. | Sangre Chicana | Jose Luis Mendieta | Mexico City, Mexico | 11/19/77 |
| 29. | Cachorro Mendoza | ??*(7) | Mexico City, Mexico | 6/8/79 |
| 30. | El Satanico | Cachorro Mendoza | Mexico City, Mexico | 10/19/79 |
| 31. | Ringo Mendoza | El Satanico | Mexico City, Mexico | 6/6/80 |
| 32. | El Faraon | Ringo Mendoza | Mexico City, Mexico | 12/5/80 |
| 33. | El Solar | Cachorro Mendoza*(8) | Mexico City, Mexico | 5/29/81 |
| 34. | El Satanico | El Solar | Mexico City, Mexico | 10/23/81 |
| 35. | Lizmark | El Satanico | Mexico City, Mexico | 2/19/82 |
| 36. | Espectro Jr. | Lizmark | Cuernavaca, Mexico | 3/3/83 |
| 37. | Lizmark | Espectro Jr. | Puebla, Mexico | 5/28/83 |
| 38. | Ultraman | Aguila Solitaria*(9) | Mexico City, Mexico | 8/12/83 |
| 39. | Jerry Estrada | Ultraman | Mexico City, Mexico | 3/4/84 |
| 40. | Atlantis | Jerry Estrada | Mexico City, Mexico | 11/30/84 |
| 41. | Talisman | Atlantis | Mexico City, Mexico | 3/2/86 |
| 42. | Mogur | Talisman | Mexico City, Mexico | 11/30/86 |
| 43. | El Satanico | Mogur | Mexico City, Mexico | 1/31/88 |
| 44. | El Dandy | El Satanico | Mexico City, Mexico | 1989 |
| 45. | Javier Cruz | El Dandy | Cuernavacas, Mexico | 7/26/90 |
| 46. | Emilio Charles Jr. | Javier Cruz | Cuernavacas, Mexico | 8/30/90 |
| 47. | Octagon | Emilio Charles Jr. | Mexico City, Mexico | 11/20/90 |
| 48. | Blue Panther | Octagon | Leon, Mexico | 7/24/92 |
| 49. | Octagon | Blue Panther | Veracruz, Mexico | 4/30/94 |
| 50. | Blue Panther | N/A*(10) | Tijuana, Mexico | 5/27/94 |
| 51. | El Hijo del Santo | Blue Panther | Tijuana, Mexico | 1/26/96 |
| 52. | Fuerza Guerrera | El Hijo del Santo | Saltillo, Mexico | 9/15/96 |
| 53. | Octagon | Fuerza Guerrera | Naucalpan, Mexico | 1/29/97 |
| 54. | Pentagon II | Octagon | Nezahaulcoyotl, Mexico | 3/28/97 |
| 55. | Abismo Negro | Pentagon II | Tlalnepantla de Baz, Mexico | 5/19/98 |
| 56. | Espectro Jr. II | Abismo Negro | Ecatepec de Morelos, Mexico | 1/27/99 |
| 57. | Mascara Sagrada Jr. | Espectro Jr. II | Toluca, Mexico | 6/17/99 |
| 58. | Espectro Jr. II | Mascara Sagrada Jr. | Toluca, Mexico | 7/8/99 |
| 59. | Pimpinela Escarlata | Espectro Jr. II | Queretaro, Mexico | 4/27/01 |
| 60. | Psicosis II | Pimpinela Escarlata | Huamantla, Mexico | 8/13/02 |
| 61. | Zumbido | Histeria*(11) | Salamanca, Mexico | 1/29/06 |
| 62. | Octagon | Zumbido | Torreon, Mexico | 7/15/06 |
*The circumstances around the formation of the title are unknown.
*(2)The title was vacated due to unknown circumstances. This match determined the new champion.
*(3)Gaona regained the title due to unknown circumstances.
*(4)Guzman vacated the title after winning the NWA Middleweight Title. This match determined the new champion.
*(5)The title was vacated due to unknown circumstances. This match determined the new champion.
*(6)Aguayo vacated the title after winning the NWA Middleweight Title. This match determined the new champion.
*(7)The title was vacated due to unknown circumstances. This match determined the new champion.
*(8)The title was vacated due to unknown circumstances. This match determined the new champion.
*(9)The title was vacated due to unknown circumstances. This was the finals of a tournament to crown the new champion.
*(10)Octagon was unable to defend the title and the belt was awarded to Panther.
*(11)Psicosis was stripped of the belt after defending it in a hardcore match against Histeria. This was the finals of a tournament to crown the new champion.