| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Bobby Bruns | Maurice Boyer* | Bridgeport, CT | 11/10/39 |
| 2. | Orville Brown | Bobby Bruns | Kansas City, KS | 6/13/40 |
| 3. | Lee Wyckoff | Orville Brown | Kansas City, KS | 4/17/41 |
| 4. | Orville Brown | Lee Wyckoff | Kansas City, KS | 10/16/41 |
| 5. | Tom Zaharias | Orville Brown | Kansas City, KS | 3/5/42 |
| 6. | Orville Brown | Tom Zaharias | Kansas City, KS | 6/25/42 |
| 7. | Ed Lewis | Orville Brown | Kansas City, KS | 11/26/42 |
| 8. | Lee Wyckoff | Ed Lewis | Kansas City, KS | 1/14/43 |
| 9. | Orville Brown | Lee Wyckoff | Kansas City, KS | 2/18/43 |
| 10. | Lee Wyckoff | Orville Brown | Great Bend, KS | 5/??/43 |
| 11. | Orville Brown | Lee Wyckoff | Kansas City, KS | 6/17/43 |
| 12. | The Swedish Angel | Orville Brown | Kansas City, KS | 12/3/43 |
| 13. | Orville Brown | The Swedish Angel | Kansas City, KS | 12/9/43 |
| 14. | Dave Levin | Orville Brown | Kansas City, KS | 5/4/44 |
| 15. | Lee Wyckoff | Dave Levin | Topeka, KS | 6/29/44 |
| 16. | Orville Brown | Lee Wyckoff | Topeka, KS | 8/16/44 |
| 17. | Bobby Bruns | Orville Brown | Kansas City, KS | 6/20/46 |
| 18. | Orville Brown | Bobby Bruns | Kansas City, KS | 8/8/46 |
| 19. | Vic Christy | Orville Brown | St. Joseph, MO | 3/14/47 |
| 20. | Roy Graham | Vic Christy | St. Joseph, MO | 3/30/47 |
| 21. | Orville Brown | Roy Graham | Kansas City, KS | 4/10/47 |
| 22. | Tug Carlson | Orville Brown | St. Joseph, MO | 12/19/47 |
| 23. | Orville Brown | Tug Carlson | St. Joseph, MO | 12/26/47 |
| 24. | Bobby Bruns | Orville Brown | Kansas City, KS | 4/29/48 |
| 25. | Orville Brown** | Bobby Bruns | Kansas City, KS | 5/4/48 |
*Bruns was awarded the title after a victory over Boyer.
**The title was retired when Brown joined the NWA and was recognized as the organization's first champion.