| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Averno | N/A* | N/A | 8/12/10 |
| 2. | La Mascara | Averno | Mexico City, Mexico | 11/22/11 |
| 3. | Volador Jr. | La Mascara | Guadalajara, Mexico | 2/14/12 |
| 4. | Prince Devitt | Volador Jr. | Mexico City, Mexico | 3/30/12 |
| 5. | Dragon Rojo Jr. | Prince Devitt | Mexico City, Mexico | 9/28/12 |
| 6. | La Sombra | Dragon Rojo Jr. | Bunkyo, Japan | 1/20/13 |
| 7. | Ultimo Guerrero | La Sombra | Puebla, Mexico | 8/31/15 |
*CMLL created the title to replace the NWA World Middleweight Title, which they returned to the organization. As the reigning Middleweight Champion, Averno was awarded the new title.