| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Mephisto | N/A* | Mexico City, Mexico | 8/12/10 |
| 2. | La Sombra | Mephisto | Mexico City, Mexico | 3/13/11 |
| 3. | Negro Casas | La Sombra | Puebla, Mexico | 2/13/12 |
| 4. | Mascara Dorada | Negro Casas | Mexico City, Mexico | 6/2/13 |
| 5. | Volador Jr. | Mascara Dorada | Mexico City, Mexico | 11/19/13 |
| 6. | La Sombra | Volador Jr. | Mexico City, Mexico | 6/6/14 |
| 7. | Volador Jr. | La Sombra | Mexico City, Mexico | 8/1/14 |
*The title was created when the NWA World Welterweight Title was vacated and returned to the NWA. Since Mephisto was the current champion, he was awarded the title.