| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Greg Valentine | N/A* | N/A | 10/30/94 |
| 2. | Kevin Von Erich | Greg Valentine | Dallas, TX | 1/7/95 |
| 3. | John Hawk | Kevin Von Erich | Dallas, TX | 1/14/95 |
| 4. | Greg Valentine | John Hawk | Dallas, TX | 3/18/95 |
| 5. | Tommy Cairo | Devon Storm*(2) | Williamstown, NJ | 6/24/95 |
| 6. | Reckless Youth | Derrick Domino*(3) | Yardville, NJ | 9/7/96 |
| 7. | Lance Diamond | Reckless Youth | Cherry Hill, NJ | 4/12/97 |
| 8. | Ace Darling | Lance Diamond | Wilmington, DE | 4/26/97 |
| 9. | Reckless Youth | Ace Darling | Vineland, NJ | 6/14/97 |
| 10. | Jeff Jarrett | Barry Windham*(4) | New Haven, CT | 1/5/98 |
| 11. | Barry Windham | N/A*(5) | N/A | 3/1/98 |
| 12. | The Colorado Kid | Recon*(6) | Nashville, TN | 8/1/98 |
| 13. | Chris Michaels | The Colorado Kid | Nashville, TN | 12/26/98 |
| 14. | The Colorado Kid | Chris Michaels | Nashville, TN | 1/9/99 |
| 15. | Big Bully Douglas | The Colorado Kid | Nashville, TN | 9/12/99 |
| 16. | Mike Rapada | Big Bully Douglas | Lebanon, TN | 10/30/99 |
| 17. | Terry Taylor | Mike Rapada | Nashville, TN | 11/6/99 |
| 18. | The Colorado Kid | Terry Taylor | Nashville, TN | 12/25/99 |
| 19. | Air Paris | The Colorado Kid | Fairview, TN | 5/11/00 |
| 20. | Chris Harris | Air Paris | Nashville, TN | 5/20/00 |
| 21. | Mike Rapada | Chris Harris | Lebanon, TN | 9/14/00 |
| 22. | Steve Corino | Red Dogg*(7) | North Richland Hills, TX | 4/13/01 |
| 23. | Robbie Royce | Steve Corino | Winnipeg, MB | 4/21/01 |
| 24. | Dark Rain | Gene Swan*(8) | St. Boniface, MB | 7/29/01 |
| 25. | Spyder | Dark Rain | St. Boniface, MB | 8/26/01 |
| 26. | Quinn Magnum | Spyder | St. Petersburg, FL | 10/13/01 |
| 27. | Paul Atlas | Quinn Magnum | McKeesport, PA | 9/28/02 |
| 28. | Jorge Estrada | Paul Atlas | Corpus Christi, TX | 10/26/02 |
| 29. | Hotstuff Hernandez | Jorge Estrada | Cornelia, GA | 5/3/03 |
| 30. | JT Wolfen | Hotstuff Hernandez | Honolulu, HI | 9/27/03 |
| 31. | Tommy Marr | JT Wolfen | Nashville, TN | 10/8/05 |
| 32. | Dru Onyx | Tommy Marr | Altamonte Springs, FL | 4/22/06 |
| 33. | Damien Wayne | Dru Onyx | Las Vegas, NV | 8/24/07 |
| 34. | Mike DiBiase | Damien Wayne | Elkin, NC | 12/8/07 |
| 35. | Apolo | Mike DiBiase | Tyler, TX | 5/2/09 |
| 36. | The Sheik | Apolo | Fort Pierce, FL | 1/30/10 |
| 37. | Shaun Tempers | Ace Rockwell*(9) | Cornelia, GA | 6/25/11 |
| 38. | Carson | Shaun Tempers | Cypress, TX | 10/12/12 |
| 39. | Byron Wilcott | Carson | Cypress, TX | 1/11/13 |
| 40. | Kahagas | Byron Wilcott | Houston, TX | 4/20/13 |
| 41. | Byron Wilcott | Kahagas | Sherman, TX | 5/16/14 |
| 42. | Tim Storm | Byron Wilcott | Sherman, TX | 10/17/14 |
| 43. | Jax Dane | Tim Storm | Las Vegas, NV | 4/12/15 |
| 44. | Tim Storm | Andy Anderson*(10) | Sherman, TX | 7/17/15 |
| 45. | Tyson Dean | Tim Storm | Pavo, GA | 7/16/16 |
| 46. | Mustang Mike | Tyson Dean | Amelia, LA | 4/8/17 |
*Valentine was recognizes as the initial champion.
*(2)The title was vacated when NWA Dallas ceased operations. The title was moved to NWA Championship Wrestling America, and this was the tournament final to crown a new champion.
*(3)Domino defended the title when Cairo no-showed the event.
*(4)The title was vacated so it could be used on World Wrestling Federation television. This match determined the new champion.
*(5)Windham was awarded the title when Jarrett left Jim Cornette's NWA-affiliated group.
*(6)The NWA stripped Windhame of the title. This match was considered to be for the title after the fact, since Colorado Kid had already beaten Recon for the Music City Wrestling Title previously. The North American Title then replaced the MCW Title.
*(7)The title was vacated when Rapada won the NWA World Title. This match determined the new champion.
*(8)The title was vacated when Royce left the Canadian Wrestling Federation. This was the finals of a tournament to crown a new champion.
*(9)The title was vacated when Sheik won the NWA World Title. This match determined the new champion.
*(10)Dane vacated the title due to an injury. This was the finals of a tournament to crown a new champion.