| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | El Santo | Pete Pancoff* | Mexico City, Mexico | 3/15/46 |
| 2. | Jack O'Brien | El Santo | Mexico City, Mexico | 2/15/47 |
| 3. | Gory Guerrero | Jack O'Brien | Mexico City, Mexico | 4/29/49 |
| 4. | Bobby Bonales | Gory Guerrero | Mexico City, Mexico | 7/13/51 |
| 5. | El Santo | Bobby Bonales | Mexico City, Mexico | 9/26/52 |
| 6. | Blue Demon | El Santo | Mexico City, Mexico | 7/25/53 |
| 7. | Karloff Lagarde | Blue Demon | Mexico City, Mexico | 1/31/58 |
| 8. | Huracan Ramirez | Karloff Lagarde | Cuernavaca, Mexico | 8/5/65 |
| 9. | Karloff Lagarde | Huracan Ramirez | Mexico City, Mexico | 9/24/65 |
| 10. | Vento Castella | Karloff Lagarde | Mexico City, Mexico | 5/7/67 |
| 11. | Karloff Lagarde | Vento Castella | Mexico City, Mexico | 7/3/67 |
| 12. | Alberto Munoz | Karloff Lagarde | Mexico City, Mexico | 7/11/71 |
| 13. | Mano Negra | Karloff Lagarde*(2) | Mexico City, Mexico | 12/14/73 |
| 14. | Blue Demon | Mano Negra | Mexico City, Mexico | 6/29/75 |
| 15. | Fishman | Blue Demon | Mexico City, Mexico | 4/9/76 |
| 16. | Mano Negra | Fishman | Mexico City, Mexico | 1/19/77 |
| 17. | Americo Rocca | Mano Negra | Mexico City, Mexico | 4/30/79 |
| 18. | Kato Kung Lee | Americo Rocca | Mexico City, Mexico | 1/19/80 |
| 19. | El Supremo | Kato Kung Lee | Mexico City, Mexico | 5/4/80 |
| 20. | Lizmark | El Supremo | Acapulco, Mexico | 6/4/80 |
| 21. | La Fiera | Lizmark | Mexico City, Mexico | 10/23/81 |
| 22. | Americo Rocca | La Fiera | Guadalajara, Mexico | 7/18/82 |
| 23. | Mocho Cota | Americo Rocca | Mexico City, Mexico | 1/27/84 |
| 24. | Chamaco Valaguez | Mocho Cota | Cuernavaca, Mexico | 7/26/84 |
| 25. | El Dandy | ??*(3) | Mexico City, Mexico | 11/17/85 |
| 26. | Monarca Cruz | El Dandy | Monterrey, Mexico | 4/7/86 |
| 27. | El Dandy | Monarca Cruz | Mexico City, Mexico | 8/24/86 |
| 28. | Americo Rocca | El Dandy | Mexico City, Mexico | 11/2/86 |
| 29. | Solar II | Americo Rocca | Cuernavaca, Mexico | 7/30/88 |
| 30. | Fuerza Guerrera | Solar II | Mexico City, Mexico | 10/4/88 |
| 31. | Aguila Solitaria | Fuerza Guerrera | Mexico City, Mexico | 6/2/89 |
| 32. | Fuerza Guerrera | Aguila Solitaria | Puebla, Mexico | 9/21/89 |
| 33. | Misterioso | Fuerza Guerrera | Mexico City, Mexico | 12/6/91 |
| 34. | Negro Casas | El Hijo del Santo*(4) | Mexico City, Mexico | 12/1/95 |
| 35. | Shinjiro Otani | Negro Casas | Tokyo, Japan | 8/3/96 |
| 36. | Ultimo Dragon | Shinjiro Otani | Tokyo, Japan | 8/4/96 |
| 37. | The Great Sasuke | Ultimo Dragon | Tokyo, Japan | 8/5/96 |
| 38. | Ultimo Dragon | The Great Sasuke | Osaka, Japan | 10/11/96 |
| 39. | Jushin Liger | Ultimo Dragon | Tokyo, Japan | 1/4/97 |
| 40. | El Samurai | Jushin Liger | Sapporo, Japan | 7/6/97 |
| 41. | Shinjiro Otani | El Samurai | Nagoya, Japan | 8/10/97 |
| 42. | Dragon Kid | Dr. Cerebro*(5) | Nagoya, Japan | 2/6/99 |
| 43. | Judo Suwa | Dragon Kid | Kawasaki, Japan | 4/25/99 |
| 44. | Keni'chiro Arai | Judo Suwa | Tokyo, Japan | 7/22/00 |
| 45. | Keni'chiro Arai | Yasushi Kanda*(6) | Tokyo, Japan | 1/29/01 |
| 46. | Susumu Mochizuki | Keni'chiro Arai | Kobe, Japan | 5/27/01 |
| 47. | Ryo Saito | Susumu Mochizuki | Tokyo, Japan | 9/30/01 |
| 48. | Genki Horiguchi | Ryo Saito | Kobe, Japan | 4/28/02 |
| 49. | Ricky Marvin | Super Nova*(7) | Kobe, Japan | 7/7/02 |
| 50. | Genki Horiguchi | Ricky Marvin | Kumamoto, Japan | 7/24/02 |
| 51. | Darkness Dragon | Genki Horiguchi | Shimonoseki, Japan | 7/28/02 |
| 52. | YOSSINO | Genki Horiguchi*(8) | Sapporo, Japan | 3/22/03 |
| 53. | Hajime Ohara | La Mascara*(9) | Mexico City, Mexico | 5/13/06 |
| 54. | Super Delfin | Hajime Ohara | Osaka, Japan | 1/20/07 |
| 55. | Hajime Ohara | Super Delfin | Osaka, Japan | 2/10/07 |
| 56. | La Sombra | Hajime Ohara | Mexico City, Mexico | 11/27/07 |
| 57. | Mephisto | La Sombra | Acapulco, Mexico | 5/27/09 |
| 58. | Cassandro | Dr. Cerebro*(10) | London, UK | 6/25/11 |
| 59. | Magno | Cassandro and Bobby Zavala*(11) | El Paso, TX | 2/15/15 |
| 60. | Impostor Jr. | Bobby Zavala*(12) | El Paso, TX | 5/31/15 |
| 61. | Ultimo Samuray | Impostor Jr. | El Paso, TX | 12/6/15 |
| 62. | Impostor Jr. | Ultimo Samuray | El Paso, TX | 12/25/15 |
| 63. | Akantus | Impostor Jr. | El Paso, TX | 4/24/16 |
*This match determined the first champion.
*(2)The title was vacated after Munoz suffered a near fatal injury. This match determined the new champion.
*(3)The title was vacated due to unknown circumstances. This match determined the new champion.
*(4)Misterioso vacated the title when he left CMLL. This was the finals of a tournament to crown a new champion.
*(5)The title had come under the umbrella of the J-Crown, a conglomerate of eight different titles. When the WWF demanded the return of their Light Heavyweight title belt, Otani vacated five of the six remaining titles in the J-Crown, including the Welterweight Title, which came under the jurisdiction of Toryumon Japan. This match determined the new champion.
*(6)The title was vacated due to outside interference when Arai defended against Susumu Mochizuki. This was the finals of a tournament to crown a new champion.
*(7)The title was vacated when a defense against Dragon Kid went to a no-contest. This match determined the new champion.
*(8)Dragon vacated the title due to injury. This match determined the new champion.
*(9)YOSSINO vacated the title in order to concentrate on the Toryumon Ultimo Dragon Gym Championship. This match determined the new champion.
*(10)The title was vacated when CMLL returned the title to the NWA. This match determined the new champion.
*(11)This was a Three-Way Match.
*(12)The title was vacated when Magno signed with WWE. This match determined the new champion.