| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Adam Cole | Lars Sullivan, Killian Dain, Velveteen Dream, Ricochet and EC3* | New Orleans, LA | 4/7/18 |
| 2. | Ricochet | Adam Cole | Brooklyn, NY | 8/18/18 |
| 3. | Johnny Gargano | Ricochet | Phoenix, AZ | 1/26/19 |
| 4. | The Velveteen Dream | Johnny Gargano | Winter Park, FL | 1/30/19 |
| 5. | Roderick Strong | The Velveteen Dream | Winter Park, FL | 9/18/19 |
| 6. | Keith Lee | Roderick Strong | Winter Park, FL | 1/22/20 |
| 7. | Damian Priest | Bronson Reed, The Velveteen Dream, Johnny Gargaon and Cameron Grimes** | Winter Park, FL | 8/22/20 |
| 8. | Johnny Gargano | Damian Priest | Winter Park, FL | 10/28/20 |
| 9. | Leon Ruff | Johnny Gargano | Winter Park, FL | 11/11/20 |
| 10. | Johnny Gargano | Leon Ruff and Damien Priest*** | Winter Park, FL | 12/6/20 |
| 11. | Bronson Reed | Johnny Gargano | Winter Park, FL | 5/18/21 |
| 12. | Isaiah Scott | Bronson Reed | Winter Park, FL | 6/29/21 |
*This was a Ladder Match to determine the first champion.
**Lee vacated the title upon winning the NXT Championship. This was a Five Way Ladder Match to determine the new champion.
***This was a Triple Threat Match.
1. Adam Cole
---pinned Oney Lorcan, NXT: 4/11/18
---pinned Wolfgang, WWE United Kingdom Championship Tournament - Night 2: 6/19/18
2. Ricochet
---no contest against Pete Dunne, NXT: 8/23/18
---beat Pete Dunne and Adam Cole in a Triple Threat Match, NXT: 9/20/18
---pinned Tyler Breeze, NXT: 11/28/18
3. Johnny Gargano
---N/A
4. The Velveteen Dream
---pinned Buddy Murphy, NXT: 4/10/19
---pinned Tyler Breeze, TakeOver XXV: 6/1/19
---beat Pete Dunne and Roderick Strong in a Triple Threat Match, TakeOver - Toronto II: 8/10/19
5. Roderick Strong
---beat Keith Lee and Dominic Dijakovic in a Triple Threat Match, NXT: 10/23/19
---submitted Austin Theory, NXT: 12/20/19
6. Keith Lee
---pinned Dominik Dijakovic, TakeOver - Portland: 2/16/20
---pinned Cameron Grimes, NXT: 3/11/20
---pinned Johnny Gargano, TakeOver - In Your House: 6/7/20
---pinned Adam Cole, The Great American Bash: 7/8/20
7. Damian Priest
---pinned Timothy Thatcher, NXT: 9/16/20
---pinned Johnny Gargano, TakeOver 31: 10/4/20
---pinned Dexter Lumis, NXT: 10/16/20
8. Johnny Gargano
---N/A
9. Leon Ruff
---beat Johnny Gargano by DQ, NXT: 11/18/20
10. Johnny Gargano
---pinned Leon Ruff, NXT: 12/30/20
---pinned KUSHIDA, TakeOver - Vengeance Day: 2/14/21
---beat Bronson Reed and Austin Theory in a Triple Threat Match, TakeOver - Stand and Deliver: 4/8/21
11. Bronson Reed
---w/ Wes Lee & Nash Carter, beat Santos Escobar & Raul Mendoza & Joaquin Wilde in a Championship Six-Man Tag Team Match, TakeOver - In Your House: 6/13/21
12. Isaiah Scott