| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Oliver Grey & Adrian Neville (British Ambition) | Luke Harper & Erick Rowan (The Wyatt Family)* | Winter Park, FL | 1/31/13 |
| 2. | The Wyatt Family | Adrian Neville & Bo Dallas** | Winter Park, FL | 5/2/13 |
| 3. | Adrian Neville & Corey Graves | The Wyatt Family | Winter Park, FL | 6/20/13 |
| 4. | Rick Viktor & Conor O'Brian (The Ascension) | Adrian Neville & Corey Graves | Winter Park, FL | 9/12/13 |
| 5. | Sin Cara & Kalisto (The Lucha Dragons) | The Ascension | Winter Park, FL | 9/11/14 |
| 6. | Buddy Murphy & Wesley Blake | The Lucha Dragons | Winter Park, FL | 1/15/15 |
| 7. | Aiden English & Simon Gotch (The Vaudevillains) | Buddy Murphy & Wesley Blake | New York, NY | 8/22/15 |
| 8. | Dash Wilder & Scott Dawson (The Revival) | The Vaudevillains | Winter Park, FL | 10/22/15 |
| 9. | Jason Jordan & Chad Gable (American Alpha) | The Revival | Dallas, TX | 4/1/16 |
| 10. | The Revival | American Alpha | Winter Park, FL | 6/8/16 |
| 11. | Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa (#DIY) | The Revival | Toronto, ON | 11/19/16 |
| 12. | Akam & Rezar (The Authors of Pain) | #DIY | San Antonio, TX | 1/28/17 |
| 13. | Eric Young & Alexander Wolfe (Sanity) | The Authors of Pain | New York, NY | 8/19/17 |
| 14. | Kyle O'Reilly & Bobby Fish (The Undisputed Era) | Sanity | Winter Park, FL | 11/29/17 |
| 15. | Tyler Bate & Trent Seven (Moustache Mountain) | The Undisputed Era | London, UK | 6/19/18 |
| 16. | Kyle O'Reilly & Roderick Strong (The Undisputed Era) | Moustache Mountain | Winter Park, FL | 6/21/18 |
| 17. | Hanson & Rowe (War Raiders) | The Undisputed Era | Phoenix, AZ | 1/26/19 |
| 18. | Angelo Dawkins & Montez Ford (The Street Profits) | The Undisputed Era, Oney Lorcan & Danny Burch and Wesley Blake & Steve Cutler (The Forgotten Sons)*** | Bridgeport, CT | 6/1/19 |
| 19. | The Undisputed Era | The Street Profits | Winter Park, FL | 8/14/19 |
| 20. | Pete Dunne & Matt Riddle (The Broserweights) | The Undisputed Era | Portland, OR | 2/16/20 |
| 21. | Marcel Barthel & Fabian Aichner (Imperium) | Matt Riddle & Timothy Thatcher**** | Winter Park, FL | 5/13/20 |
| 22. | Tyler Breeze & Fandango (Breezango) | Imperium | Winter Park, FL | 8/26/20 |
| 23. | Danny Burch & Oney Lorcan | Breezango | Winter Park, FL | 10/21/20 |
| 24. | Wes Lee & Nash Carter (MSK) | Zack Gibson & James Drake (The Grizzled Young Veterans) and Raul Mendoza & Joaquin Wilde (Legado del Fantasma)*(5) | Orlando, FL | 4/7/21 |
*This was the finals of a tournament to crown the first tag team champions.
**Dallas was filling in for an injured Oliver Grey.
***The War Raiders relinquished the titles when they were called up to the main roster. This was a Four Way Ladder Match to determine new champions.
****Due to the travel ban because of the Coronavirus pandemic, Dunne was unable to travel to the US to defend the belts. Thatcher substituted as Riddle's partner.
*(5)Burch was put out with an injury, and the titles were vacated. This was a Triple Threat Match to determine the new champions.
Title Defenses:
1. British Ambition
---N/A
2. The Wyatt Family
---pinned Kassius Ohno & Corey Graves, NXT: 5/23/13
3. Adrian Neville & Corey Graves
---N/A
4. The Ascension
---pinned Hunico & Camacho, NXT: 10/24/13
---pinned Grandmaster Sexay & Scotty 2 Hotty, ArRIVAL: 2/27/14
---pinned El Local & Kalisto, TakeOver: 5/29/14
---pinned Sami Zayn & Tyson Kidd, NXT: 5/30/14
5. The Lucha Dragons
---pinned Viktor & Konnor, NXT: 9/12/14
---pinned Aiden English & Simon Gotch, TakeOver - R Evolution: 12/11/14
6. Buddy Murphy & Wesley Blake
---pinned Sin Cara & Kalisto, TakeOver - Rival: 2/11/15
---pinned Enzo Amore & Colin Cassady, TakeOver - Unstoppable: 5/20/15
7. The Vaudevillains
---pinned Buddy Murphy & Wesley Blake, NXT: 9/10/15
8. The Revival
---pinned Aiden English & Simon Gotch, NXT: 11/19/15
---pinned Enzo Amore & Colin Cassady, TakeOver - London: 12/16/15
---pinned Enzo Amore & Colin Cassady, WWE Roadblock: 3/12/16
9. American Alpha
---N/A
10. The Revival
---beat Chad Gable & Jason Jordan in a 2 out of 3 Falls Match, NXT: 6/24/16
---submitted Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa, NXT TakeOver - Brooklyn II: 8/20/16
11. #DIY
---pinned Dash Wilder & Scott Dawson, NXT: 11/30/16
---pinned Akira Tozawa & Tajiri, NXT: 12/3/16
---pinned Nick Miller & Shane Thorne, NXT: 12/8/16
12. The Authors of Pain
---lost to Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa by DQ, NXT: 2/1/17
---beat Dash Wilder & Scott Dawson and Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa in a Triple Threat Match, TakeOver - Orlando: 4/1/17
---beat Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa in a Ladder Match, TakeOver - Chicago: 5/20/17
---pinned Otis Dozovic & Tucker Knight, NXT: 6/23/17
13. Sanity
---no contest against Akam & Rezar, NXT: 10/4/17
14. The Undisputed Era
---pinned Akam & Rezar, TakeOver - Philadelphia: 1/27/18
---beat Akam & Rezar and Roderick Strong & Pete Dunne, TakeOver - New Orleans: 4/7/18
---pinned Oney Lorcan & Danny Burch, TakeOver - Chicago II: 6/16/18
15. Moustache Mountain
---N/A
16. The Undisputed Era
---pinned Tyler Bate & Trent Seven, TakeOver - Brooklyn IV: 8/18/18
---lost to Hanson & Ray Rowe by DQ, NXT: 9/20/18
---pinned Tucker Knight & Otis Dozovic, NXT: 11/28/18
17. War Raiders
---pinned Aleister Black & Ricochet, TakeOver - New York: 4/5/19
---no contest against Montez Ford & Angelo Dawkins, NXT: 5/1/19
18. The Street Profits
---pinned Kyle O'Reilly & Bobby Fish, TakeOver - Toronto II: 8/10/19
19. The Undisputed Era
---pinned Montez Ford & Angelo Dawkins, NXT: 10/2/19
---pinned Dominik Dijakovic & Keith Lee, NXT: 11/27/19
20. The Broserweights
---pinned Kyle O'Reilly & Bobby Fish, NXT: 3/11/20
21. Imperium
---pinned Tyler Breeze & Fandango, NXT: 6/17/20
---pinned Kyle O'Reilly & Bobby Fish, NXT: 8/5/20
22. Breezango
---pinned Marcel Barthel & Fabian Aichner, NXT: 9/16/20
23. Danny Burch & Oney Lorcan
---pinned Tyler Breeze & Fandango, NXT: 11/11/20
---beat Drake Maverick & Killian Dain in a Streetfight, NXT: 12/23/20
---pinned Finn Balor & Karrion Kross, NXT: 3/17/21
24. MSK
---pinned Killian Dain & Drake Maverick, NXT: 4/13/21
---pinned Raul Mendoza & Joaquin Wilde, NXT: 6/1/21
---w/ Bronson Reed, beat Joaquin Wilde & Raul Mendoza & Santos Escobar in a Championship Six-Man Tag Team Match, TakeOver - In Your House: 6/13/21
---pinned Timothy Thatcher & Tommaso Ciampa, The Great American Bash: 7/6/21