| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Seth Rollins | Jinder Mahal* | Winter Park, FL | 7/26/12 |
| 2. | Big E. Langston | Seth Rollins | Winter Park, FL | 12/6/12 |
| 3. | Bo Dallas | Big E. Langston | Winter Park, FL | 5/23/13 |
| 4. | Adrian Neville | Bo Dallas | Winter Park, FL | 2/27/14 |
| 5. | Sami Zayn | Adrian Neville | Winter Park, FL | 12/11/14 |
| 6. | Kevin Owens | Sami Zayn | Winter Park, FL | 2/11/15 |
| 7. | Finn Balor | Kevin Owens | Tokyo, Japan | 7/4/15 |
| 8. | Samoa Joe | Finn Balor | Lowell, MA | 4/21/16 |
| 9. | Shinsuke Nakamura | Samoa Joe | Brooklyn, NY | 8/20/16 |
| 10. | Samoa Joe | Shinsuke Nakamura | Toronto, ON | 11/19/16 |
| 11. | Shinsuke Nakamura | Samoa Joe | Osaka, Japan | 12/3/16 |
| 12. | Bobby Roode | Shinsuke Nakamura | San Antonio, TX | 1/28/17 |
| 13. | Drew McIntyre | Bobby Roode | Brooklyn, NY | 8/19/17 |
| 14. | Andrade Almas | Drew McIntyre | Houston, TX | 11/18/17 |
| 15. | Aleister Black | Andrade Almas | New Orleans, LA | 4/7/18 |
| 16. | Tommaso Ciampa | Aleister Black | Winter Park, FL | 7/18/18 |
| 17. | Johnny Gargano | Adam Cole** | Brooklyn, NY | 4/5/19 |
| 18. | Adam Cole | Johnny Gargano | Bridgeport, CT | 6/1/19 |
*This was the finals of a Gold Rush Tournament to crown the first champion.
**Ciampa had to relinquish the title due to a neck injury before his title defense against Gargano. Cole won a Fatal Five Way Match to earn the right to face Gargano for the vacant belt.
Title Defenses:
1. Seth Rollins
---pinned Michael McGillicutty, NXT: 8/28/12
---pinned Jinder Mahal, NXT: 11/15/12
---lost to Corey Graves by DQ, NXT: 12/6/12
2. Big E. Langston
---pinned Conor O'Brian, NXT: 3/21/13
---pinned Brad Maddox, NXT: 3/21/13
---pinned Damien Sandow, NXT: 5/2/13
3. Bo Dallas
---pinned Antonio Cesaro, NXT: 6/20/13
---pinned Leo Kruger, NXT: 7/11/13
---pinned Sami Zayn, NXT: 9/12/13
---lost to Adrian Neville by CO, NXT: 10/24/13
---beat Adrian Neville in a Lumberjack Match, NXT: 11/21/13
4. Adrian Neville
---pinned Bo Dallas, NXT: 2/28/14
---beat Brodus Clay in a No DQ Match, NXT: 4/24/14
---pinned Tyson Kidd, TakeOver: 5/29/14
---pinned Tyson Kidd, NXT: 5/30/14
---beat Tyler Breeze by DQ, NXT: 7/17/14
---beat Tyler Breeze, Sami Zayn and Tyson Kidd in a Fatal Four Way Match, TakeOver - Fatal 4 Way: 9/11/14
---pinned Tyson Kidd, NXT: 9/12/14
---pinned Titus O'Neil, NXT: 9/25/14
---pinned Sami Zayn, NXT: 10/23/14
5. Sami Zayn
---pinned Adrian Neville, NXT: 12/12/14
6. Kevin Owens
---pinned Finn Balor, NXT: 2/18/15
---no contest against Sami Zayn, TakeOver - Unstoppable: 5/20/15
7. Finn Balor
---beat Kevin Owens in a Ladder Match, TakeOver - Brooklyn: 8/22/15
---lost to Apollo Crews by DQ, NXT: 10/22/15
---pinned Samoa Joe, TakeOver - London: 12/16/15
---pinned Samoa Joe, TakeOver - Dallas: 4/1/16
8. Samoa Joe
---beat Finn Balor in a Steel Cage Match, TakeOver - The End: 6/8/16
9. Shinsuke Nakamura
---N/A
10. Samoa Joe
---N/A
11. Shinsuke Nakamura
---beat Samoa Joe in a Steel Cage Match, NXT: 12/8/16
12. Bobby Roode
---pinned Kassius Ohno, NXT: 2/22/17
---pinned Shinsuke Nakamura, TakeOver - Orlando: 4/1/17
---pinned Hideo Itami, TakeOver - Chicago: 5/20/17
---pinned Roderick Strong, NXT: 6/23/17
13. Drew McIntyre
---pinned Roderick Strong, NXT: 9/14/17
14. Andrade Almas
---pinned Johnny Gargano, TakeOver - Philadelphia: 1/27/18
---pinned Johnny Gargano, NXT: 2/1/18
15. Aleister Black
---pinned Lars Sullivan, TakeOver - Chicago II: 6/16/18
16. Tommaso Ciampa
---beat Johnny Gargano in a Last Man Standing Match, TakeOver - Brooklyn IV: 8/18/18
---pinned The Velveteen Dream, TakeOver - War Games II: 11/17/18
---pinned Aleister Black, TakeOver - Phoenix: 1/26/19
17. Johnny Gargano
---N/A
18. Adam Cole