| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Paige | Emma* | Winter Park, FL | 6/20/13 |
| 2. | Charlotte | Natalya** | Winter Park, FL | 5/29/14 |
| 3. | Sasha Banks | Charlotte, Becky Lynch and Bayley*** | Winter Park, FL | 2/11/15 |
| 4. | Bayley | Sasha Banks | New York, NY | 8/22/15 |
| 5. | Asuka | Bayley | Dallas, TX | 4/1/16 |
| 6. | Ember Moon | Nikki Cross, Peyton Royce and Kairi Sane**** | Houston, TX | 11/18/17 |
| 7. | Shayna Baszler | Ember Moon | New Orleans, LA | 4/7/18 |
| 8. | Kairi Sane | Shayna Baszler | Brooklyn, NY | 8/18/18 |
| 9. | Shayna Baszler | Kairi Sane | Uniondale, NY | 10/28/18 |
*This was the finals of a tournament to crown the first champion.
**Paige was stripped of the title after moving to the main WWE roster and winning the Divas Title. This was the finals of a tournament to crown a new champion.
***This was a Fatal Four Way Match.
****Asuka vacated the title due to negotiating a contract with Raw or Smackdown. It was decided to put the title up for grabs in a Fatal Four Way Match, featuring Kairi Sane, the winner of the Mae Young Classic Tournament, as well as three others who qualified on NXT television.
Title Defenses:
1. Paige
---pinned Summer Rae, NXT: 7/11/13
---pinned Natalya, NXT: 10/24/13
---submitted Emma, ArRIVAL: 2/27/14
2. Charlotte
---pinned Summer Rae, NXT: 6/12/14
---pinned Bayley, TakeOver - Fatal 4 Way: 9/11/14
---pinned Bayley, NXT: 9/12/14
---pinned Sasha Banks, TakeOver - R Evolution: 12/11/14
---beat Sasha Banks by DQ, NXT: 1/15/15
3. Sasha Banks
---pinned Charlotte, NXT: 2/12/15
---submitted Alexa Bliss, NXT: 2/18/15
---submitted Becky Lynch, TakeOver - Unstoppable: 5/20/15
---submitted Charlotte, NXT: 6/18/15
4. Bayley
---beat Sasha Banks in an Iron Woman Match, TakeOver - Respect: 10/7/15
---pinned Alexa Bliss, NXT: 10/22/15
---pinned Eva Marie, NXT: 11/19/15
---submitted Nia Jax, TakeOver - London: 12/16/15
---pinned Carmella, NXT: 1/22/16
5. Asuka
---pinned Nia Jax, TakeOver - The End: 6/8/16
---pinned Bayley, TakeOver - Brooklyn II: 8/20/16
---submitted Mickie James, TakeOver - Toronto: 11/19/16
---pinned Nia Jax, NXT: 12/3/16
---beat Peyton Royce, Billie Kay and Nikki Cross in a Fatal Four Way Match, TakeOver - San Antonio: 1/28/17
---submitted Peyton Royce, NXT: 2/1/17
---pinned Ember Moon, TakeOver - Orlando: 4/1/17
---beat Ruby Riot and Nikki Cross in a Triple Threat Match, TakeOver - Chicago: 5/20/17
---no contest against Ruby Riot and Nikki Cross in a Triple Threat Match, NXT: 5/25/17
---beat Nikki Cross in a Last Woman Standing Match, NXT: 6/23/17
---submitted Ember Moon, TakeOver - Brooklyn III: 8/19/17
6. Ember Moon
---pinned Sonya Deville, NXT: 11/29/17
---pinned Shayna Baszler, TakeOver - Philadelphia: 1/27/18
---lost to Shayna Baszler by DQ, NXT: 2/1/18
7. Shayna Baszler
---submitted Dakota Kai, NXT: 5/9/18
---submitted Nikki Cross, TakeOver - Chicago II: 6/16/18
---beat Toni Storm by CO, WWE United Kingdom Championship Tournament - Night 2: 6/19/18
8. Kairi Sane
---N/A
9. Shayna Baszler
---beat Kairi Sane in a Best 2 out of 3 Falls Match, TakeOver - War Games II: 11/17/18
---submitted Bianca Belair, TakeOver - Phoenix: 1/26/19
---beat Bianca Belair, Kairi Sane and Io Shirai in a Fatal Four Way Match, TakeOver - New York: 4/5/19
---beat Kairi Sane by DQ, NXT: 4/10/19
---submitted Io Shirai, TakeOver XXV: 6/1/19
---beat Io Shirai in a Steel Cage Match, NXT: 6/12/19