| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Trailer Park Trash | Vic the Bruiser* | Jeffersonville, IN | 8/17/97 |
| 2. | Bill Dundee | won battle royale*(2) | Jeffersonville, IN | 11/1/97 |
| 3. | Rip Rogers | Bill Dundee | Jeffersonville, IN | 11/16/97 |
| 4. | Nick Dinsmore | Rip Rogers | Jeffersonville, IN | 6/3/98 |
| 5. | David C. | N/A*(3) | Jeffersonville, IN | 6/10/98 |
| 6. | Doug Basham | David C. | Jeffersonville, IN | 7/5/98 |
| 7. | Rip Rogers | Doug Basham | Jeffersonville, IN | 9/13/98 |
| 8. | Doug Basham | Rip Rogers | Louisville, KY | 12/29/98 |
| 9. | Rip Rogers | Doug Basham | Louisville, KY | 1/3/99 |
| 10. | Rod Steele | Rip Rogers | Louisville, KY | 2/2/99 |
| 11. | Nick Dinsmore | Rod Steele | Jeffersonville, IN | 4/18/99 |
| 12. | Rob Conway | Nick Dinsmore | Jeffersonville, IN | 4/28/99 |
| 13. | Nick Dinsmore | Rob Conway | New Albany, IN | 5/7/99 |
| 14. | Damaja | Nick Dinsmore | Louisville, KY | 6/8/99 |
| 15. | Rob Conway | Damaja | Louisville, KY | 8/17/99 |
| 16. | Rico Constantino | Rob Conway | Louisville, KY | 11/10/99 |
| 17. | Flash Flanagan | Rico Constantino | Louisville, KY | 12/26/99 |
| 18. | Rico Constantino | Flash Flanagan | Louisville, KY | 2/6/00 |
| 19. | Flash Flanagan | Rico Constantino | Jeffersonville, IN | 2/17/00 |
| 20. | Damaja | Flash Flanagan | Louisville, KY | 4/4/00 |
| 21. | Nick Dinsmore | Damaja | Jeffersonville, IN | 5/24/00 |
| 22. | Flash Flanagan | Nick Dinsmore | Jeffersonville, IN | 7/8/00 |
| 23. | Nick Dinsmore | Flash Flanagan | Louisville, KY | 8/4/00 |
| 24. | Rob Conway | Nick Dinsmore | Jeffersonville, IN | 9/6/00 |
| 25. | Nick Dinsmore | Rob Conway | Jeffersonville, IN | 10/25/00 |
| 26. | Rico Constantino | Nick Dinsmore | Louisville, KY | 2/27/01 |
| 27. | Flash Flanagan | Rico Constantino | Louisville, KY | 4/4/00 |
| 28. | Doug Basham | Flash Flanagan | Jeffersonville, IN | 7/25/01 |
| 29. | Leviathan | Doug Basham | Jeffersonville, IN | 11/28/01 |
| 30. | The Prototype | Leviathan | Jeffersonville, IN | 2/20/02 |
| 31. | Nova | The Prototype | Jeffersonville, IN | 5/15/02 |
| 32. | Damaja | Nova | Louisville, KY | 11/6/02 |
| 33. | Nick Dinsmore | Damaja | Louisville, KY | 2/19/03 |
| 34. | Doug Basham | Nick Dinsmore | Louisville, KY | 4/6/03 |
| 35. | Damaja | Doug Basham | Louisville, KY | 6/30/03 |
| 36. | Rob Conway | Damaja | Louisville, KY | 7/30/03 |
| 37. | Johnny Jeter | Rob Conway | Louisville, KY | 8/13/03 |
| 38. | Mark Magnus | Johnny Jeter | Louisville, KY | 10/15/03 |
| 39. | Nick Dinsmore | Johnny Jeter*(4) | Louisville, KY | 1/7/04 |
| 40. | Matt Morgan | Nick Dinsmore | Louisville, KY | 4/14/04 |
| 41. | Chris Cage | Matt Morgan | Louisville, KY | 10/13/04 |
| 42. | Chad Toland | Chris Cage | Louisville, KY | 12/1/04 |
| 43. | Elijah Burke | Chad Toland | Louisville, KY | 12/8/04 |
| 44. | Matt Morgan | Elijah Burke | Louisville, KY | 4/13/05 |
| 45. | Brent Albright | Matt Morgan | Louisville, KY | 4/27/05 |
| 46. | Johnny Jeter | Brent Albright | Louisville, KY | 8/3/05 |
| 47. | Matt Capppotelli | Johnny Jeter | Louisville, KY | 11/9/05 |
| 48. | Brent Albright | CM Punk*(5) | Louisville, KY | 3/1/06 |
| 49. | CM Punk | Brent Albright | Louisville, KY | 6/3/06 |
| 50. | Chet the Jett | CM Punk | Louisville, KY | 8/30/06 |
| 51. | Jacob Duncan | Chet the Jett | Louisville, KY | 10/25/06 |
| 52. | Chet the Jett | Jacob Duncan | Louisville, KY | 12/13/06 |
| 53. | Paul Burchill | Chet the Jett | Louisville, KY | 12/13/06 |
| 54. | Cody Runnels | Paul Burchill | Elizabethtown, KY | 2/17/07 |
| 55. | Paul Burchill | Cody Runnels | Louisville, KY | 2/18/07 |
| 56. | Aaron Stevens | Paul Burchill | Louisville, KY | 3/14/07 |
| 57. | Paul Burchill | Aaron Stevens | Louisville, KY | 5/9/07 |
| 58. | Jay Bradley | Paul Burchill and Aaron Stevens*(6) | Louisville, KY | 6/1/07 |
| 59. | Paul Burchill | Jay Bradley | Louisville, KY | 6/27/07 |
| 60. | Vladimir Kozlov | Paul Burchill | Elizabethtown, KY | 7/28/07 |
| 61. | Michael W. Kruel | Vladimir Kozlov | Elizabethtown, KY | 7/28/07 |
| 62. | Matt Sydal | Michael W. Kruel | Louisville, KY | 12/5/07 |
| 63. | Jay Bradley | Matt Sydal | Louisville, KY | 2/13/08 |
| 64. | Nick Dinsmore | Jay Bradley | Louisville, KY | 2/20/08 |
| 65. | Anthony Bravado | Nick Dinsmore | Louisville, KY | 6/25/08 |
| 66. | Ryback | Anthony Bravado | Louisville, KY | 10/18/08 |
| 67. | Anthony Bravado | Ryback | Louisville, KY | 11/1/08 |
| 68. | Aaron Stevens | Anthony Bravado | Louisville, KY | 11/29/08 |
| 69. | Vaughn Lilas | Aaron Stevens | Louisville, KY | 1/17/09 |
| 70. | Apoc | Vaughn Lilas | Louisville, KY | 2/7/09 |
| 71. | Vaughn Lilas | Apoc | Louisville, KY | 4/25/09 |
| 72. | Apoc | Vaughn Lilas | Louisville, KY | 5/17/09 |
| 73. | Low Rider | Apoc | Louisville, KY | 7/18/09 |
| 74. | Moose | Low Rider | Louisville, KY | 1/6/10 |
| 75. | Beef Wellington | won battle royale*(7) | Louisville, KY | 2/27/10 |
| 76. | Mike Mondo | Beef Wellington | Louisville, KY | 5/29/10 |
| 77. | James Thomas | Mike Mondo | Louisville, KY | 6/16/10 |
| 78. | Low Rider | James Thomas | Louisville, KY | 7/31/10 |
| 79. | Cliff Compton | Low Rider and Mike Mondo*(8) | Louisville, KY | 1/8/11 |
| 80. | Mike Mondo | Cliff Compton and Low Rider*(9) | Louisville, KY | 3/5/11 |
| 81. | Cliff Compton | Mike Mondo*(10) | Louisville, KY | 5/14/11 |
| 82. | Elvis Pridemoore | Cliff Compton | Louisvile, KY | 5/25/11 |
| 83. | Jason Wayne | Mike Mondo*(11) | Louisville, KY | 7/1/11 |
| 84. | Nick Dinsmore | Jason Wayne | Louisville, KY | 10/26/11 |
| 85. | Rudy Switchblade | Nick Dinsmore, Jason Wayne, Adam Revolver, Ted McNaler, James Thomas, Rocco Bellagio and Mike Mondo*(12) | Louisville, KY | 11/2/11 |
| 86. | Johnny Spade | Rudy Switchblade | Louisville, KY | 3/3/12 |
| 87. | Rob Terry | Johnny Spade | Louisville, KY | 5/12/12 |
| 88. | Johnny Spade | Rob Terry*(13) | Louisville, KY | 7/7/12 |
| 89. | Crimson | Johnny Spade | Louisville, KY | 9/12/12 |
| 90. | Rob Terry | Crimson | Louisville, KY | 12/1/12 |
| 91. | Doug Williams | Rob Terry | Louisville, KY | 1/30/13 |
| 92. | Jamin Olivencia | Doug Williams | Louisville, KY | 4/10/13 |
| 93. | Jamin Olivencia | Johnny Spade*(14) | Louisville, KY | 12/7/13 |
| 94. | Marcus Anthony | Jamin Olivencia | Louisville, KY | 1/4/14 |
| 95. | Melvin Maximus | Marcus Anthony | Louisville, KY | 8/2/14 |
*This match determined the first champion.
*(2)The title was vacated, and a battle royale was held to determine a new champion.
*(3)David C. won the belt by forfeit.
*(4)Magnus was pinned by both Nick Dinsmore and Johnny Jeter during a title defense. The belt was held up, and this match determined the new champion.
*(5)Cappotelli gave up the belt after announcing he was retiring due to a brain tumor. This was the finals of a tournament to crown a new champion.
*(6)The belt was held up after a double pin in a title defense. This was a Three Way Match to determine the new champion.
*(7)Moose was stripped of the title for attacking officials. A battle royale was held to crown a new champion.
*(8)This was a Three Way Match.
*(9)This was a Three Way Match.
*(10)Mondo was stripped of the title for attacking OVW President Danny Davis. This was a Brass Knuckles on a Pole Match to determine the new champion.
*(11)Pridemoore gave up the belt after learning he won it due to outside interference. This was the finals of a tournament to crown a new champion.
*(12)This was an Eight Man Melee Match.
*(13)OVW Board of Directors member Ken Wayne vacated all the titles. This was the finals of a Ten Man Gauntlet to determine the new champion.
*(14)The title was vacated by OVW owner Danny Davis. This match determined the new champion.