| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Brent Albright | Seth Skyfire* | Louisville, KY | 1/26/05 |
| 2. | Deuce Shade | Ken Doane*(2) | Louisville, KY | 6/8/05 |
| 3. | Ken Doane | Deuce Shade | Louisville, KY | 6/22/05 |
| 4. | CM Punk | Ken Doane | Louisville, KY | 11/9/05 |
| 5. | Aaron Stevens | CM Punk and Brent Albright*(3) | Louisville, KY | 1/4/06 |
| 6. | Seth Skyfire | Aaron Stevens | Louisville, KY | 3/8/06 |
| 7. | Charles Evans | Seth Skyfire | Louisville, KY | 8/23/06 |
| 8. | Devon Driscoll | Charles Evans | Louisville, KY | 10/11/06 |
| 9. | Charles Evans | Devon Driscoll | Louisville, KY | 11/1/06 |
| 10. | El Aero Fuego | Charles Evans | Louisville, KY | 11/15/06 |
| 11. | Eddie Kraven | El Aero Fuego | Louisville, KY | 1/3/07 |
| 12. | Boris Alexiev | Mike Kruel*(4) | Louisville, KY | 1/24/07 |
| 13. | Mike Kruel | Boris Alexiev | Louisville, KY | 2/7/07 |
| 14. | Boris Alexiev | Mike Kruel | Louisville, KY | 3/14/07 |
| 15. | Shawn Spears | Boris Alexiev | Cincinnati, OH | 3/17/07 |
| 16. | Cody Runnels | Shawn Spears | Louisville, KY | 7/6/07 |
| 17. | Shawn Spears | Cody Runnels | Louisville, KY | 7/13/07 |
| 18. | Ted McNaler | Shawn Spears | Louisville, KY | 9/19/07 |
| 19. | Shawn Spears | Ted McNaler | Louisville, KY | 10/24/07 |
| 20. | Colt Cabana | Shawn Spears | Louisville, KY | 10/31/07 |
| 21. | James Curtis | Colt Cabana | Louisville, KY | 11/14/07 |
| 22. | Jamin Olivencia | James Curtis | Louisville, KY | 2/20/08 |
| 23. | Joey Matthews | Jamin Olivencia | Louisville, KY | 3/12/08 |
| 24. | Tommy McNaler | Joey Matthews | Louisville, KY | 4/16/08 |
| 25. | JD Michaels | Tommy McNaler | Louisville, KY | 6/4/08 |
| 26. | Rudy Switchblade | JD Michaels*(5) | Louisville, KY | 8/27/08 |
| 27. | Jamin Olivencia | N/A*(6) | Louisville, KY | 10/15/08 |
| 28. | Igotta Brewski | Jamin Olivencia | Louisville, KY | 10/15/08 |
| 29. | Outlaw | N/A*(7) | Louisville, KY | 11/26/08 |
| 30. | Johnny Punch | Outlaw | Louisville, KY | 1/14/09 |
| 31. | Mike Mondo | Johnny Punch | Louisville, KY | 2/4/09 |
| 32. | Jamin Olivencia | Mike Mondo | Charlestown, IN | 5/6/09 |
| 33. | El Rojo Uno | Jamin Olivencia | Louisville, KY | 5/13/09 |
| 34. | Jamin Olivencia | El Rojo Uno | Louisville, KY | 6/10/09 |
| 35. | Brent Wellington | Jamin Olivencia | Louisville, KY | 7/22/09 |
| 36. | Moose | Brent Wellington | Louisville, KY | 9/9/09 |
| 37. | Kamikaze Kid | Shiloh*(8) | Louisville, KY | 11/25/09 |
| 38. | Asher Knight | Kamikaze Kid | Louisville, KY | 1/27/10 |
| 39. | Kamikaze Kid | Asher Knight and Shiloh*(9) | Louisville, KY | 2/3/10 |
| 40. | Shiloh Jonze | Kamikaze Kid | Louisville, KY | 2/17/10 |
| 41. | Kamikaze Kid | N/A*(10) | Louisville, KY | 2/24/10 |
| 42. | Jamin Olivencia | Kamikaze Kid | Louisville, KY | 5/7/10 |
| 43. | Ali | Jamin Olivencia | Louisville, KY | 6/4/10 |
| 44. | The Metal Master | Ali | Louisville, KY | 9/15/10 |
| 45. | Mohammed Ali Vaez | The Metal Master | Louisville, KY | 11/3/10 |
| 46. | Alex Silva | Mohammed Ali Vaez | Louisville, KY | 12/11/10 |
| 47. | Mohammed Ali Vaez | Alex Silva | Louisville, KY | 1/26/11 |
| 48. | Rudy Switchblade | Mohammed Ali Vaez | Louisville, KY | 2/23/11 |
| 49. | Mohammed Ali Vaez | Rudy Switchblade | Louisville, KY | 4/2/11 |
| 50. | Jamin Olivencia | Mohammed Ali Vaez | Louisville, KY | 5/14/11 |
| 51. | Rudy Switchblade | Jamin Olivencia | Louisville, KY | 5/25/11 |
| 52. | Paredyse | Rudy Switchblade | Louisville, KY | 7/20/11 |
| 53. | Adam Revolver | Paredyse | Louisville, KY | 9/14/11 |
| 54. | Jason Wayne | Adam Revolver | Louisville, KY | 9/21/11 |
| 55. | Rocco Bellagio | Jason Wayne | Louisville, KY | 10/5/11 |
| 56. | Alex Silva | Rocco Bellagio | Louisville, KY | 11/9/11 |
| 57. | Adam Revolver | Alex Silva | Louisville, KY | 11/16/11 |
| 58. | Ted McNaler | Adam Revolver | Louisville, KY | 12/7/11 |
| 59. | Christopher Silvio | Ted McNaler | Louisville, KY | 12/21/11 |
| 60. | Mohammed Ali Vaez | Christopher Silvio | Louisville, KY | 4/18/12 |
| 61. | Rob Terry | Mohammed Ali Vaez | Rio de Janeiro, Brazil | 4/21/12 |
| 62. | Mohammed Ali Vaez | Rob Terry | Louisville, KY | 4/25/12 |
| 63. | Jamin Olivencia | Mohammed Ali Vaez | Louisville, KY | 6/2/12 |
| 64. | Mohammed Ali Vaez | Jamin Olivencia | Louisville, KY | 6/6/12 |
| 65. | Mohammed Ali Vaez | Flash Flanagan*(11) | Louisville, KY | 7/7/12 |
| 66. | Tony Gunn | N/A*(12) | Louisville, KY | 7/25/12 |
| 67. | Ryan Howe | Tony Gunn and Rob Terry*(13) | Louisville, KY | 8/8/12 |
| 68. | Alex Silva | Ryan Howe | Louisville, KY | 9/12/12 |
| 69. | Cliff Compton | Alex Silva | Louisville, KY | 10/17/12 |
| 70. | Joe Coleman | James Thomas*(14) | Louisville, KY | 11/7/12 |
| 71. | Jamin Olivencia | Joe Coleman | Louisville, KY | 12/1/12 |
| 72. | Cliff Compton | Jamin Olivencia | Louisville, KY | 1/5/13 |
| 73. | Rockstar Spud | Cliff Compton | Louisville, KY | 3/13/13 |
| 74. | Randy Royal | Rockstar Spud | Louisville, KY | 5/11/13 |
| 75. | Dylan Bostic | Randy Royal | Louisville, KY | 7/3/13 |
| 76. | Flash Flanagan | Dylan Bostic and Rudy Switchblade*(15) | Louisville, KY | 8/3/13 |
| 77. | Elijah Burke | Flash Flanagan | Louisville, KY | 9/11/13 |
| 78. | Shiloh Jonze | Elijah Burke | Louisville, KY | 10/5/13 |
| 79. | Paredyse | Shiloh Jonze | Louisville, KY | 11/20/13 |
| 80. | Melvin Maximus | Paredyse | Louisville, KY | 1/4/14 |
| 81. | Adam Revolver | Melvin Maximus | Louisville, KY | 5/15/14 |
| 82. | Melvin Maximus | Adam Revolver | Louisville, KY | 5/21/14 |
| 83. | Adam Revolver | Melvin Maximus | Louisville, KY | 6/11/14 |
| 84. | Michael Hayes | Adam Revolver | Louisville, KY | 8/2/14 |
*This was the finals of a tournament to crown the first champion.
*(2)Albright vacated the title when he won the OVW Heavyweight Championship. This was the finals of a tournament to crown a new champion.
*(3)This was a Three-Way Match.
*(4)Kruel was making title defenses for Kraven, utilizing the Freebird Rule.
*(5)The title was held up due to a double pin between Michaels and Rudy Switchblade. This was the rematch to determine the new champion.
*(6)Olivencia won the title by forfeit due to Switchblade sustaining an injury.
*(7)Outlaw won the title by forfeit when Brewski could not compete due to a backstage attack.
*(8)Moose was stripped of the title after repeated interference by Tilo and Taryn Shay. This was the finals of a tournament to crown a new champion.
*(9)This was a Three-Way Match.
*(10)The title was awarded back to Kamikaze Kid since the referee during the title match was not licensed in the state of Kentucky.
*(11)Vaez was stripped of the title due to the referee helping him to win it. This match determined the new champion.
*(12)Gunn won the title by forfeit after Rob Terry attacked Vaez, and he was unable to compete.
*(13)This was a Three-Way Match.
*(14)Compton vacated the title due to an injury. This match determined the new champion.
*(15)This was a Three-Way Match.
*(13)