| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | ODB | N/A* | Rio de Janeiro, Brazil | 7/12/06 |
| 2. | Serena | ODB, Katie Lea and Beth Phoenix*(2) | Louisville, KY | 9/13/06 |
| 3. | Beth Phoenix | Serena | Louisville, KY | 10/4/06 |
| 4. | Katie Lea | Serena*(3) | Louisville, KY | 11/1/06 |
| 5. | ODB | Katie Lea | Louisville, KY | 6/1/07 |
| 6. | Roucka | ODB, Serena, Melody, Josie and Katie Lea*(4) | Louisville, KY | 9/19/07 |
| 7. | Katie Lea | Roucka | Louisville, KY | 2/20/08 |
| 8. | Josie | Katie Lea | Louisville, KY | 2/27/08 |
| 9. | Serena | Josie | Louisville, KY | 5/23/08 |
| 10. | Josie | Serena | Louisville, KY | 7/2/08 |
| 11. | Serena | Josie | Louisville, KY | 7/2/08 |
| 12. | Reggie | Serena | Louisville, KY | 7/16/08 |
| 13. | Serena | Reggie | Louisville, KY | 7/16/08 |
| 14. | The Baroness | Serena and Josie*(5) | Louisville, KY | 7/24/08 |
| 15. | Serena | The Baroness | Louisville, KY | 7/24/08 |
| 16. | Josie | Serena | Louisville, KY | 7/31/08 |
| 17. | Serena | Josie | Louisville, KY | 8/7/08 |
| 18. | Melody | Serena, Josie and Reggie*(6) | Louisville, KY | 11/12/08 |
| 19. | Epiphany | Melody | Louisville, KY | 8/12/09 |
| 20. | Hannah Blossom | Epiphany | Louisville, KY | 10/7/09 |
| 21. | Josie | Hannah Blossom | Louisville, KY | 11/28/09 |
| 22. | Hannah Blossom | N/A*(7) | Louisville, KY | 12/2/09 |
| 23. | Josie | Hannah Blossom | Louisville, KY | 12/16/09 |
| 24. | CJ Lane | Josie | Louisville, KY | 3/27/10 |
| 25. | Taryn Shay | CJ Lane | Louisville, KY | 6/26/10 |
| 26. | Holly Blossom | Taryn Shay | Louisville, KY | 7/31/10 |
| 27. | Lady JoJo | Holly Blossom | Louisville, KY | 8/28/10 |
| 28. | Izza Belle Smothers | Lady JoJo | Louisville, KY | 8/6/11 |
| 29. | Lady JoJo | Izza Belle Smothers | Louisville, KY | 8/24/11 |
| 30. | Taeler Hendrix | Lady JoJo | Louisville, KY | 11/12/11 |
| 31. | Epiphany | Taeler Hendrix | Louisville, KY | 6/2/12 |
| 32. | Taeler Hendrix | Epiphany*(8) | Louisville, KY | 7/7/12 |
| 33. | Heidi Lovelace | Taeler Hendrix | Elizabethtown, KY | 9/15/12 |
| 34. | Taryn Terrell | Heidi Lovelace | Louisville, KY | 11/14/12 |
| 35. | Taeler Hendrix | Taryn Terrell | Louisville, KY | 12/1/12 |
| 36. | Jessie Belle | Taeler Hendrix | Louisville, KY | 1/5/13 |
| 37. | Epiphany | Jessie Belle | Louisville, KY | 3/2/13 |
| 38. | Trina Thompson | Epiphany | Louisville, KY | 4/17/13 |
| 39. | Hannah Blossom | Holly Blossom, Lei'D Tapa and Taeler Hendrix*(9) | Louisville, KY | 9/18/13 |
| 40. | Lei'D Tapa | Hannah Blossom | Louisville, KY | 10/5/13 |
| 41. | The Bodyguy | Lei'D Tapa | Louisville, KY | 12/7/13 |
| 42. | Lei'D Tapa | The Bodyguy | Louisville, KY | 1/4/14 |
| 43. | Jessie Belle | Lei'D Tapa | Louisville, KY | 3/1/14 |
| 44. | Lei'D Tapa | Jessie Belle | Louisville, KY | 4/6/14 |
*ODB appointed herself the inaugural champion.
*(2)This was a Fatal Four Way Match.
*(3)This was the finals of an eight woman Gauntlet Match.
*(4)This was a Six Way Match.
*(5)This was a Three Way Match.
*(6)This was a Four Way Match.
*(7)The title was awarded back to Hannah after it was revealed that Josie pinned her sister Holly in their match.
*(8)OVW Board of Directors member Ken Wayne vacated all the titles. This match determined the new champion.
*(9)Thompson vacated the title due to injury. This was a Fatal Four Way Ladder Match to determine the new champion.