| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Davey Andrews | Derrick Dempsey and Shane Hagadorn* | Detroit, MI | 11/4/05 |
| 2. | Derrick Dempsey | Shane Hagadorn, Bobby Dempsey and Pelle Primeau** | Philadelphia, PA | 1/14/06 |
| 3. | Shane Hagadorn | Derrick Dempsey | East Windsor, CT | 6/3/06 |
| 4. | Pelle Primeau | Shane Hagadorn | Edison, NJ | 4/14/07 |
| 5. | Mitch Franklin | Pelle Primeau | Hartford, CT | 8/24/07 |
| 6. | Ernie Osiris | Mitch Franklin | Philadelphia, PA | 11/2/07 |
| 7. | Rhett Titus | Ernie Osiris | Philadelphia, PA | 6/7/08 |
*This was a Three Way Match to determine the first trophy holder.
*The trophy was vacated when Ricky Reyes destroyed it on December 17. This was a Four Way Match to determine the new trophy holder.
Title Defenses
1. Davey Andrews
---pinned Pelle Primeau, Steel Cage Warfare: 12/3/05
2. Derrick Dempsey
---pinned Shane Hagadorn, Unscripted II: 2/11/06
---pinned Pelle Primeau, Better Than Our Best: 4/1/06
---pinned Pelle Primeau, The 100th Show: 4/22/06
3. Shane Hagadorn
---submitted Mitch Franklin, In Your Face: 6/17/06
---pinned Smash Bradley, Time to Man Up: 8/4/06
---submitted Pelle Primeau, Gut Check: 8/26/06
---submitted Pelle Primeau, Survival of the Fittest: 10/6/06
---submitted Pelle Primeau, Honor Reclaims Boston: 11/3/06
---submitted Rhett Titus, Black Friday Fallout: 11/24/06
---pinned Bobby Dempsey, Dethroned: 11/25/06
---submitted Alex Payne, Fifth Year Festival - Philly: 2/17/07
---submitted Ernie Osiris, Fifth Year Festival - Dayton: 2/23/07
4. Pelle Primeau
---beat Rhett Titus, Mitch Franklin and Alex Payne in a Four Way Match, Domination: 6/9/07
5. Mitch Franklin
---pinned Alex Payne, Man Up: 9/15/07
6. Ernie Osiris
---pinned Mitch Franklin, Unscripted III: 12/1/07
---beat Alex Payne and Rhett Titus in a Three Way Match, Bedlam in Beantown: 4/11/08
---pinned Mitch Franklin, Up For Grabs: 6/6/08
7. Rhett Titus
---N/A