| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Nicole Savoy | Candice LaRae and Heidi Lovelace* | Dallas, TX | 4/2/16 |
| 2. | Shazza McKenzie | Nicole Savoy | Berwyn, IL | 7/8/17 |
| 3. | Dust | Shazza McKenzie | Berwyn, IL | 4/15/18 |
| 4. | Samantha Heights | Dust | Woodside, NY | 4/5/19 |
| 5. | Hyan | Rhia O'Reilly and Kris Statlander** | Berwyn, IL | 11/3/19 |
*This was a Three Way Elimination Match, and the finals of a tournament to crown the first champion.
**Heights had to vacate the title due to injury. This was the final match of a tournament to crown an interim champion. Later, Hyan would go on to defeat Thunderkitty in order to become the undisputed champion.
Title Defenses
1. Nicole Savoy
---pinned Ryo Mizunami, SHIMMER Volume 82: 6/25/16
---pinned Shayna Baszler, SHIMMER Volume 83: 6/25/16
---pinned Jessicka Havok, SHIMMER Volume 84: 6/26/16
---pinned Kay Lee Ray, SHIMMER Volume 85: 6/26/16
2. Shazza McKenzie
---pinned Rosemary, SHIMMER Volume 94: 7/9/17
---pinned Nicole Matthews, SHIMMER Volume 95: 7/9/17
---pinned Cheerleader Melissa, SHIMMER Volume 96: 11/11/17
---pinned Kellyanne, SHIMMER Volume 97: 11/11/17
---no contest against Allysin Kay, SHIMMER Volume 98: 11/12/17
---submitted Veda Scott, SHIMMER Volume 99: 11/12/17
---pinned Tessa Blanchard, SHIMMER Volume 100: 4/7/18
---pinned Shotzi Blackheart, SHIMMER Volume 101: 4/14/18
---pinned Hudson Envy, SHIMMER Volume 102: 4/14/18
---pinned Zoe Lucas, SHIMMER Volume 103: 4/15/18
3. Dust
---pinned Madison Rayne, SHIMMER Volume 105: 10/20/18
---pinned Rachael Ellering, SHIMMER Volume 106: 10/20/18
---pinned Samantha Heights, SHIMMER Volume 107: 10/21/18
---pinned Willow Nightingale, SHIMMER Volume 108: 10/21/18
---pinned Leva Bates, SHIMMER Volume 109: 3/30/19
---pinned Solo Darling, SHIMMER Volume 110: 3/30/19
---lost to Samantha Heights by DQ, SHIMMER Volume 112: 3/31/19
4. Samantha Heights
---pinned Shazza McKenzie, GPW Special Champions Edition: 6/2/19
5. Hyan
---pinned Holidead, SHIMMER Volume 117: 11/3/19
---pinned Thunderkitty, SHIMMER Volume 118: 10/11/20