| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Ashley Lane & Nevaeh | Lexie Fyfe & Malia Hosaka (The Experience)* | Berwyn, IL | 10/19/08 |
| 2. | Portia Perez & Nicole Matthews (The Canadian Ninjas) | Ashley Lane & Nevaeh | Berwyn, IL | 5/3/09 |
| 3. | Hiroyo Matsumoto & Misaki Ohata (The Seven Star Sisters) | The Canadian Ninjas | Berwyn, IL | 3/26/11 |
| 4. | Daizee Haze & Tomoka Nakagawa | The Seven Star Sisters | Berwyn, IL | 3/27/11 |
| 5. | Ayumi Kurihara & Ayako Hamada | Daizee Haze & Tomoka Nakagawa | Berwyn, IL | 10/1/11 |
| 6. | Sara Del Rey & Courtney Rush (The Queens of Winning) | Ayumi Kurihara & Ayako Hamada, Allison Danger & Leva Bates (Regeneration X) and The Canadian Ninjas** | Berwyn, IL | 3/18/12 |
| 7. | The Canadian Ninjas | The Queens of Winning | Montreal, QB | 7/7/12 |
| 8. | Kellie Skater & Tomoka Nakagawa (The Global Green Gangsters) | The Canadian Ninjas | Berwyn, IL | 4/14/13 |
| 9. | Kimber Lee & Cherry Bomb (The Kimber Bombs) | The Global Green Gangsters | Berwyn, IL | 4/11/15 |
| 10. | Heidi Lovelace & Evie (Slap Happy) | The Kimber Bombs, KC Spinelli & Xandra Bale and Kay Lee Ray & Mia Yim*** | Berwyn, IL | 6/26/16 |
| 11. | Tessa Blanchard & Vanessa Kraven (Mount Tessa) | Slap Happy | Berwyn, IL | 11/13/16 |
| 12. | Delilah Doom & Leva Bates (Totally Tubular Tag Team) | Mount Tessa | Berwyn, IL | 11/11/17 |
| 13. | Cheerleader Melissa & Mercedes Martinez | Totally Tubular Tag Team, Charli Evans & Jessica Troy (Blue Nation) and Jessicka Havok & Nevaeh (Killer Death Machines)**** | Berwyn, IL | 10/21/18 |
| 14. | Ashley Vox & Delmi Exo (Team Sea Stars) | Cheerleader Melissa & Mercedes Martinez | Berwyn, IL | 11/2/19 |
*This was the final match in a Gauntlet series to determine the first SHIMMER Tag Team Champions.
**This was a Four Way Elimination Match.
***This was a Four Way Elimination Match.
****This was a Four Way Elimination Match.
Title Defenses:
1. Ashley Lane & Nevaeh
---pinned Portia Perez & Nicole Matthews, SHIMMER Volume 22: 10/19/08
---pinned Sassy Stephie & Hellena Heavenly, IPW Insane Intentions: 11/1/08
---pinned Hailey Hatred & Mary Elizabeth, HWA High Def: 11/22/08
---beat Rain & Jetta in a 2 out of 3 Falls Match, SHIMMER Volume 23: 5/2/09
---beat Sara Del Rey & Amazing Kong by DQ, SHIMMER Volume 25: 5/3/09
2. The Canadian Ninjas
---beat Rachel Summerlyn & Jessica James by DQ, ACW A Nightmare on 10th Street: 10/18/09
---pinned MsChif & Cheerleader Melissa, SHIMMER Volume 29: 4/10/10
---pinned Nikki Roxx & Ariel, SHIMMER Volume 31: 4/11/10
---pinned Rachel Summerlyn & Jessica James, SHIMMER Volume 34: 9/11/10
---pinned Jessie McKay & Tenille, SHIMMER Volume 36: 9/12/10
3. Hiroyo Matsumoto & Misaki Ohata
---pinned Britani & Saraya Knight, SHIMMER Volume 38: 3/26/11
---pinned Nikki Roxx & Ariel, SHIMMER Volume 39: 3/27/11
4. Daizee Haze & Tomoka Nakagawa
---pinned Ayumi Kurihara & Hiroyo Matsumoto, ROH Honor Takes Center Stage - Night 2: 4/2/11
5. Ayumi Kurihara & Ayako Hamada
---pinned Britani & Saraya Knight, SHIMMER Volume 42: 10/1/11
---pinned Sara Del Rey & Madison Eagles, SHIMMER Volume 43: 10/2/11
---pinned Portia Perez & Nicole Matthews, SHIMMER Volume 44: 10/2/11
---pinned Allison Danger & Leva Bates, SHIMMER Volume 45: 3/17/12
---pinned Hailey Hatred & Kalamity, SHIMMER Volume 46: 3/17/12
---pinned RAY & LEON, SHIMMER Volume 47: 3/18/12
6. The Queens of Winning
---N/A
7. The Canadian Ninjas
---pinned LuFisto & Kana, SHIMMER Volume 49: 10/27/12
---pinned Allison Danger & Leva Bates, SHIMMER Volume 52: 10/28/12
---beat LuFisto & Kana, Taylor Made & Allysin Kay and Tomoka Nakagawa & Kellie Skater in a Four Way Match, SHIMMER Volume 53: 4/6/13
---lost to Kellie Skater & Tomoka Nakagawa by CO, SHIMMER Volume 54: 4/13/13
---lost to Shazza McKenzie & Veda Scott by DQ, SHIMMER Volume 55: 4/13/13
8. Global Green Gangsters
---pinned Kana & LuFisto, SHIMMER Volume 58: 10/19/13
---pinned Allysin Kay & Taylor Made, SHIMMER Volume 59: 10/19/13
---pinned Sassy Stephie & Nevaeh, SHIMMER Volume 60: 10/20/13
---pinned Kimber Lee & Cherry Bomb, SHIMMER Volume 61: 10/20/13
---pinned Allysin Kay & Ivelisse Velez, SHINE 14: 10/25/13
---pinned Nicole Matthews & Madison Eagles, SHIMMER Volume 62: 4/5/14
---pinned RAY & LEON, SHIMMER Volume 64: 4/12/14
---pinned Rhia O'Reilly & Saraya Knight, SHIMMER Volume 65: 4/13/14
---pinned Cheerleader Melissa & Mercedes Martinez, SHIMMER Volume 66: 4/13/14
---pinned Tsukasa Fujimoto & Kaori Yoneyama, SHIMMER Volume 68: 10/18/14
---pinned Mayumi Ozaki & Saraya Knight, SHIMMER Volume 69: 10/19/14
---beat Nicole Matthews & Portia Perez by DQ, SHIMMER Volume 70: 10/19/14
---DCO against Kimber Lee & Cherry Bomb, SHINE 26: 4/3/15
9. The Kimber Bombs
---pinned Courtney Rush & Xandra Bale, SHIMMER Volume 73: 4/11/15
---pinned Kay Lee Ray & Mia Yim, SHIMMER Volume 82: 6/25/16
---pinned KC Spinelli & Xandra Bale, SHIMMER Volume 83: 6/25/16
10. Slap Happy
---pinned Melanie Cruise & Yumi Ohka, SHIMMER Volume 85: 6/26/16
---pinned Kay Lee Ray & Mia Yim, SHIMMER Volume 86: 11/11/16
---pinned Christina Von Eerie & Hudson Envy, SHIMMER Volume 87: 11/12/16
11. Mount Tessa
---pinned KC Spinelli & Xandra Bale, SHIMMER Volume 90: 11/13/16
---pinned Mia Yim & Kay Lee Ray, SHIMMER Volume 91: 4/1/17
---pinned Mia Yim & Kay Lee Ray, SHIMMER Volume 92: 7/8/17
---pinned Jessicka Havok & Nevaeh, SHIMMER Volume 93: 7/8/17
---beat Leva Bates & Delilah Doom, Britt Baker & Chelsea Green and Rosemary & Angel Dust in a Four Way Match, SHIMMER Volume 95: 7/9/17
12. Totally Tubular Tag Team
---pinned Deonna Purrazzo & Ashley Lane, SHIMMER Volume 98: 11/12/17
---pinned Rosemary & Dust, SHIMMER Volume 99: 11/12/17
---pinned LuFisto & Hudson Envy, SHIMMER Volume 100: 4/7/18
---pinned Charli Evans & Jessica Troy, SHIMMER Volume 101: 4/14/18
---pinned Dynamite DiDi & Kikyo, SHIMMER Volume 103: 4/15/18
---no contest against Leva Bates & Delilah Doom, SHIMMER Volume 106: 10/20/18
13. Cheerleader Melissa & Mercedes Martinez
---pinned Ashley Vox & Delmi Exo, SHIMMER Volume 109: 3/30/19
---lost to DASH Chisako & Hiroyo Matsumoto by DQ, SHIMMER Volume 111: 3/31/19
---pinned Thunder Rosa & Holidead, SHIMMER Volume 113: 4/5/19
---pinned Big Swole & Nicole Savoy, SHIMMER Volume 114: 11/2/19
14. Team Sea Stars
---pinned Charli Evans & Jessica Troy, SHIMMER Volume 116: 11/3/19
---pinned Solo Darling & Willing Nightingale, SHIMMER Volume 117: 11/3/19
---pinned Allysin Kay & Marti Belle, SHIMMER Volume 118: 10/11/20