| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Leva Bates & Mia Yim (The Lucha Sisters) | Allysin Kay & Taylor Made (Made in Sin)* | Ybor City, FL | 2/28/14 |
| 2. | Malia Hosaka & Brandi Wine (Legendary) | The Lucha Sisters | Ybor City, FL | 6/27/14 |
| 3. | Kimber Lee & Cherry Bomb (The Kimber Bombs) | Legendary | Ybor City, FL | 3/6/15 |
| 4. | Jayme Jameson & Marti Belle (Better Than You) | The Lucha Sisters** | Ybor City, FL | 12/11/15 |
| 5. | Santana Garrett & Raquel | Better Than You | Ybor City, FL | 12/16/16 |
| 6. | Mercedes Martinez & Ivelisse (Las Sicarias) | Santana Garrett & Raquel | Ybor City, FL | 5/12/17 |
| 7. | Thunder Rosa & Holidead (Twisted Sisterz) | Las Sicarias, Kiera Hogan & Dementia D'Rose (The Cutie Pie Club) and Aja Perera & Aerial Monroe (#Team SPAM)*** | Ybor City, FL | 7/20/18 |
| 8. | Gabby Gilbert & Luscious Latasha (Rainbow Bright) | Twisted Sisterz | Woodside, NY | 1/19/19 |
| 9. | Aja Perera & Big Swole (Team Aye) | Rainbow Bright | New York, NY | 9/21/19 |
| 10. | Jayme Jameson & Marti Belle (BTY) | Team Aye | Fern Park, FL | 1/18/20 |
*This was the finals of a tournament to crown the first champions.
**Cherry Bomb suffered a shoulder injury and they had to vacated the tag belts. This was the finals of a tournament to crown new champions.
***This was a Four Way Elimination Match.
Title Defenses
1. The Lucha Sisters
---pinned Sassy Stephie & Nevaeh, 2014 - A Wrestling Odyssey: 4/4/14
---pinned Kellie Skater & Evie, SHINE 18: 4/18/14
2. Legendary
---pinned Leva Bates & Mia Yim, SHINE 21: 8/22/14
---pinned Kimber Lee & Cherry Bomb, SHINE 23: 12/5/14
3. The Kimber Bombs
---DCO against Kelly Skater & Tomoka Nakagawa, SHINE 26: 4/3/15
---pinned Brandi Wine & Malia Hosaka, SHINE 27: 5/15/15
---no contest against Marti Belle & Andrea, SHINE 28: 7/24/15
4. Better Than You
---pinned Ivelisse Velez & Amanda Carolina Rodriguez, SHINE 33: 2/27/16
---pinned Shazza McKenzie & Evie, SHINE 35: 6/17/16
---pinned Amanda Carolina Rodriguez & La Rosa Negra, SHINE 36: 7/22/16
---pinned Dominique Fabiano & Priscilla Kelly, SHINE 37: 9/2/16
5. Santana Garrett & Raquel
---beat Amber O'Neal & Kennadi Brink and Amanda Carolina Rodriguez & Thea Trinidad in a Three Way Match, SHINE 40: 1/13/17