| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Rain | Mia Yim* | Ybor City, FL | 7/12/13 |
| 2. | Ivelisse Velez | Rain | Ybor City, FL | 1/24/14 |
| 3. | Mia Yim | Ivelisse Velez | Beijing, China | 11/16/14 |
| 4. | Santana Garrett | Mia Yim | Ybor City, FL | 4/3/15 |
| 5. | Taylor Made | Santana Garrett | Ybor City, FL | 12/11/15 |
| 6. | Ivelisse Velez | Taylor Made, Allysin Kay and Madison Eagles** | Ybor City, FL | 6/17/16 |
| 7. | LuFisto | Allysin Kay and Mercedes Martinez*** | Ybor City, FL | 1/13/17 |
| 8. | Allysin Kay | Mercedes Martinez**** | New York, NY | 9/8/17 |
| 9. | Miyu Yamashita | Allysin Kay | New York, NY | 4/5/19 |
| 10. | Allysin Kay | Miyu Yamashita | Sapporo, Japan | 5/6/19 |
| 11. | Mercedes Martinez | Allysin Kay | Livonia, MI | 12/13/19 |
| 12. | Ivelisse Velez | Mercedes Martinez | Chicago, IL | 12/14/19 |
*This was the final round of a tournament to crown the first SHINE Champion.
**This was a Four Way Match.
***Velez had to vacate the title due to injury. This was a Three Way Match to determine a new champion.
****LuFisto gave up the title due to health reasons. This was the finals of a tournament to crown the new champion.
Title Defenses
1. Rain
---pinned Jessicka Havok, SHINE 12: 8/23/13
---pinned Angelina Love, SHINE 13: 9/27/13
---pinned Hiroyo Matsumoto, SHINE 14: 10/25/13
---pinned Amazing Kong, SHINE 15: 12/13/13
2. Ivelisse Velez
---pinned Mercedes Martinez, SHINE 17: 2/28/14
---pinned Leva Bates, FIP Everything Burns: 3/14/14
---pinned Jazz, 2014 - A Wrestling Odyssey: 4/4/14
---pinned Mercedes Martinez, DGUSA Mercury Rising: 4/5/14
---pinned Saraya Knight, SHINE 18: 4/18/14
---no contest against Mia Yim, FIP Accelerate: 5/3/14
---pinned La Rosa Negra, FIP Heatstroke: 8/9/14
---pinned Nevaeh, SHINE 21: 8/22/14
---pinned Su Yung, WWN Live! in Grand Epoch City: 11/10/14
---pinned Allysin Kay, WWN Live! in Chengdu: 11/12/14
3. Mia Yim
---lost to Nevaeh by DQ, SHINE 23: 12/5/14
---pinned Santana Garrett, SHINE 24: 1/23/15
---beat Nevaeh in a 2 out of 3 Falls Match, SHINE 25: 3/6/15
4. Santana Garrett
---pinned Mia Yim, SHINE 27: 5/15/15
---beat Ivelisse Velez by ref stoppage, SHINE 28: 7/24/15
---pinned Allysin Kay, SHINE 29: 9/4/15
---pinned Evie, SHINE 30: 10/2/15
5. Taylor Made
---pinned Nicole Matthews, WWN Mercury Rising: 4/2/16
---beat Jessicka Havok by DQ, SHINE 34: 4/15/16
6. Ivelisse Velez
---submitted Su Yung, SHINE 36: 7/22/16
---pinned LuFisto, SHINE 37: 9/2/16
---submitted Vanessa Kraven, SHINE 38: 11/5/16
w/Mercedes Martinez, Amanda Carolina Rodriguez & Thea Trinidad beat LuFisto, Amber O'Neal, Kennadi Brink & Andrea in an Eight-Woman Tag Team Match, SHINE 39: 12/16/16
7. LuFisto