| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Luscious Latasha | Amber, Roxie Cotton and Jana* | Belleville, NJ | 8/14/09 |
| 2. | Jana | Luscious Latasha and Lea Morrison** | Union City, NJ | 10/3/09 |
| 3. | Luscious Latasha | Jana | Union City, NJ | 10/10/09 |
| 4. | Britney Savage | Luscious Latasha and Becky Bayless*** | Union City, NJ | 10/10/09 |
| 5. | Alicia | Britney Savage | Flemington, NJ | 12/12/09 |
| 6. | Britney Savage | Alicia | Union City, NJ | 3/6/10 |
| 7. | Alicia | Britney Savage | Middletown, NJ | 8/6/10 |
| 8. | Britney Savage | Alicia | Union City, NJ | 8/6/10 |
| 9. | Sassy Stephanie | Britney Savage | Union City, NJ | 3/5/11 |
| 10. | Rain | Sassy Stephanie | Fairless Hills, PA | 9/24/11 |
| 11. | Jessicka Havok | Rain | Fairless Hills, PA | 9/24/11 |
| 12. | Marti Belle | Jessicka Havok | Deer Park, NY | 6/17/12 |
| 13. | Niya | Marti Belle | Voorhees, NJ | 2/8/14 |
| 14. | Nevaeh | Niya | Philadelphia, PA | 2/21/15 |
| 15. | Leva Bates | Hania the Howling Huntress*(4) | Philadelphia, PA | 7/11/15 |
| 16. | Su Yung | Leva Bates | Voorhees, NJ | 11/19/16 |
| 17. | Kiera Hogan | Su Yung and Veda Scott*(5) | Voorhees, NJ | 2/11/17 |
| 18. | Jordynne Grace | Kiera Hogan | Voorhees, NJ | 6/16/18 |
| 19. | Kris Statlander | Jordynne Grace | Voorhees, NJ | 3/2/19 |
| 20. | Davienne | Kris Statlander | Voorhees, NJ | 9/7/19 |
*This was the finals of a tournament to crown the first Spirit Champion.
*(2)This was a Triple Threat Match.
*(3)This was a Triple Threat Match.
*(4)The title was vacated due to injury. This match determined the new champion.
*(5)This was a Three-Way Match.
Title Defenses:
1. Luscious Latasha
---pinned Jana, No Limits: 8/22/09
---pinned Amber, As the World Turns: 8/22/09
---beat Lea Morrison by DQ, Excellence: 10/3/09
2. Jana
---N/A
3. Luscious Latasha
---N/A
4. Brittney Savage
---N/A
5. Alicia
---N/A
6. Brittney Savage
---pinned Tina San Antonio, King & Queen of the Ring: 4/3/10
---pinned Becky Bayless, Uncensored Rumble: 6/26/10
7. Alicia
---N/A
8. Brittney Savage
---pinned Sassy Stephanie, Breaking Barriers: 11/6/10
9. Sassy Stephanie
---pinned Jana, IndyMania: 4/3/11
---pinned Amber, Martinez vs. Lexxus: 8/6/11
---no contest against Allysin Kay, Havok vs. Alicia III: 8/6/11
10. Rain
---N/A
11. Jessicka Havok
---pinned Becky Bayless, Blitzkrieg: 1/21/12
---pinned Mercedes Martinez, 5th Anniversary Show: 3/3/12
---pinned Marti Belle, King & Queen of the Ring: 4/14/12
---pinned Marti Belle, Y.O.L.O.: 4/28/12
12. Marti Belle
---pinned Nikki Addams, Full Steam Ahead: 10/13/12
---pinned Ezavel Suena, Blood and Thunder: 10/12/13
13. Niya