| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Roxie Cotton & Annie Social (The Beatdown Betties) | Amy Lee & Missy Sampson* | Boonton, NJ | 10/11/08 |
| 2. | Amy Lee & Taylor Wilde | The Beatdown Betties | Boonton, NJ | 1/10/09 |
| 3. | The Beatdown Betties | Amy Lee & Taylor Wilde, Lea Morrison & Kylie Pierce and Alere Little Feather & Missy Sampson*(2) | Boonton, NJ | 1/10/09 |
| 4. | Miss April & Brooke Carter (The AC Express) | The Beatdown Betties | Edison, NJ | 2/7/09 |
| 5. | Alicia & Brooke Carter*(3) | N/A | Boonton, NJ | 6/6/09 |
| 6. | Hailey Hatred & Jessicka Havok | Alicia & Brooke Carter | Boonton, NJ | 8/22/09 |
| 7. | Angel Orsini & Mercedes Martinez | Hailey Hatred & Jessicka Havok | Union City, NJ | 11/7/09 |
| 8. | Cindy Rogers & Jana (The Cosmo Club) | Angel Orsini & Mercedes Martinez | Port Jefferson Station, NY | 3/6/10 |
| 9. | Marti Belle & Tina San Antonio (The Belle Saints) | The Cosmo Club | Union City, NJ | 11/6/10 |
| 10. | Marti Belle & Jazz | Amy Lee & Cindy Rogers and Jana & Luscious Latasha*(4) | Union City, NJ | 3/5/11 |
| 11. | Amber & Lexxus (The Boston Shore) | Marti Belle & Jazz | New York, NY | 5/27/11 |
| 12. | Jana & Luscious Latasha (The Soul Sisters) | Lexxus & Tina San Antonio*(5) | Deer Park, NY | 3/3/12 |
| 13. | Sassy Stephanie & Allysin Kay (The Midwest Militia) | The Soul Sisters | Deer Park, NY | 3/3/12 |
| 14. | Annie Social & Kimber Lee (Chicks Using Nasty Tactics) | Sassy Stephanie & Jessicka Havok*(6) | Voorhees, NJ | 2/8/14 |
| 15. | David Starr & JT Dunn (Juicy Product) | Chicks Using Nasty Tactics | Voorhees, NJ | 7/12/14 |
| 16. | Chicks Using Nasty Tactics | Juicy Product | Philadelphia, PA | 2/21/15 |
| 17. | Eddy McQueen & Rick Cataldo (The Fella Twins) | Annie Social & Gabby Gilbert*(7) | Voorhees, NJ | 2/13/16 |
| 18. | Penelope Ford & Maria Manic (Ruthless Ambition) | The Fella Twins | Voorhees, NJ | 5/13/17 |
| 19. | Angel Sinclair & Ava Everett (The Platinum Hunnies) | Megan Mason & Davienne (The Endless) and Gabby Gilbert & Luscious Latasha (Rainbow Bright)*(8) | Voorhees, NJ | 4/26/19 |
| 20. | Delmi Exo & Kasey Catal | Ava Everett & Candy Cartwright*(9) | Voorhees, NJ | 8/3/19 |
| 21. | Ruthless Lala & Su Yung | Delmi Exo & Kasey Catal< | Voorhees, NJ | 12/28/19 |
*This was the finals of a tournament to crown the first tag team champions.
*(2)This was a Four Corners Match.
*(3)When Miss April was signed by WWE, Carter was allowed to choose a replacement for her team.
*(4)The titles were vacated when San Antonio suffered an ankle injury. This match was a Triple Threat match to determine new champions.
*(5)When Amber left the pro wrestling business, Lexxus was allowed to hold onto the titles until she could find a replacement.
*(6)Havok substituted for Allysin Kay for this title defense.
*(7)Gilbert replaced Kimber Lee in the title defense.
*(8)The titles were vacated when Manic decided to go for the WSU Title. This was a Three-Way tournament final to determine new champions.
*(9)Cartwright was brought on as a trial member of the team and took Sinclair's place in the title defense.
Title Defenses:
1. The Beatdown Betties
---pinned Jana & Luscious Latasha, NWS Wrestling Academy Show: 11/29/08
2. Amy Lee & Taylor Wilde
---N/A
3. The Beatdown Betties
---N/A
4. The AC Express
---pinned Rick Cataldo & Roxie Cotton, 2nd Anniversary Show: 3/7/09
5. Brooke Carter & Alicia
---pinned Hailey Hatred & Jessika Havok, Uncensored Rumble II: 6/6/09
---beat Angel Orsini & Rain by DQ, No Limits: 8/22/09
6. Hailey Hatred & Jessika Havok
---pinned Brooke Carter & Alicia, Excellence: 10/3/09
---no contest against Angel Orsini & Mercedes Martinez, Raining Misery: 10/3/09
7. Angel Orsini & Mercedes Martinez
---N/A
8. The Cosmo Club
---pinned Divina Fly & Niya, Uncensored Rumble III: 6/26/10
9. The Belle Saints
---pinned Jamilia Craft & Jennifer Cruz, Martinez vs. Rain II: 11/6/10
---pinned Jennifer Cruz & Monique, Alicia vs. Roxx II: 12/11/10
10. Marti Belle & Jazz
---N/A
11. The Boston Shore
---pinned Marti Belle & Tina San Antonio, Uncensored Rumble IV: 6/25/11
---pinned Jessie Brooks & Jana, Alicia vs. Havok III: 8/6/11
---pinned Rain & Jetta, Breaking Barriers II: 11/19/11
12. The Soul Sisters
---N/A
13. The Midwest Militia
---pinned Brittney Savage & Alicia, King & Queen of the Ring: 4/14/12
---pinned Jana & Luscious Latasha, 6th Annual J-Cup: 4/28/12
Chicks Using Nasty Tactics
---pinned Christina Von Eerie & Nevaeh, Mutiny: 2/8/14
---pinned Rick Cataldo & Veda Scott, United: 7/12/14
14. Juicy Product
---pinned Annie Social & Kimber Lee, Resurgence: 9/13/14
15. Chicks Using Nasty Tactics