| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Alicia | Luna Vachon, Amy Lee and Nikki Roxx* | Lake Hiawatha, NJ | 7/14/07 |
| 2. | Alexa Thatcher | Alicia | Belleville, NJ | 8/17/07 |
| 3. | Alicia | Alexa Thatcher | Neptune, NJ | 8/18/07 |
| 4. | Tammy Sytch | Alicia | Lake Hiawatha, NJ | 12/22/07 |
| 5. | Nikki Roxx | Tammy Sytch and Alexa Thatcher** | Bergenfield, NJ | 3/21/08 |
| 6. | Angel Orsini | Nikki Roxx | Rahway, NJ | 5/31/08 |
| 7. | Mercedes Martinez | Angel Orsini | Boonton, NJ | 3/7/09 |
| 8. | Jessicka Havok | Mercedes Martinez | Deer Park, NY | 3/3/12 |
| 9. | Mercedes Martinez | Jessicka Havok | Deer Park, NY | 4/28/12 |
| 10. | Jessicka Havok | Mercedes Martinez and Britney Savage*** | Deer Park, NY | 4/28/12 |
| 11. | LuFisto | Athena**** | Voorhees, NJ | 5/10/14 |
| 12. | Cherry Bomb | LuFisto | Voorhees, NJ | 5/9/15 |
| 13. | Mercedes Martinez | Cherry Bomb | Voorhees, NJ | 2/11/17 |
| 14. | Tessa Blanchard | Mercedes Martinez | Voorhees, NJ | 6/16/18 |
| 15. | Kris Statlander | Diamante*(5) | Voorhees, NJ | 10/18/19 |
| 16. | Brittany Blake | Kris Statlander | Voorhees, NJ | 12/14/19 |
*This was the finals of a tournament to crown the first WSU Champion.
*(2)This was a Triple Threat Match.
*(3)This was a Triple Threat Match.
*(4)Havok was stripped of the title and banned from the company. This was a Two out of Three Falls Match to determine the new champion.
*(5)Statlander won a tournament to become the interim champion. When Blanchard later left the company, Statlander was promoted to the official champion.
Title Defenses:
1. Alicia
---N/A
2. Alexa Thatcher
---N/A
3. Alicia
---pinned Rick Cataldo, Satan's Sisters Slaughterhouse: 7/14/07
---pinned Nikki Roxx, Satan's Sisters Slaughterhouse: 7/14/07
---pinned Talia, PWS: 9/7/07
---pinned Della Morte, WUW: 9/15/07
---beat Becky Bayless via ref stoppage in a No DQ Match, It's Always Sunny in Lake Hiawatha: 9/22/07
---pinned Christy Hemme, WSU: 9/22/07
---pinned Alere Little Feather, NWS: 10/5/07
---pinned Talia, NWS: 11/9/07
---beat Becky Bayless in a Last Woman Standing Match: 12/22/07
4. Tammy Sytch
---N/A
5. Nikki Roxx
---beat Cindy Rogers and Alexa Thatcher in a Triple Threat Match, Testament of Strength: 4/20/08
6. Angel Orsini
---pinned Amy Lee, The Show Must Go On: 6/21/08
---beat Mercedes Martinez in a Falls Count Anywhere Match, Army of One: 6/21/08
---beat Roxie Cotton, Rick Cataldo and Annie Social in a Four Way Match, JAPW: 8/16/08
---beat Dawn Marie and Portia Perez in a Triple Threat Match, Us and Them: 8/22/08
---beat Portia Perez in a Lumberjill Match, Another Brick in the Wall: 8/23/08
---pinned Annie Social: 9/20/08
---pinned Kara Slice, Payback's a Bitch: 10/4/08
---time limit draw against Mercedes Martinez, Push It to the Limit: 10/10/08
---pinned Bobcat: 10/11/08
---pinned Amy Lee: 10/18/08
---pinned Lizzy Valentine: 10/25/08
---pinned Reyna Fire, FCW: 11/15/08
---beat Mercedes Martinez in a Steel Cage Match, Poetic Injustice Caged: 1/10/09
---pinned Kylie Pierce, 2009 Hall of Fame Ceremony: 2/7/09
---pinned Miss April, NWS: 2/21/09
7. Mercedes Martinez
---pinned Jana, Women's J-Cup 2009: 4/10/09
---beat Angel Orsini and Rain in a Triple Threat Match, King & Queen of the Ring: 4/11/09
---pinned Roxie Cotton: 5/30/09
---beat Angel Orsini in an Iron Woman Match, Ironwoman: 6/6/09
---pinned Nikki Roxx, No Limits: 8/22/09
---pinned Portia Perez, Excellence: 10/3/09
---pinned Awesome Kong, Awesome Challenge: 12/9/09
---beat Rain in an Uncensored Rules Match, 3rd Anniversary Event: 3/6/10
---pinned Amber O'Neal, Women's J-Cup 2010: 4/2/10
---pinned Alicia, Uncensored Rumble III: 6/26/10
---pinned Mickie James, When the Tigers Broke Free: 8/6/10
---pinned Jazz, Breaking Barriers: 11/6/10
---beat Rain in an I Quit Match, Martinez/Rain II: 11/6/10
---beat Angel Orsini in a Ladder Match, The Final Chapter: 1/22/11
---pinned Serena Deeb, 4th Anniversary Show: 3/5/11
---no contest against Alicia, 4th Anniversary Show: 3/5/11
---pinned Britney Savage, Uncensored Rumble IV: 6/25/11
8. Jessicka Havok
---N/A
9. Mercedes Martinez
---N/A
10. Jessicka Havok
---beat Mercedes Martinez in a Casket Match, Uncensored Rumble: 6/17/12
---beat Lexxus and Alicia in a Triple Threat Match, Full Steam Ahead: 10/13/12
---pinned Athena, An Ultraviolent Affair: 2/9/13
---pinned Lexxus, Blood and Thunder: 10/12/13
---pinned Shanna, Secret Show #3: 2/7/14
---pinned The Alpha Female, Mutiny: 2/8/14
11. LuFisto
---pinned Mickie Knuckles, United: 7/12/14
---pinned Allysin Kay, Resurgence: 9/13/14
---pinned Shanna, Anniversary: 2/21/15