| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | TJ Perkins | Gran Metalik* | Winter Park, FL | 9/14/16 |
| 2. | Brian Kendrick | TJ Perkins | Boston, MA | 10/30/16 |
| 3. | Rich Swann | Brian Kendrick | Columbia, SC | 11/29/16 |
| 4. | Neville | Rich Swann | San Antonio, TX | 1/29/17 |
| 5. | Akira Tozawa | Neville | Boston, MA | 8/14/17 |
| 6. | Neville | Akira Tozawa | Brooklyn, NY | 8/20/17 |
| 7. | Enzo Amore | Neville | Los Angeles, CA | 9/24/17 |
| 8. | Kalisto | Enzo Amore | Indianapolis, IN | 10/9/17 |
| 9. | Enzo Amore | Kalisto | Minneapolis, MN | 10/22/17 |
| 10. | Cedric Alexander | Mustafa Ali*(2) | New Orleans, LA | 4/8/18 |
| 11. | Buddy Murphy | Cedric Alexander | Melbourne, Australia | 10/6/18 |
| 12. | Tony Nese | Buddy Murphy | East Rutherford, NJ | 4/7/19 |
| 13. | Drew Gulak | Tony Nese and Akira Tozawa*(3) | Tacoma, WA | 6/23/19 |
| 14. | Lio Rush | Drew Gulak | Winter Park, FL | 10/9/19 |
| 15. | Angel Garza | Lio Rush | Winter Park, FL | 12/11/19 |
| 16. | Jordan Devlin | Angel Garza, Isaiah Scott and Travis Banks*(4) | Houston, TX | 1/25/20 |
| 17. | Santos Escobar | Drake Maverick*(5) | Winter Park, FL | 5/27/20 |
| 18. | Kushida | Santos Escobar | Winter Park, FL | 4/13/21 |
| 19. | Roderick Strong | Kushida | Winter Park, FL | 9/21/21 |
| 20. | Carmelo Hayes*(6) | Roderick Strong | Winter Park, FL | 1/4/22 |
*This was the finals of the Cruiserweight Classic Tournament. Before the match started, WWE COO Triple H presented the title belt and declared that the winner would be the first champion.
*(2)Amore was let go from WWE, and the title was vacated. This was the finals of a tournament to crown a new champion.
*(3)This was a Triple Threat Match.
*(4)This was a Fatal Four Way Match.
*(5)With Devlin unable to return to the US during the COVID pandemic, a tournament was held to crown an interim champion. This was the final match to determine the interim champion.
*(6)This match unified the Cruiserweight Championship with the North American Championship.
Title Defenses
1. TJ Perkins
---submitted Brian Kendrick, Clash of Champions: 9/25/16
2. Brian Kendrick
---lost to TJ Perkins by CO, Raw: 10/31/16
---beat Kalisto by DQ, Survivor Series: 11/20/16
3. Rich Swann
---pinned TJ Perkins, Raw: 12/5/16
---pinned Brian Kendrick, 205 Live: 12/6/16
---beat Brian Kendrick and TJ Perkins in a Triple Threat Match, Roadblock - End of the Line: 12/18/16
4. Neville
---pinned Jack Gallagher, Fastlane: 3/5/17
---submitted Rich Swann, Raw: 3/6/17
---pinned Austin Aries, WrestleMania 33: 4/2/17
---lost to Austin Aries by DQ, Payback: 4/30/17
---beat Austin Aries in a Submission Match, Extreme Rules: 6/4/17
---submitted TJP, 205 Live: 6/6/17
---pinned Akira Tozawa, Great Balls of Fire: 7/9/17
5. Akira Tozawa
---N/A
6. Neville
---pinned Akira Tozawa, 205 Live: 8/22/17
7. Enzo Amore
---N/A
8. Kalisto
---N/A
9. Enzo Amore
---lost to Kalisto by DQ, 205 Live: 10/24/17
---pinned Kalisto, Survivor Series: 11/19/17
---lost to Cedric Alexander by CO, Raw: 1/8/18
10. Cedric Alexander
---pinned Kalisto, The Greatest Royal Rumble: 4/27/18
---pinned Hideo Itami, 205 Live: 7/10/18
---pinned Drew Gulak, SummerSlam: 8/19/18
---pinned Drew Gulak, 205 Live: 9/18/18
11. Buddy Murphy
---pinned Mustafa Ali, Survivor Series: 11/18/18
---pinned Cedric Alexander, TLC: 12/16/18
---beat Akira Tozawa, Hideo Itami and Kalisto in a Triple Threat Match, Royal Rumble: 1/27/19
---pinned Akira Tozawa, Elimination Chamber: 2/17/19
12. Tony Nese
---pinned Buddy Murphy, 205 Live: 4/9/19
13. Drew Gulak
---pinned Tony Nese, Extreme Rules: 7/14/19
---pinned Oney Lorcan, SummerSlam: 8/11/19
---beat Humberto Carrillo and Lince Dorado in a Triple Threat Match, Clash of Champions: 9/15/19
14. Lio Rush
---beat Kalisto and Akira Tozawa in a Triple Threat Match, Survivor Series: 11/24/19
---pinned Akira Tozawa, NXT: 11/27/19
15. Angel Garza
---N/A
16. Jordan Devlin
---N/A
17. Santos Escobar
---pinned Isaiah Scott, NXT: 8/26/20
---pinned Isaiah Scott, TakeOver 31: 10/4/20
---pinned Jake Atlas, NXT: 11/11/20
---pinned Gran Metalik, New Year's Evil: 1/6/21
---pinned Curt Stallion, NXT: 2/3/21
---beat Jordan Devlin in a Unification Ladder Match, TakeOver: Stand and Deliver: 4/8/21
18. Kushida
---submitted Oney Lorcan, NXT: 4/20/21
---beat Santos Escobar in a Best 2 out of 3 Falls Match, NXT: 5/11/21
---submitted Carmelo Hayes, NXT: 6/1/21
---submitted Trey Baxter, NXT: 6/15/21