| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Mark Lewin & Don Curtis | Hans Schmidt & Dick the Bruiser* | ?? | 1958 |
| 2. | Jerry & Eddie Graham | Mark Lewin & Don Curtis | Washington, D.C. | 9/1/58 |
| 3. | Mark Lewin & Don Curtis | Jerry & Eddie Graham | Washington, D.C. | 12/58 |
| 4. | Jerry & Eddie Graham | Mark Lewin & Don Curtis | Bridgeport, CT | 5/27/59 |
| 5. | Jerry Graham & Johnny Valentine | Mark Lewin & Don Curtis** | West Hempstead, NY | 11/14/59 |
| 6. | Jerry & Eddie Graham | N/A*** | N/A | 3/60 |
| 7. | Red & Lou Bastien | Jerry & Eddie Graham | New Haven, CT | 4/2/60 |
| 8. | Jerry & Eddie Graham | Red & Lou Bastien | New Haven, CT | 4/16/60 |
| 9. | Red & Lou Bastien | Jerry & Eddie Graham | Chicago, IL | 4/23/60 |
| 10. | Al Costello & Roy Heffernan (The Fabulous Kangaroos) | Red & Lou Bastien | Washington, D.C. | 7/21/60 |
| 11. | Red & Lou Bastien | The Fabulous Kangaroos | Washington, D.C. | 8/8/60 |
| 12. | The Fabulous Kangaroos | Red & Lou Bastien | Bridgeport, CT | 8/24/60 |
| 13. | Johnny Valentine & Buddy Rogers | The Fabulous Kangaroos | Teaneck, NJ | 11/19/60 |
| 14. | The Fabulous Kangaroos | Johnny Valentine & Buddy Rogers | Washington, D.C. | 11/26/60 |
| 15. | Johnny Valentine & Bob Ellis | The Fabulous Kangaroos | Washington, D.C. | 1/11/62 |
| 16. | Buddy Rogers & Johnny Barend | Johnny Valentine & Bob Ellis | Washington, D.C. | 7/5/62 |
| 17. | Buddy Austin & Great Scott | Buddy Rogers & Johnny Barend | Washington, D.C. | 3/7/63 |
| 18. | Skull Murphy & Brute Bernard | Buddy Austin & Great Scott | Washington, D.C. | 5/16/63 |
| 19. | Killer Kowalski & Gorilla Monsoon | Skull Murphy & Brute Bernard | Washington, D.C. | 11/14/63 |
| 20. | John & Chris Tolos | Killer Kowalski & Gorilla Monsoon | Teaneck, NJ | 12/28/63 |
| 21. | Doc McClairty & Argentina Apollo | John & Chris Tolos | New Haven, CT | 2/16/64 |
| 22. | Jerry & Luke Graham | Doc McClairty & Argentina Apollo | Washington, D.C. | 6/6/64 |
| 23. | Gene Kiniski & Waldo Von Erich | Jerry & Luke Graham | Washington, D.C. | 2/4/65 |
| 24. | Gorilla Monsoon & Bill Watts | Gene Kiniski & Waldo Von Erich | Washington, D.C. | 4/8/65 |
| 25. | Dan & Bill Miller | Gorilla Monsoon & Bill Watts | Washington, D.C. | 8/7/65 |
| 26. | Johnny Valentine & Tony Parisi | Dan & Bill Miller | New York, NY | 2/21/66 |
| 27. | Baron Mikel Scicluna & Smasher Sloan | Johnny Valentine & Tony Parisi | Washington, D.C. | 9/22/66 |
| 28. | Tony Parisi & Spiros Arion | Baron Mikel Scicluna & Smasher Sloan | Washington, D.C. | 12/8/66 |
| 29. | Spiros Arion & Arnold Skaaland | N/A**** | N/A | 6/30/67 |
| 30. | Lou Albano & Tony Altimore (The Sicilians) | Spiros Arion & Arnold Skaaland | Atlantic City, NJ | 7/10/67 |
| 31. | Bruno Sammartino & Spiros Arion | The Sicilians | Atlantic City, NJ | 7/29/67 |
*This match determined the first champions.
**Eddie Graham left the promotion, and this match was held to determine the new champions.
***Eddie Graham returned and took back his half of the titles from Valentine.
****Parisi gave his half of the championship to Skaaland.