| No. | Won By | Won From | Location | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Bobo Brazil | N/A* | California | 4/6/63 |
| 2. | Johnny Barend | Bobo Brazil | Philadelphia, PA | 6/8/63 |
| 3. | Bobo Brazil | Johnny Barend | Philadelphia, PA | 7/9/63 |
| 4. | Johnny Barend | Bobo Brazil | Baltimore, MD | 9/11/63 |
| 5. | Bobo Brazil | Johnny Barend | Newton Square, PA | 10/22/63 |
| 6. | Ray Stevens | Bobo Brazil | ?? | 6/18/64 |
| 7. | Bobo Brazil | Ray Stevens | Trenton, NJ | 8/24/64 |
| 8. | The Sheik | Bobo Brazil | Detroit, MI | 9/22/65 |
| 9. | Bobo Brazil | The Sheik | ?? | 11/24/65 |
| 10. | The Sheik | Bobo Brazil | Boston, MA | 1/20/67 |
| 11. | Bobo Brazil | The Sheik | Washington, D.C. | 2/10/70 |
| 12. | Pedro Morales | Freddie Blassie** | Los Angeles, CA | 1/7/71 |
| 13. | Bobo Brazil | N/A*** | Harrisburg, PA | 2/19/71 |
*Brazil was awarded the title.
**The title was vacated for unknown reasons. This was a tournament final to crown the new champion.
***Morales gave up the title when he won the WWWF World Title. Brazil was awarded the belt.