| Current Sand Gnats | Former Sand Gnats | Former Sand Gnats Pre-Stats Era (1995-1998) |
(The Last Gnats Season- 2008) | Harold Ahle | Pete "The Hammer" Bishop |
| Tim Ciaramitaro | Matt Baglieri | Eric Johnson |
| Ben Carruthers | Nathan Boorom | Scott "Bubba" Johnston |
| John Carruthers | Mike Cam | Greg Madigan |
| Scott Davis | Jake Carruthers | Dave "Maniac" Maniaci |
| Kevin DeSilva Piques | Al Covelli | George McCabe |
| Steve Dever | Dave Gallagher | Jim O'Neil |
| Kerry Felstead | Steve Gilliam | John Walters |
| Steve Fish | Mike Girgenti | |
| Derek Gallacher | Josh Gullion | |
| Don Harris | Ryan Hodges | |
| Jay MacJanet | Jamie July | |
| Mike McLean | Duane Kemp | |
| Robb McLean | Jay Lennox | |
| Mike Pietrangelo | Kyle Lentz | |
| Mike Pozzebon | Justin Monaghan | |
| Pete Saddler | Chris Ness | |
| Dan Nywening | ||
| Steve Oatley | ||
| Christian Oliver | ||
| James Palin | ||
| Demetre Papavasiliou | ||
| Mark Piazza | ||
| Nick Pietrangelo | ||
| Paul Pooler | ||
| Paul Reece | ||
| George Saddler | ||
| Chris Shickluna | ||
| Rob Walters | ||
