Site hosted by Angelfire.com: Build your free website today!
 

Pike County Federation of Sportsmen's Clubs

Fishing for Panfish

On this page ...

What is a panfish?

Why fish for panfish?

Where to find panfish?

Where to find panfish?

Panfish hotspots

Best baits and lures

 

Links

Pennsylvania Fish & Boat Commission

Federation Home Page

Federation Fishing Page

Carp Fishing, European Style


Keep 

the 

sport 

alive.  

 

 

Take 

kid 

fishing 

today!

Best viewed with Internet Explorer 5.0 --- Other browsers may alter fonts.

What is a Panfish?

The definition of panfish varies from state to state, region to region.  For our purposes, we will only address the species that are generally considered panfish in Pennsylvania.  They include:

bluegills                          carp

pumpkinseed sunfish         brown bullhead

red ear sunfish                  black bullhead

black crappie                   rock bass

white crappie                  white bass

yellow perch                   suckers

white perch                    catfish

Of these, white crappy, white perch, white bass, and black bullhead are species that generally live west of the Appalachians and are not normally found in Pike County. 

Although the name panfish was derived by the fact that most of these species are small and can be easily cooked whole or filleted in a frying pan, the Fish and Boat Commission still considers members of the catfish family to be panfish.  Channel catfish, blue catfish, and flathead catfish commonly exceed 10 pounds in size.  However, most are caught when they weigh less than 3 pounds.

Why fish for panfish?

Panfish are much maligned by many fishermen.  Yet, if one looks past the snobbery of trout fishing, and the technology of bass fishing, fishing for panfish can provide much of the same thrills at a fraction of the cost.  The problem with panfish is that they are a fish of the proletariat.  They care not whether you are fishing with a thousand dollar fly rod or a three dollar cane pole.  When hungry they will hit royal coachman or a garden worm.  They don't even seem to care how much experience you might have, swimming past the experts bait and taking a child's.  

7 Reasons to pursue panfish ...

1. Relaxation:  Unlike trout and bass fishing, you need only put into it the amount of effort you desire.  You may choose to cast a fly line or work a spinner around some weeds - or, just put on a bobber and bait and rest the rod on a forked stick.

2. Low start up costs:  There is no need for a $20,000 fully equipped boat and a thousand dollars in rods and tackle.  The start up panfish angler could begin with a hand line, hook, and worm.  Most anglers would opt for more equipment.  Some even buy $20,000 fully equipped boats. But, it is by choice and not necessity.  

3. Ample opportunity:  Everywhere in Pike County is within one mile of a body of water that contains panfish.

4. Tasty:  No need to elaborate.

5. No guilt: While trout and bass fisherman argue over "catch and release" versus taking fish for food, the prolific nature of panfish make the point moot.  In fact, many waters are suffering from an over abundance of panfish depressing bass size and numbers due to excessive competition for food.

6. Family fun:  Fishing for panfish is fun for the old an young alike.  It is especially good for families with young children as most kids get more fun by catching 15 "sunnies" than "not catching" trout.

7. Fishing skills tune up:  Since you can fish for panfish using the same techniques as you would for trout, bass or walleye, you can practice your techniques before the season starts, or in the case of trout, when the weather is too warm for good trout fishing.

America is coming back to fishing for panfish.  Recently a nationwide crappie fishing tournament tour (Crappiethon)  has been established in a manner similar to the Bassmasters.  Carp (always a top game fish in Europe) are now being pursued by fly fishermen on western reservoirs.  Fishing charters throughout the South are specializing in catfish.  The Pennsylvania Fish & Boat Commission, too, has recognized the value of panfish by designating certain waters (two of which are in Pike County) to be managed for trophy panfish.  And, serious panfish tournaments are being held on Lake Wallepaupack.

Where to find panfish?

Generally speaking, Pike County's panfish are found mostly in lakes and ponds although there are exceptions.  Yellow perch, catfish, suckers, carp, and rock bass may be found in the Delaware River.  Suckers may be found in any free flowing stream with an adequate supply of water in the summer.  Of course, many anglers have been surprised by where they have found panfish.  Perch have been caught in the Lackawaxen River.  Sunfish have been caught in the Lackawaxen River as well as in the Shohola Creek.  While catching panfish may occasionally occur in a trout stream, those fishing for panfish would be better off going to the nearest pond.

Panfish Hotspots

There are many great panfish waters in Pike County.  Unfortunately, not all of them are open to the public.  The following is a list of a few of the top panfish waters that are open to public fishing.  

1.  Lake Wallenpaupack - has just about everything.  Species available include bluegills and other sunfish, rock bass, bullheads and catfish, yellow perch, black crappie, and carp.

Tip - Fish for rock bass along rocky shoreline in 2 to 4 feet deep water.  Use small worms, meal worms, grubs, or 1 inch minnows for bait.  Good lures are flies (wet or dry), poppers, small spinners or spinner baits (fished slowly).  These fish are very territorial.  If the fish hits but does not get hooked, casting back to the same spot will usually result in another hit.  Daytime fishing is good and fishing action is less affected by direct sun or lots of chop.  Nightfall increases the action and can produce a lot of fun for those using a fly rod and poppers.

Tip - The best fishing for sunfish and bluegills is around the numerous docks that encircle the lake.  Especially productive are those that enter into deeper water at the head of the lake where trophy fish 1/2 to 1 pound are regularly caught.  Remember, while the shoreline is open to all, the docks are private property.  Ask permission first.

2.  Shohola Lake - This thousand acre impoundment is a panfish paradise!  Species available include bluegills and other sunfish, black crappie, and yellow perch. Although there is a lot of shoreline, much of it is very brushy.  The near shore areas are fairly shallow and the muddy bottom makes wading tough.  Therefore it is recommended that shore fishing be limited to the areas near the boat launch and dam.  Boat fishing is the preferred way to fish Shohola Lake.  The lake is limited to electric motors only but with the lake's narrowness and three launches, canoes and row boats are equally at home.

Tip - While fishing is usually good all day, large (1/2 to 3/4 pound) sunfish feed heavily starting about an hour before sun down.  Worms, small minnows, grubs, and meal worms make good baits.  Dry flies and poppers are good artificials.  Shohola Lake is shallow, stumpy, and very weedy.  Avoid deep diving lures, most spinners, and anything that is not weedless!

Tip - As the sun goes down, the bullheads come out.  Tie off to a stump.  Use short casts around the boat to avoid stump tangles.  Best bait - worms.  Bring enough, you will need them!

Bonus - Shohola Lake was the first place that Pennsylvania chose to reintroduce bald eagles.  Watch for these grand birds especially in the early morning and before dusk.  Click here for more on Shohola's eagles!

Bonus - Shohola Lake has picnic facilities and an improved trail to a lookout point to see Shohola Falls (one of the nicest in Pennsylvania).  Its a great place to bring the family.

Warning - Shohola Lake is in Pennsylvania Gamelands (public hunting lands).  The land was purchased and developed for hunting with money generated by hunting license fees and excise taxes on hunting equipment.  The lake was built especially for duck hunting.  While the public is invited to use the grounds, remember, hunters have priority and interfering with the hunters is a violation of state law.  Caution should be exercised when fishing in October, November, and December.

3.  Promised Land State Park - Both the upper lake and the lower lake are currently in the state's Panfish Enhancement program.  Special regulations are in effect for yellow perch, bluegills and other sunfish.  Other species available include bullheads and channel catfish.

Bonus - Another great place to take the family with boat rentals, picnic facilities and a beach.

Bonus - Eagles now nest along the lake in sight of the boat launch.  Click here for more about Pike County's eagles.

4.  Greeley Lake - With access limited to a small boat launch, boat fishing is a necessity.  No gasoline motors.  Species available include sunfish, crappie, and bullheads.  Large pumpkinseed sunfish may be taken with small minnows.

5.  Delaware River - While usually targeted for trout, shad, smallmouths, and walleye, the Delaware does offer good fishing for some species of panfish.  Species available include catfish, bullheads, yellow perch, suckers, carp, sunfish, and rock bass.

Tip - Fish for catfish at the head of large pools so the bait's scent drifts down the pool.

Tip - Suckers may be visually located by wading along pools just above riffles.  Best bait - worms, but be sure to bury the hook.

Tip - Carp may be found in pools throughout the river.  Good places to start looking are the deep pools around bridge abutments.

6.  Lackawaxen River - Another trout hotspot that can provide good sucker fishing.  Best spots, pools with slower current.

7.  Community lakes and ponds - While not generally open to the public, many Pike County residents and visitors have access to the lakes and ponds within the private community.  While the quality of bass and trout fishing may vary, most are under-fished panfish hotspots. When given a choice, try a small pond as they often allow the best shore fishing and the least interference from other users.  Especially good fishing may be had in Gold Key Lakes, Sunrise Lakes, Conashaugh Lakes, Hemlock Farms, Wild Acres Lakes, Twin Lakes, Walker Lake, just to name a few.

Best Baits & Lures

Panfish eat just about anything!  However, certain baits are used more commonly for certain species.  Sometimes it is because the fish prefer the the particular bait.  Sometimes it is because the fishermen prefer to use the particular bait.  Don't be afraid to experiment.  Pieces of Slim Jims, bananas, and even leaves have been known to catch fish at times.  However, the following is a list of commonly used baits by species:

Bluegills and Other Sunfish

worms, grubs, meal worms, most any insect especially crickets and small grasshoppers, small salamanders, small minnows

small pieces of hotdog, corn, small dough balls, small pieces of cheese

dry flies, wet flies, small spinners, poppers, small rapalas, plastic grubs, 

Black Crappies - 

small minnows, small worms especially when given motion, grubs, crickets and small grasshoppers, small salamanders

wet flies, small streamers, small jigs, plastic grubs, rapalas up to 4 inches, spinners, any small minnow imitation

Yellow Perch - 

small minnows, worms especially when trolled or retrieved, crickets and small grasshoppers

wet flies, streamers, small rapalas, any small minnow imitation

Carp -

Worms, minnows, insects, crayfish, meat from shellfish, salamanders, 

chunks of fish, corn, pieces of hotdog, shrimp, peas, cheese, dough balls, salmon eggs

difficult to catch on artificial lures.

Brown Bullhead

worms, minnows, crickets and grasshoppers, insects, crayfish, meat from shellfish, salamanders

small pieces of hotdog, corn, dough balls, cheese, salmon eggs, chunks of fish,

difficult to catch on artificial lures

Catfish -

worms, minnows, crickets and grasshoppers, insects, crayfish, meat from shellfish, salamanders

pieces of hotdog, corn, dough balls, cheese, salmon eggs, chunks of fish, chicken livers, commercially prepared stink baits

difficult to catch on artificial lures

Suckers

worms, small minnows, crickets and small grasshoppers, insects, meat from shellfish

small pieces of hotdog, corn, small dough balls, small pieces of cheese, salmon eggs, small chunks of fish

bead head nymphs, wet flies

Rock Bass

small minnows, worms, grubs, meal worms, crickets and grasshoppers, insects, small salamanders

small pieces of hotdog, small dough balls, 

dry flies, wet flies, small streamers, poppers, small rapalas, spinners, any small minnow imitations