(1999) The Path Not Taken takes place in the second season of the series. This magical look into the lives of Nicholas, Natalie, LaCroix, Janette, and Schanke is both fun and introspective.

While accidentally witnessing a crime, LaCroix comes into possession of a magical lamp (Aladdin’s lamp) that can grant a wish. As the lamp passes through the possession of each Forever Knight character, their lives will change. Each will be granted a chance to experience life or unlife as they never have.