THE STORY OF ANNA SMITH NAIL & JOSEPH WHITEHEAD
Anna Smith was born in Elbert County, Georgia in 1781. Her mother died when Anna was still a young child. A devoted older sister persuaded her cruel husband, a man whose last name was Nails, to allow her younger sister to come and live with them so she could care for Anna. The husband agreed, but he treated Anna as a bonservant and forced her to work alongside his slaves. According to a custom not uncommon in those days, the young girl took his last name, becoming Anna Smith Nails.
A young man named Joseph Whitehead lived in the same community. Soon he became attracted to the pretty young girl in the Nails home. In 1798 when Joseph was 19 years of age and Anna was 17, they decided to marry. With the aid of Anna's sister, the couple eloped to be married by a nearby minister. Leaving word for the cruel brother-in-law not to follow if he valued his life, the couple mounted horses and set out northward.
Young Joe had made friends with the Indians of Elbert County who told him of a high waterfall deep in Cherokee lands. With this as their goal, Anna and Joe traveled many days through dense forest with only Indian trails to guide them. They faced possible death on every hand from wild animals, from unfriendly Indians and from the uncharted wildness itself. Finally, after a courageous journey of some 50 miles, they arrived at the beautiful Tocca Falls valley.
The chief of the Cherokees befriended the young couple. He led them to a spot about two miles above the falls, and there young Joe built a cabin for his new bride. By trading with the chief, Joseph soon owned a plot of land that extended for five miles in every direction. Joseph and Anna were the first white settlers in the Tocca Falls vally.
Joseph and Anna bore four sons and five daughters, and some of their descendants still live in northeast Georgia. joseph died in 1858. Anna died in 1876 at the age of 95.
The Whiteheads sleep silently in a family cemetery about one mile above the falls on property that now belongs to Tocca Falls College.
In James Mooney's "Sacred Formula and Myths of the Cherokee", James Wofford (Worn-Out-Blanket) who was an interpreter for John Ross during the Removal of the Cherokee Indians said that his grandfather owned the Toccoa Falls in Georgia and so did Joseph Whitehead hold title also.