| Independence | 2005 | Predictions | ||||
| Mike Isaacs | Matt Kellems | Paul Kuchar | ||||
| Liberty | Gigolos | Liberty | ||||
| Frogtown | Liberty | Gigolos | ||||
| Miami | Horny Toads | Horny Toads | ||||
| Horny Toads | Revenge | Miami | ||||
| BallBusters | Miami | Arcola | ||||
| Gigolos | Mudcats | Mudcats | ||||
| Revenge | Mavericks | BallBusters | ||||
| Mudcats | BallBusters | Frogtown | ||||
| Mavericks | Cairo | Mavericks | ||||
| Sinners | Frogtown | Jamestown | ||||
| Cairo | Cyclones | Sinners | ||||
| Cyclones | Sinners | Cyclones | ||||
