Year

Player Name

 Club

Against

Score

1983

Arnold Mühren

 Manchester United

Liverpool

1-2

1985

Dennis van Wijk

 Norwich City

Sunderland

1-0

1995

Richard Sneekes

 Bolton Wanderers

Liverpool

1-2

1998

Ed de Goey

 Chelsea

Middlesbrough

2-0 aet

2001

Sander Westerveld

 Liverpool

Birmingham City

1-1 aet, Liverpool wins penalties

2003

Ruud van Nistelrooy

 Manchester United

Liverpool

0-2

2004

George Boateng & Boudewijn Zenden

 Middlesbrough

Bolton Wanderers

2-1

2006

Edwin van der Sar

 Manchester United

Wigan Athletic

4-0

Arjan de Zeeuw

 Wigan Athletic

Manchester United

0-4

2007

Arjan Robben

 Chelsea

Arsenal

2-1