Remember when Aaron and Lucy shared their first kiss?

Lucy and Aaron discover a pack of cigarettes in the barn and wonder if Alison was spying on them. Lucy defends Alison, but Aaron thinks that they need to confront her with the evidence. Craig, who has found the photo of Lucy and Aaron on the bike, calls Lucy to come home, where he confronts her about riding Aaron’s motorcycle. Lucy fights with Craig about trying to control her and they eventually come to an understanding. Craig warns her to be wary of whoever left the picture for him to find. Meanwhile, Emily is having trouble connecting with Alison. Aaron arrives with the cigarettes and Alison denies spying on him and Lucy. Later, Lucy shows up and demands an explanation for how Craig got the picture of her and Aaron on his bike.

Aaron’s fantasy about kissing Lucy is interrupted by Craig, who implies that if Lucy continues to get in trouble, she will be shipped back to Montega. He can’t control Lucy, but he wants Aaron to promise not to take her on his bike anymore. Aaron refuses to make decisions for Lucy, but does vow to drive safely with her. Craig accepts this, but lets Aaron know that Margo is investigating his juvenile record from Seattle. At Java, Lucy confronts Alison about showing the photo to Craig. Alison tries to use sympathy to explain her actions, but Lucy refuses to forgive her.

Concerned that Craig will reveal his police record, Aaron rudely dismisses Lucy. Lucy stands up for herself and is angry at Aaron because she fought with her dad for him. Aaron confesses that Craig could tell her some things about him that would make her not want to see him anymore. Aaron explains that he was wrongly accused of burglary and Lucy vows not to let Craig ruin him with it. Lucy runs to Margo and asks for help in not letting Craig hurt Aaron.

Aaron accuses Holden of exposing his juvenile record and jeopardizing his relationship with Lucy. Holden denies it and discovers that Craig threatened Aaron with revealing his past. Holden decides to confront Craig himself, despite Aaron’s objections. At the station, Margo questions Lucy about her relationship with Aaron. She agrees not to show Aaron’s police record to Craig, if Aaron will join her for dinner and prove that he has changed. Delighted, Lucy shares the news with Aaron, but he refuses to go to dinner.

Lucy storms off when Aaron refuses to go to dinner at Margo’s house. Lucy informs them that Aaron isn’t coming. Meanwhile, Alison goes to Aaron and asks him to give Lucy a present from her. She says that she is worried she ruined her relationship with Lucy. Aaron hears her out, gets dressed and goes to Margo’s for dinner. The dinner goes well and he is honest when Margo asks him about his trouble in Seattle. Margo tells Lucy that she thinks he is a good kid. At the Snyder Barn, Lucy and Aaron share their first kiss.