- Quarter-Finals

8/5/91; St. Joseph, MO; Civic Arena
Worldwide - 8/24/91
- Richard Morton defeated Johnny Rich

8/5/91; St. Joseph, MO; Civic Arena
Worldwide - 8/31/91
- Badstreet defeated Joey Maggs

8/12/91; Gainesville, GA; Georgia Mountains Center
The Main Event - 9/8/91
- Mike Graham defeated Terrence Taylor

- Semi-Finals

Clash of the Champions XVI - 9/5/91; Augusta, GA; Augusta-Richmond Civic Center
- Brian Pillman pinned Badstreet (Brad Armstrong) at 6:52 with a crossbody off the top; prior to the bout, Badstreet was escorted ringside by WCW US Tag Team Champions Michael Hayes & Jimmy Garvin but both were sent backstage before the bout began (Pillman's official return to the ring after an 11-week absence)

Clash of the Champions XVI - 9/5/91; Augusta, GA; Augusta-Richmond Civic Center
- Richard Morton (w/ Alexandra York) pinned Mike Graham at 7:40 with a roll up and grabbing the tights for leverage after kicking out of a roll up and sending Graham head-first into the corner; due to pre-match stipulations, Morton advanced to meet Brian Pillman in the finals at Halloween Havoc

- Finals

Halloween Havoc 91 - 10/27/91; Chattanooga, TN; UTC Arena
- Brian Pillman pinned Richard Morton (w/ Alexandra York) to win the title with a crossbody off the top at 12:43; during the bout, referee Nick Patrick wore a "Refer-Eye" video camera helmet