| Date | New Champion | Defeated | Where | Event/Show | ||||||||||||||||||||
| November 13, 2006 | Joe Corey | N/A | Cincinnati, Ohio |  |
||||||||||||||||||||
| March 23, 2008 | Chaos Wolf | Joe Corey *Lights Out Match |
South Bend, Indiana |  |
||||||||||||||||||||
| May 16, 2008 | Sylvester Terkay | Chaos Wolf *Extreme Rules Match |
Houston, Texas |  |
||||||||||||||||||||
| April 10, 2009 | Travis Wakeman | Sylvester Terkay | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | |
