Written by Melody LZX
Based on some situations originated by James Cameron.

I sometimes wondered.

Sometimes I wondered if I had missed her while surveying the people who survived on the ship that day.

That day, I had done an all-around survey of the people on the Carpathia, but I was too disgusted by those…those third class people on the ship. Filthy beings they were, and so many of them staying in the same place as us! I could not bear to look too closely, and I did not find her.

Rose DeWitt Bukater, my ex-fiancée, had cheated on me with a third class man.

My fists clenched. It was humiliating to be cheated on with another man, but imagine that. She chose a filthy, dirty, third class man over me. And she chose to whore herself, to roger around with him in the sheets, and to allow him to draw a portrait of her, naked, except for the diamond I gave her, which hung around her neck.

The diamond I gave her.

When I saw the picture, I was furious, enraged. I wanted to tear the whole ship down, looking for the adulterous pair. I wanted to kill him with my bare fists, to see him go white, gasping for breath, and die with his eyes wide open, afraid. I wanted to teach him a lesson.

Caledon Hockley was not one to be fooled around with.

I looked down the list of survivors they took down after we landed in New York, but I did not see the name Rose DeWitt Bukater. There were several Roses on the list, but not one Rose DeWitt Bukater. I had gone away with an empty feeling in my stomach. The diamond had gone down with her.

Later on, I married another girl, Theresa Deswall, but she did not have as high a social standing as Rose had, nor did she appeal to me as much as Rose did.

I saw Rose as a challenging task, a difficult horse that was hard to conquer. I thought I had her the first few days on the Titanic, thought I finally had her under my control, and there was a triumphant feeling that came with the victory. I gave her the diamond that night, and saw it as a mark of my victory--Rose DeWitt Bukater, who refused to listen to anyone, was finally docile.

Then I found out about him.

When I first saw him, I did not think of him as any threat. Sure, he saved Rose, and he was almost handsome in a scruffy kind of way. And he could almost pass for a gentleman that night at dinner.

When I came back from cards and found that Rose was missing, and not in her room, either, I immediately sent Lovejoy to find her.

It was a disgrace to discover that she had been dancing, if you call that dancing, away at a third class party. I was embarrassed, humiliated, and I took great care to warn her the next day.

To think she continued her affair, and even slept with him.

Caledon Hockley had never been insulted, and never will be.

Well, they got their punishment. I like to think it was God’s way of punishing them that night. At least, that was what I thought.

Until, over eighty years later, I saw her again on television.

She could well be a fraud. Somehow, she did not seem like one.

They were doing a documentary on the Titanic. What was the big deal about it? Sure, over a thousand died, and it was a great big mistake made by the fools steering the ship. Supposedly unsinkable, and it would have been unsinkable had it not been for the fools.

Then they announced that they had found the woman who was the woman in the picture, and taking a closer look at that picture, I realized that it was the exact same picture that man drew on his death night.

Then I saw her.

There was no logic, no logic at all as to how she could still have been alive. I did not see her on the Carpathia, nor did I see her in the lifeboats that I could see. Rose DeWitt Bukater had died that night. Or so I thought.

I sometimes wondered whether I had been wrong my entire life, and got cheated by her yet again, for over eighty years.

The End.

Stories