Well I decided to make it (2003).
My very first slash fic posted was (a horrible experience) Dawson's Creek slash story which was more of a PWP, which wasn't too popular. I hide for about a year a so (but still writing but not posting). I then broke out with a little fans when I wrote my second one featuring the guys of 2gether called "Truth or Dare" originally posted at Nifty.
I then went on to create an O-Town slash called "What the Hair, and Everything Else" or "Watch the Hair" for short, which was also had a very small crowd of fans (Also posted at Nifty).
Right in the middle of writing the chapters for "Watch the Hair" I planned to do the sequel called "LMNT" featuring the guys of LMNT; and the prequel of "Watch the Hair" featuring the early days of the Making the Band members (with Paul!) called "Making the Band." Both of the Prequel and Sequel do have atleast a chapter completed but never posted.